Rating summary

Movie		3.5
Video		5.0
Audio		5.0
Extras		4.0
Overall		4.5

Brave 3D Blu-ray Movie Review

"If you had a chance to change your fate, would you?"

Reviewed by Kenneth Brown November 4, 2012

There's no other explanation. Walt Disney Animation Studios and Pixar are having some sort of body-swapping Freaky Friday crisis. Disney Animation proper struggled throughout the Noughts: Atlantis: The Lost Empire, Treasure Planet, Brother Bear, Home on the Range, Chicken Little and Bolt all disappointed. Some were decent but underperformed, some weren't so decent and... underperformed. Pixar, though, dominated the animation market and awards circuit: Monsters, Inc., Finding Nemo, The Incredibles, Ratatouille, Wall-E, Up and Toy Story 3 left audiences and critics clamoring for more instant classics. But with John Lasseter's promotion to chief creative officer of Walt Disney Animation and Pixar Studios, the field began to level. Now it's Disney that's delivering the all-ages crowd pleasers and sharply tuned adventures -- The Princess and the Frog, Tangled, Winnie the Pooh and newcomer Wreck-It Ralph -- and Pixar that's suddenly and inexplicably floundering, first with Cars 2 and more recently with Brave. That's not to say Brave is a bad film. It isn't, not by any means. It's just slimmer, slighter and less satisfying than the Pixar greats of old, leaving one to wonder if the studio that Buzz and Woody built will ever be at the top of its game again.

"I want my freedom!"

Feisty, free-spirited Scottish princess Merida (Kelly Macdonald) is shocked and outraged to learn that her parents, rough-n-tumble King Fergus (Billy Connolly) and prim-and-proper Queen Elinor (Emma Thompson), are hosting a series of games to determine which of three firstborn warriors will win her hand in marriage. Merida wants nothing to do with any of the lads, much less a betrothal, and decides to chart her own course instead, besting (and inadvertently humiliating) all three suitors in archery and claiming her future as hers and hers alone. Her mother is furious, the clan lords (Robbie Coltrane, Craig Ferguson and Kevin McKidd) are insulted, and war is imminent. An encounter with a strange old witch (Julie Walters) complicates things even further. Merida purchases a spell to change her fate but only brings more chaos and confusion to an already chaotic and confusing situation. With just two days to reverse the spell, the young princess has to prevent war, mend her relationship with her mother and help her father destroy a demon bear that has terrorized the kingdom for years.

Much of Brave plays out like a direct-to-video Disney sequel rather than a full-fledged Pixar feature film. The story is simple and formulaic by any standard, the characters are lovable but all-too-expected genre archetypes, the conflict is minimal, there's no real villain to point to (especially with a kindly witch and a mindlessly aggressive bear being the only potential sources of villainy), resolution comes too swiftly and much too easily, and the entire tale lacks scope, scale and raw emotional power. Worse, with all of Scotland and its Highlands at Pixar's disposal, Merida's adventure is limited to the castle and the grounds immediately bordering said castle, and her most perilous journeys are made all the more effortless by glowing will-o'-the-wisps, which cut down on pesky travel time by pointing the princess in whatever direction she has to go. It's also one of the animation studio's shortest films, making it more of a bite-sized appetizer than a four-course meal. It's a shame too. So much of Brave is pure Pixar -- the casting, the voice acting, the memorable heroes and supporting players, the clever comedy, the heart and the breathtaking, oh-so-extraordinary animation -- that I found myself falling for the film, even though I knew it wasn't up to par. It didn't take long to realize, though, that I was falling in love with individual bits and pieces, not the whole.

I can't say the same for the other six kids in the room -- three boys and three girls, ages three through ten -- who couldn't pry their eyes off the screen, keep their jaws off the floor, or contain their laughs, gasps and cheers. I've made it a habit, whenever possible, of viewing critically divisive family fare with my son and our friends' caravan of children, and it certainly has an effect on one's perspective. Brave's biggest failing is that it won't sustain adults as readily as it will their kids, which begs two questions: who are these films for, and should they always be judged on their ability to reach audiences of all ages? Is Pixar not allowed to make kiddie fare? Does a movie about learning humility have to resonate with everyone in the room? Haven't we already had our day? Our films, our classics, our own adventures to pore over and cherish? Can't our kids have their own?

It's easy to dismiss any animated movie, especially one from a studio with so many overwhelming successes. And it's easy to dismiss Brave. It isn't as moving, awe-inspiring, invigorating, intelligent or sweeping as Pixar's best. But it also has valuable things to offer those who won't notice how familiar it all feels, who won't see its squandered potential, or care about its small-scale ambitions. A lesson in respect, honor and love. A tale of a family capable of weathering the worst storms. An adventure built on the notion that youthful impulse and tradition aren't mutually exclusive, and the idea that one is inadequate without the other. A magnificently animated entry in a master animation studio's catalog. Lesser Pixar film or no, Brave is all these things, and children, especially little girls, will adore everything it has to give.

Brave 3D Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality 

Even when Brave left me firmly planted in my home theater, Pixar's stunning animation swept me away to lush highlands and misty forests unknown. Thankfully, Disney's 1080p/MVC-encoded video presentation is just as gorgeous, bringing Merida's world to breathtaking life and, in some ways, making her somewhat humble adventure grander and more satisfying on Blu-ray than it was on the big screen. The film's palette is nothing short of magical, with lavish reds, fiery oranges, lovely greens, disarming earthtones, bright blues and inky blacks, all delivered via perfect color and impeccable contrast. There isn't a hue off kilter, or a hair out of place for that matter. Detail is magnificent, capturing every nuance the animators saw fit to incorporate into their already jaw-dropping animation. Tattered kilt seams, tight tartan patterns, pinpoint freckles, scraggly beards, errant whiskers, shaggy manes, scuffed armor, knicked blades, matted fur, the smallest droplets of water, thinnest blades of grass, tiniest leafs on distant trees... nothing misses the mark. Edges are sharp and clean, fine textures are terrificly resolved, and the image is as pristine as they come. Moreover, I didn't notice any instances of macroblocking, aliasing, noise or other encoding eyesores, and banding was in incredibly short supply. (Almost to the point of declaring the presentation band-free, although I'd have to pore over the film a few more times to be sure.)

Brave's 3D experience doesn't disappoint either, and might just be the animated 3D presentation of the year. Depth is outstanding, with rolling hills and deep woods that retreat to the horizon, storms that extend into the distance, old ruins that loom overhead and wrap around our feisty heroine, vast castle halls and cramped torch-lit passageways create a convincing sense of space and scale, and every last trip beyond the castle walls is one filled with awe. Dimensionality follows suit, lending volume and free-spiritedness to Merida's untamed locks of hair, intimidating mass to Mor'Du's hulking frame, and a pleasing realism to the roundness of faces, the curve of hands and the delicate or not-so-delicate features of the animated characters. There also isn't any 3D-born aliasing or anomalies of note, and filmfans with displays prone to ghosting will only get hung up on a few shots (arrows and spears are a touch problematic, especially in wide shots of the Highland Games and scenes in which the clans are clamoring for war). Of course, none of that has anything to do with the technical quality of the encode and 3D experience, which remains on point throughout. Ultimately, Brave's 2D and 3D presentations are easily two of the year's best.

Brave 3D Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality 

As if a masterclass video presentation wasn't enough, along comes Brave's Dolby TrueHD 7.1 surround track, which is quite simply one of Disney's best lossless mixes of the year. Even in the film's opening minutes, the quality of the experience becomes abundantly clear. The kindly invitations of an almost inaudible will-o'-the-wisp, the wind rustling the tops of the trees, the grass crunching beneath Merida's feet, the sudden deafening roar of a demon intruder, the weight of the girl's father charging into battle. There's little doubt that Brave's sonic prowess will be a show-stopper. It only gets better from there too as Merida strikes out beyond the castle grounds, into the wild wood and farther. The LFE channel, bold and boisterous as ever, remains undeterred and unhindered throughout, injecting heft and presence into any and every element that requires even the least bit of its support. The rear speakers, meanwhile, create a truly immersive soundfield that's more enveloping and involving than most I've heard. The forests alone are a directional wonderland, Dun Broch castle even more so. Effects careen around the room with precision and startling accuracy, pans are devilishly smooth and dynamics are impeccable. All in all, Brave sounds as good as it looks. Together, the film's video and audio presentations are so sublime that it's almost overwhelming. And I don't say that lightly.

Brave 3D Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras 

• Audio Commentary (Disc 1): Director Mark Andrews, co-director Steve Purcell, story supervisor Brian Larsen and editor Nick Smith waste little time, thoughtfully and extensively dissecting the film shot by shot, scene by scene, hitting on everything from the film's voice casting to its performances, story development, character designs, world and locations, animation strides and challenges, score and songs, and more. It's a terrific commentary, even if Andrews dominates the conversation a bit too much at times.
• Short Films (Disc 1, HD, 14 minutes): In La Luna, a boy, his father and his grandfather row out into the middle of the ocean to watch the moon rise and tend to pressing responsibilities. In The Legend of Mor'Du, Brave's witch reveals the origin of Mor'Du the Demon Bear. Unfortunately, while La Luna is presented via a Dolby TrueHD 7.1 surround track, Mor'Du is presented with a 640kbps Dolby Digital 5.1 mix.
• Behind the Scenes (Disc 1, HD, 50 minutes): Eight behind-the-scenes featurettes are available on the feature film disc. "Brave Old World" follows the Pixar team on a research trip to Scotland. "Merida & Elinor" digs into the lead female characters with the voice cast, designers and animators. "Bears" should be even more self-explanatory to those who've seen the film. "Brawl in the Hall" looks at the development and animation of the comedic clash of the clans. "Wonder Moss" delves into the complex mathematical creation of the movie's background moss, something most people will take for granted. "Magic" dissects Brave's fairy tale roots and magical elements. "Clan Pixar" introduces the artists and animators, touching on their daunting task and intense efforts. And "Once Upon a Scene" offers a glimpse into various versions of Brave's opening, key scenes and story.
• Extended Scenes (Disc 1, HD, 13 minutes): Four extended scenes, each with a helpful pop-up icon that identifies the bits and pieces that were cut from the final edit. Scenes include "Meet the Lords," "Triplets' Distraction," "The Ruins" and "Blockade." ("Blockade," however, was never fully completed and is presented in part with pre-viz animatics.)
• Promotional Pieces (Disc 2, HD, 14 minutes): Some pieces in this collection could have easily been billed as deleted scenes and snippets -- "Feast Your Eyes Montage (Wee Bits of Animation)," "Relics," "Clan Dun Broch," "Launch" and "Flying Guts Theater" -- while other pieces are simply trailers from the US, UK and Japan.
• Fergus & Mor'Du: An Alternate Opening (Disc 2, HD, 3 minutes): A deleted intro -- Fergus, alone and outmatched, loses his leg to Mor'Du in a snowy forest -- assembled from animation at various stages in its production.
• Fallen Warriors (Disc 2, HD, 2 minutes): A montage of shots that made it all the way through to the final stages of animation only to be lopped off during the last edit of the film.
• Dirty Hairy People (Disc 2, HD, 4 minutes): The animators honor Scotland and the time period with dirt, hair, dirty hair, grime, mud, bad teeth, tattered clothing and other subtle touches.
• It is English... Sort Of (Disc 2, HD, 4 minutes): Scottish slang, Pixar style.
• Angus (Disc 2, HD, 3 minutes): Designing and animating Merida's horse, Angus.
• The Tapestry (Disc 2, HD, 4 minutes): Merida's family tapestry and its role in the film.
• Art Galleries (Disc 2, HD): "Characters," "Color Keys," "Development Art," "Environments" and "Graphics."

Brave 3D Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation 

Regardless of how you respond to Brave -- by most every account a lesser entry in the Pixar canon that still manages to outclass most animated films on the market -- its Blu-ray release will go down as one of the best of 2012. Its video presentation is stunning, its 3D experience equally so, its Dolby TrueHD 7.1 surround track is pitch perfect, and its supplemental package features a generous spread of extras that stretches across two Blu-ray discs. Is the film as wondrous as its BD release? Sadly no. Even so, children will be delighted with Brave's magical adventure, however slight it may be by Pixar standards.