7.2 | / 10 |
| Users | 0.0 | |
| Reviewer | 2.0 | |
| Overall | 2.0 |
Four Alaskan sunrises, presented in high definition.
Director: Daniel Zatz, David Conover| Documentary | Uncertain |
| Nature | Uncertain |
Video codec: MPEG-4 AVC
Video resolution: 1080p
Aspect ratio: 1.78:1
Original aspect ratio: 1.78:1
English: Dolby Digital 5.1
English: Dolby Digital 2.0
None
50GB Blu-ray Disc
Single disc (1 BD)
Region A (B, C untested)
| Movie | 3.0 | |
| Video | 1.5 | |
| Audio | 3.5 | |
| Extras | 0.0 | |
| Overall | 2.0 |
Much as I could conjure up a few hundred words that wax poetic about sunrises and the Alaskan wilderness, there's really no better way to approach a Sunrise Earth review than to simply state the obvious: if you're in the market for an ambient television release, Sunrise Earth: Alaska will do. It isn't spectacular (by any means), it doesn't offer anything you can't already get from a dozen other similar titles, it only provides minimal context for the ecosystems and creatures it portends to showcase, and it doesn't boast any compelling content or innovative features that might entertain patrons waiting patiently in the lobby of a travel agency. It amounts to four serene but largely uneventful sunrises presented without anything in the way of pomp or circumstance; a glorified, mid-morning screen saver designed to set the mood in an office or waiting room, and little more.


Unfortunately, Discovery's bit-starved 1080p/AVC-encoded video presentation is hindered by an endless array of issues. Artifacting and macroblocking persist from beginning to end, peppering the otherwise lovely skies with agitated compression anomalies that range from minor to, on occasion, downright irritating. Banding, aliasing, unsightly smearing, thick edge halos and mosquito noise also disrupt the proceedings, albeit to a greater extent. Not that anyone sitting in a waiting room or lobby is likely to notice. Unless you're soaking in the image as you would a traditional nature documentary, brief glimpses at the screen won't leave most viewers disappointed. That being said, detail isn't impressive either. Animal fur is flat and matted, grass and leaves clump together, textures are average at best, and on-screen elements aren't blessed with any crispness or notable clarity; certainly none that might make Sunrise Earth: Alaska something special. Colors are fairly warm and inviting, sure. Black levels are reasonably well-resolved, I'll admit, and contrast is balanced nicely. But any semi-glowing praise ends there. Almost every aspect of the DVD-esque presentation is problematic at best, mangled at worst. Proceed accordingly.

Sunrise Earth: Alaska may not include a lossless audio track, but its 384kbps Dolby Digital 5.1 surround track is easily the highlight of the disc. Lapping waves sing a pre-dawn chorus, light winds rustle grass and trees, bears snort and grunt as they go about their morning routines, small planes drone in the distance, birds call and cry as the sun peeks over the horizon, and Discovery's lossy mix keeps pace every step of the way. LFE output is rarely called upon but subtly supports the quiet soundscape of each sunrise, rear speaker activity is restrained yet suitably playful and atmospheric, and dynamics are decidedly decent throughout. Audiophiles will no doubt bemoan the absence of a lossless audio option but, quite honestly, I suspect very few listeners would be able to discern the actual differences. All in all, Alaska sounds better than it looks, and the subsequent soundfield is more enveloping and immersive than the episodes themselves.

Sunrise Earth: Alaska doesn't feature any extras. There isn't even a "loop" option; just a standard "play all" button that requires users to restart the presentation every time the four sunrises run their course.

Sunrise Earth: Alaska doesn't hold up to home theater scrutiny, and will only serve its purpose in a waiting room or lobby. To be blunt, there's nothing remarkable about this particular ambient television release. The sunrises, locales and wildlife aren't all that captivating or visually arresting, Discovery's video encode is plagued by a string of issues, and a 384kbps Dolby Digital mix stands as the highlight of the disc. There is, of course, Alaska's low pricepoint, which naturally helps, but there are far better ambient releases available in the same price range. Skip this one.




2007

2008
(Still not reliable for this title)

2010

2010

1995

2009

2007

2001

2011-2012

IMAX
1997

2007

2024

2012

2008

BBC
2011

2009

IMAX
2007

The Silent World
1956

IMAX
2001

2008

2015
