Beauty and the Beast 3D Blu-ray Movie

Rating summary

Movie		4.5
Video		5.0
Audio		5.0
Extras		4.5
Overall		5.0

Beauty and the Beast 3D Blu-ray Movie Review

Be our guest! Be our guest! Put our 3D to the test!

Reviewed by Kenneth Brown September 27, 2011

What makes an animated classic... well, classic? Is it the film's longevity? Its ability to speak to new generations of moviegoers? Its artistry? Animation? Story? Characters? Music? Family appeal? Profit margins and merchandising horsepower? Or is it something simpler? Something purer... something indescribable that stirs deep within the soul and whispers, "this, dear boy, is a bona fide classic." Beauty and the Beast has long been one of Disney's animated crown jewels, and for good reason. Critics have praised its hand-drawn grace, haunting love story and stirring music. It was nominated for six Academy Awards, and remains the first of two animated films to be nominated for Best Picture, the Academy's highest honor. Veteran filmfans have celebrated its effortless storytelling, absorbing fairy-tale aesthetic and enduring sincerity. And children of all ages have sat in stillness, eyes wide and mouths slightly agape, soaking in every rousing song, flourish of color and intense encounter it has to offer. But more than anything, Beauty and the Beast continues to resonate some twenty years after its debut, an accomplishment many modern animated marvels struggle and fail to attain.

Breathtaking 3D video awaits...

More than an adaptation of the timeless fairy tale of the same name, Beauty and the Beast harkens back to the Disney films of old, yet strikes the delicate balance between hallowed tradition and our modern sensibilities. While Belle (voiced by Paige O'Hara) has since been inducted into Disney's "Princess" lineup, she isn't a pampered royal, a damsel in distress or a doting queen-in-waiting. But she also isn't a product of this age, a point of potential contention directors Gary Trousdale and Kirk Wise handle with sure-handed confidence. Under their careful guidance, Belle is strong-willed but vulnerable, independent yet dutiful, a kind and gentle girl but a smart and savvy survivalist, a lovelorn romantic and a woman who doesn't need a prince to define, or worse, rescue her. It's a fine line in each case, sure, but one the filmmakers nimbly traverse without pitching too far to either extreme. The Beast (Robby Benson), meanwhile, is as tragic a figure as Disney has ever produced. Lonely and embittered, Disney's cursed prince isn't the reclusive sweetheart-in-mourning newcomers might expect. Belle has to chisel through years of deep-seated hatred and festering anger to excavate the man at the heart of the creature, and their budding love story is more believable and impactful for it. Had the Beast simply been portrayed as a misunderstood monstrosity, their surprisingly complex emotional relationship would seem trite and contrived. Like Belle, we're asked to unearth the humanity in a walking nightmare, to evaluate his true character and motives, and question his every action; a process that makes our emerging affection for him all the more powerful.

The Beast's massive castle and its charming denizens are brilliantly conceived as well. Normally, I'd scoff at dancing dishware and chatty candelabras. Couldn't think of a way to work in talking animals, could you? Had to concoct a go-to source of exposition, right? Needed a few lively musical numbers, did ya? But again, Trousdale, Wise and their team succeed where most others would not. The castle itself is nothing short of a stonewall extension of the Beast: dark and sinister at first glance, teeming with warmth within. It evolves as steadily and subtly as he does, revealing itself as carefully and cautiously as Belle's would-be suitor. Elsewhere, his faithful servants, the aforementioned dishware, emerge as the fading light of the Beast's humanity, not to mention smartly employed and much-needed sources of comic relief, character development and light-heartedness. While the Beast sulks in torment, candelabra and resident maître d' Lumiere (Jerry Orbach), clock and loyalist Cogsworth (David Ogden Stiers), maternal teapot Mrs. Potts (Angela Lansbury) and young teacup Chip (Bradley Michael Pierce) embrace their fates with a bit more hopefulness; saddened by their ordeal, but determined to make the best of it. They stand (or waddle as it were) in direct contrast to their master, bridging the communication gap between Belle and the Beast, nurturing their trust and furthering their relationship. As the seasons pass, their role deepens and expands, and their exuberance injects welcome zest into a fairy tale that might otherwise have none.

But Beauty and the Beast is more than the sum of its characters, story and themes. Every hand-drawn frame, every hand-painted background and, yes, even the CG-born environments that house the film's most complicated shots exude the passion of the incredibly talented artists who devoted their all to bringing Disney's selfless heroine and sullen monstrosity to animated life. In an age of computer-generated flawlessness, it's actually refreshing to revisit a classic in which lines aren't always razor-sharp and proportions aren't always perfect. Don't get me wrong, CG animation can be extremely impressive in its own right -- Pixar is proof positive of that -- but there's something special to be said for the hand-crafted handiwork of men and women who rely solely on pencils and brushes rather than keystrokes and mouse clicks. Ominous forests breathe the breath of the night winds, dancing silverware tumbles and spills across the screen, curtains billow, dresses flutter in the breeze, fur ripples as the Beast charges... it's all breathtaking, particularly when you consider how much of the film was drawn by hand. Alan Menken's musical score and the late Howard Ashman's lyrics are just as engrossing, if not more so. Ashman's verses continually dig beneath the surface, Menken's melodies tell fairy tales all their own and their songs are as fitting and organic as those of any golden-age Disney masterpiece. Beauty and the Beast is as much an aural masterwork as it is a visual wonder, and it doesn't surprise me in the least that the film earned the nominations and awards it did. I can't imagine how difficult it must be to weave such an intricate animated tapestry, and yet Trousdale and Wise make it all look effortless.

Only Gaston (Richard White), Beauty and the Beast's arrogant antagonist, is a distraction. Built from the ground up to be an obnoxious, repellent, loathsome villain, Gaston is... um, an obnoxious, repellent and loathsome addition to the proceedings. Trousdale and Wise clearly wanted to set the hunter's bar nice and low, but he's the only obvious, heavy-handed element in their exceedingly nuanced repertoire. A twirlable mustache and a girl tied to railroad tracks are about the only things that would make his short-sighted baddie any more Old Hollywood. Maleficent, Shere Khan, Ursala, Jafar, Hades, Scar, Clayton: all dastardly villains, all completely unredeemable. But there's a more sinister evil lurking behind the cold exterior of each one; an innate sinfulness driven by warped desire and frightening intelligence. Gaston is merely a jealous, barbarous brute and his scenes suffer accordingly. Thankfully, Beauty and the Beast's bad-apple Bad Apple doesn't spoil the bunch. Trousdale and Wise's adaptation is as timeless a tale as its well-known song suggests, and anyone -- single or married, parent or otherwise -- with any appreciation for beautiful animation, arresting music and gripping storytelling should add this must-own 5-disc Blu-ray release to their collection.

Beauty and the Beast 3D Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality 

As stunning as the Blu-ray release of The Lion King 3D may be, it's Beauty and the Beast 3D that boasts the most complete and consistent 3D conversion, as well as the more technically sound 1080p/MVC-encoded 3D presentation. (If only be an extremely small margin.) Once again, I was taken by the intuitive quality of Beauty and the Beast's 3D transformation; as if the film were created with a future conversion in mind. Trees sweep past the foreground as forests and mountains plunge into the distance, the houses and carts lining the streets in Belle's picturesque French village retreat into the background while anxious villagers all but step out of the screen, the Beast's servants spin and leap through a startlingly three-dimensional castle, its hallways and chambers exhibit tremendous depth, and unforgettable scenes like the Belle and Beast's ballroom dance are as eye-popping and engrossing as any true fan of the film could hope for. The cinematic shots that rely on CG are particularly striking and, perhaps for the first time, the CG doesn't seem slightly out of sorts. It lovingly cradles the hand-drawn characters, lifting them up and out without drawing unwanted attention to itself. It's as if all of the various elements of Disney's 1991 classic have finally come together into one spectacular whole. I'll even go so far as to say that Disney's conversion and subsequent presentation are so brilliantly executed, the 3D so carefully implemented, that the majesty of the resulting image will convert many a skeptic and 3D holdout.

There aren't very many issues to speak of either. A hint of exceedingly minor ghosting is present (mainly during the "Be Our Guest" song-n-dance sequence), a bit of faint aliasing accompanies a handful of quick pans, and some negligible blink-and-you'll-miss-it banding appears in a pair of passing shots. However, and this is a crucial however, the oh-so-brief and fleeting hiccups that occur simply don't register. If I weren't scanning the image with an icy heart and a critical eye, I doubt I would have even noticed. My wife certainly didn't, and she's as quick on the draw as I am when it comes to random problems and split-second anomalies, no matter how trivial they may be. Beauty and the Beast 3D looks that good. Belle and her new friends have a roundness, a fullness to them that makes them so much more than flat characters springing to attention in a pop-up book. The same could be said of the Beast's castle, its grand halls, the surrounding forests and Belle's idyllic cottage; there's a volume and presence to each one that goes beyond mere depth to create the illusion of relatively real space and tangible environments. No small feat considering we're dealing with a hand-drawn animated feature. By its very nature, traditional animation relies on stacking elements one on top of the other and tricking the eye to reasonably convincing ends. But Beauty and the Beast's conversion accomplishes the seemingly impossible. It doesn't merely separate the elements into stacked plains, it lends each one its own mass and dimensionality. It's difficult to describe, honestly, but it's easy on the eyes and even easier to enjoy.

Artifacting, ringing, compression issues, print damage, restoration oddities, aberrant noise, flickering... nothing slithers into view that would warrant even a half-point reduction in score. And, lest we forget the untold beauty and immeasurable richness of the film's storybook palette, the film itself has never looked more vibrant, more alive. The silky sheen of a golden gown, the ethereal glow of an enchanted rose, the foreboding shadows of a moonlit forest, the warmth of an ornate ballroom, the startling flash of lightning; every splash of color, every vivid primary, every hearthy hue, every rosy cheeked face, earthy tuft of earthy fur and billowing cloak is immaculate. Flawless even. And detail? Not to lose myself to the siren call of hyperbole, but oh, the detail. The fine textures and brush strokes that lend the film's hand-painted backgrounds such personality have been impeccably rendered, the tiniest imperfections in the animators' lineart have been preserved and reproduced with care, and every nuance and subtlety is sharper, more refined and ultimately more satisfying than ever before. As remastered catalog titles go, I couldn't be happier. As 3D conversions go, I couldn't be more impressed. As 3D Blu-ray releases go, they don't get much better than Beauty and the Beast 3D.

Beauty and the Beast 3D Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality 

Perfection is a lofty ideal and an even loftier pursuit. Be that as it may, Beauty and the Beast's invigorating, wholly enveloping DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 surround track achieves sonic perfection. Dialogue doesn't squat in the center channel, it steps out into the center of the soundfield and plays with any effects and ambience in the fray. Voices are strong and sturdy, shouts and whispers are clear and stable, and every chiming clock, flickering flame, tinkering teapot and clinking dishware is masterfully prioritized. Moreover, LFE output is bold and weighty, yet agile and precise; the rear speakers are bursting with activity, transforming an already immersive experience into an absorbing one; directionality is aggressive, separation is excellent and pans are startlingly smooth; and dynamics make this one of Disney's most memorable catalog mixes. Close your eyes and listen as Alan Menken's music floods the soundstage. Note the clarity of Howard Ashman's lyrics, the swan song of each passing note and the grace of every run and crescendo. Now listen to the Beast's gruff growl as it tears through the silence of his castle, the soft tip-tap of Belle's footsteps, the rabble-rabble-rabble of an angry mob and the crack of thunder high above. It isn't often that an AV presentation wraps you in its arms and invites you into the world of a film, but Beauty and the Beast's marvelous DTS-HD monster does just that.

Beauty and the Beast 3D Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras 

Be our guest, indeed. Disney treats children of all ages to nothing less than a supplemental feast. No, the 5-disc 3D edition doesn't bring anything new to the table, but with multiple versions of the film, a Picture-in-Picture storyreel presentation, an excellent filmmakers audio commentary, a sing-along track, a fantastic three-hour documentary, an hour of previously released material, more than an hour of new featurettes and deleted scenes, a pair of interactive games it hardly matters. There's so much here that it's almost overwhelming. In an even classier move, Disney has spread all of the special features across two BD-50 discs, meaning both versions of the film are given plenty of room to breathe. Oh, did I mention the vast majority of the content is presented in high definition?

• Special Extended Edition: A 92-minute "Special Extended Edition" joins the film's 85-minute theatrical cut.
• Storyreel Picture-in-Picture Experience: Fans can view the theatrical cut alongside the filmmakers' original storyreel, an incredibly early version of the film that features rough animation, hand-drawn storyboards and other preproduction artwork.
• Audio Commentary: Producer Don Hahn and co-directors Kirk Wise and Gary Trousdale discuss the Special Extended Edition of Beauty and the Beast and waste little time doing so. The trio dissect the story and characters, the animation techniques utilized throughout the film, its place in Disney history, the dialogue and songs, casting and the voice recording sessions, the challenges they faced during its long and complex production and much, much more. It's a thoroughly engaging and informative track that should not be missed.
• Sing Along Track: The Special Extended cut even offers a text-based "Sing Along Mode" for anyone interested in belting out a Disney tune or two in the privacy of their own home.
• Fast Play: Looking for yet another way to watch Beauty and the Beast? In a fit of overkill, the BD wizards at Disney have also devised a "Fast Play Mode" that allows users to customize and automate their viewing experience based on time and specific interests. It's rather extraneous, but I'm sure someone will enjoy it. Don't like it? Move along then, there's plenty of other content on tap.
• Beyond Beauty (HD, 157 minutes): An interactive, feature-length behind-the-scenes documentary teeming with worthwhile bonus content all its own (simply press "enter" when the on-screen icons appear to extend the experience further). A handy pop-up menu even keeps track of which sub-featurettes and branching segments you have and haven't watched, making the whole of the documentary as effortless as it is extensive.
• Deleted Scenes (HD, 28 minutes): Former Walt Disney Studios chairman Peter Schneider introduces a sprawling alternate opening (pieced together from a studio storyreel created before the official voice actors were cast) and story supervisor Roger Allers does the same for a deleted scene (composed of storyboards) involving Belle's exploration of the Beast's library.
• Classic DVD Bonus Features (SD, 62 minutes): The previously released DVD's high quality materials are included as well, albeit in standard definition. "The Story Behind the Story" digs into seven separate Disney films; Hahn presides over an early presentation reel and an alternate version of "Be Our Guest;" Menken unveils an alternate score for "The Transformation;" Hahn and Menken introduce "Human Again," a deleted song comprised of storyboards; a collection of "Animation Tests, Roughs & Clean-Ups" proves to be an all-too-short treat; a "Camera Move Test" provides a glimpse at the virtual sets created for the film's most complex shots; a "Music Video" features Celine Dion performing "Beauty and the Beast;" and a series of trailers and TV spots will satisfy completists.
• Composing a Classic (HD, 20 minutes): Composer Alan Menken, music agent and Disney historian Richard Kraft, and producer Don Hahn chat at length about the film's rousing songs and musical score, as well as the art of furthering a story through music.
• Broadway Beginnings (HD, 13 minutes): A string of name-that-face celebrities, production team members and stage actors wax poetic about the Broadway adaptation of the film.
• Music Video (HD, 3 minutes): Jordin Sparks performs "Beauty and the Beast."
• Bonjour - Who Is This? (HD): An interactive game for 2-8 players that, strangely enough, requires each player to use either their home or cell phone. Frankly, I can't imagine anyone going to so much trouble for so little. But I'm sure someone out there will try to assemble their friends to play.
• Enchanted Musical Challenge (HD): A more accessible game in which players have to search the Beast's castle and answer trivia questions to find four of Belle's friends.
• Sneak Peeks (HD, 15 minutes): Among the disc's Blu-ray sneak peeks? Toy Story 3, The Lion King, Alice in Wonderland: Special 60th Anniversary Edition (coming in 2011), Dumbo, A Christmas Carol, Tangled Bambi, Fantasia and Fantasia 2000.
• Screen Saver, Adaptive Menus and BD-Live Functionality: A screen saver, another smartly designed Disney Smart Menu and a BD-Live Access Portal round out the supplemental package.

Beauty and the Beast 3D Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation 

Disney has done it again. The Blu-ray edition of Beauty and the Beast was already amazing; the 5-disc release of Beauty and the Beast 3D is nothing short of astonishing. Like its 2010 predecessor, it stands as both a must-have release and a solid contender for the studio's best Blu-ray release of the year. Yes, even though it's arguably a mere re-issue of sorts. Fans will be treated to three full versions of the classic animated film, two reference-level video transfers, an immersive 3D experience, a monstrous DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 surround track, and hours upon hours of special features including a Picture-in-Picture storyreel presentation, a filmmakers audio commentary, a three-hour branching documentary and much, much more. Without hesitation or clarification, Beauty and the Beast 3D earns my unabashed recommendation.