7 | / 10 |
Users | 4.2 | |
Reviewer | 4.5 | |
Overall | 4.3 |
Ebenezer Scrooge begins the Christmas holiday with his usual miserly contempt, barking at his faithful clerk and his cheery nephew. But when the ghosts of Christmas Past, Present and Yet to Come take him on an eye-opening journey revealing truths Old Scrooge is reluctant to face, he must open his heart to undo years of ill will before it's too late.
Starring: Jim Carrey, Gary Oldman, Colin Firth, Bob Hoskins, Robin WrightFamily | 100% |
Animation | 76% |
Adventure | 75% |
Fantasy | 62% |
Holiday | 19% |
Period | 3% |
Supernatural | 1% |
Video codec: MPEG-4 MVC
Video resolution: 1080p
Aspect ratio: 2.40:1
Original aspect ratio: 2.39:1
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 (48kHz, 24-bit)
French: Dolby Digital 5.1 (640 kbps)
Spanish: Dolby Digital 5.1 (640 kbps)
English SDH, French, Spanish
50GB Blu-ray Disc
Four-disc set (2 BDs, 2 DVDs)
Digital copy (on disc)
DVD copy
Bonus View (PiP)
Blu-ray 3D
Slipcover in original pressing
Region free
Movie | 4.5 | |
Video | 4.5 | |
Audio | 4.5 | |
Extras | 3.5 | |
Overall | 4.5 |
God bless us every one!
"Charles" and "Dickens" may be two of the most feared words in high schools around the world. The A Tale of Two Cities, Oliver
Twist, and Great Expectations author has made many an English class the worst of times for students who find themselves
struggling to get through his verbose prose and understand the finer points of his stories that lie beyond chaotic revolution and orphan boys.
Behind the many pages and small print lies timeless treasures
of literature that prove far, far better than the sum of their Cliffs Notes. Vividly-drawn characters, handsomely-realized worlds, and smartly-penned
lyricisms are all ever-present companions on every page, and they're the defining attributes of one the author's greatest stories ever told and a
seminal Holiday favorite, A Christmas Carol. First published in December of 1843, the story has become a staple of the Christmas season,
it's tale of the protagonist/antagonist Ebenezer Scrooge a treasure trove of heart and spirit that sees a man transformed not only out of fear but by
the very goodness that lies within him, long since dormant but nevertheless awaiting an opportunity to erase decades of "bah! humbug!" that came
to define a man and shape the Christmases of those unfortunate enough to be within earshot of his stilted views of that most cherished of holidays.
2009's A Christmas Carol, directed by Robert Zemeckis (The Polar Express), retells the story with a bountiful display of new
technology whilst retaining the same old-world charm that's made Dickens' tale a giant amongst its peers, even more than 150 years after its first
publication.
Yup, even dead I still look great on Blu-ray and in 3D.
3D Transfer
Rating: 4.5/5
A Christmas Carol 3D features a wonderful full HD 3D Blu-ray presentation that's pushed its way towards the top of the currently-available 3D
titles. The picture satisfies on several levels, not the least of which is its faultless detailing. Although much of the film takes place in darkened or
shadowy locales, black crush is never a problem, and fine details are free to strut their stuff with a precision that's undeniably Blu-ray. Few, if any,
transfers have achieved this level of excellence in terms of sheer detailing; whether Ebenezer Scrooge's heavily wrinkled skin, the texture of an old
leather chair that's nestled the old curmudgeon by his fireplace for what had probably been decades, the impeccable "reach-out-and-touch-it" surface
of
various brick façades, or even the finest ridges on a sheet of paper seen in one extreme close-up shot early in the film, there's no shortage of
immaculate detailing to be seen throughout the film. Bright and cheery colors are limited to a few scenes; most of the film works through shades of
gray, white, brown, and, of course, the overlying darkness that permeates much of the experience, but the film's several more front-and-center colors
--
particularly the blue shading of the ghost of Scrooge's old business associate Jacob Marley -- stand out nicely and evenly, particularly when seen
against
dark backgrounds or during those few brighter shots that immediately stand apart from the film's generally bleak visual structure. The image appears
free of any troublesome anomalies, save for very light banding seen around the glow atop the Ghost of Christmas Past. This 3D transfer's general
attributes impress a great deal, and they're matched by the marvelous and practically faultless accompanying 3D elements.
Despite a few instances of "ghosting" or "crosstalk" that sees objects outlined by a transparent mirror image of themselves, a phenomena that has in
some
way
and to some varying degree plagued most every 3D Blu-ray release to date, A Christmas Carol 3D delivers an otherwise seamless and
generally
breathtaking 3D image. The ghosting issues are apparent every now and then -- beginning with a few red berries adorning a green Christmas wreath
and
appearing intermittently throughout the film with only one or two instances where the effect is even moderately severe -- but never prove a
distraction
to the overall 3D presentation. Better yet, the picture never breaks down during several fast-motion sequences where much of the screen is in a
state of flux; the 3D imagery holds form and delivers a consistently glorious image, no matter whether the camera is lingering on an extended
steady shot or covering a fast-paced flyover of the city. The image delivers plenty of perceptible depth as the camera traverses down a narrow London
street
and as it passes
overheard in a rooftop-grazing flyover sequence early in the film. Locales both interior and exterior seem to stretch on to their physical limits, be
they across a room or across town. Several objects seem to protrude from the screen, particularly seen when characters point towards the camera,
their fingers and arms seemingly extending beyond the panel and into the living room. Disney's disc also handles snowflakes extraordinarily well; they
seem to float on by at various distances and, in some cases, on past the screen. The transfer's best attribute, however, comes in the way it handles
the ghost of old man Marley; it would seem a great challenge for 3D to give dimension to a deliberately transparent entity, and that's exactly what it
does. The result is what is probably the best and most interesting imagery yet found on a 3D release, and there's nary a hint of any sort of problem
associated with it. Disney's 3D transfer is a thing of beauty and is currently the definitive wide-release Blu-ray 3D transfer.
Please note that 2D playback on this 3D disc has been disabled; to see the 2D image, viewers are forced to play the included 2D-only Blu-ray disc.
2D Transfer
Rating: 5/5
Disney's 2D transfer is every bit as amazing as the accompanying 3D image. The higher score is in no way related to the 3D transfer; it's judged on
its own merits and considering the 2D image has less criteria to analyze, it is absent those few bugaboos that dragged down the 3D score by the
slightest of margins. This standard 2D image is exemplary from start to finish. Although much of the film is cold, gray, and dark, fine details abound,
showing off the incredible work of the film's digital artists who have created characters and locations that look remarkably real, right down to the finest
nuances in faces that show freckles, wrinkles, pores, and even rosy red cheeks that are a result of the chilled London air. London exteriors and the
various interiors seen throughout the film also deliver impeccable texturing on brick façades and wooden accents, whether those cheery and snowy
outdoor scenes or the palest of interiors lit only by candles inside and the faint glow of moonlight out the window. Colors are fantastic; they're heavily
affected by the presence or absence of light, but the transfer handles every hue -- whether pale skin, gray nighttime exteriors, the orange and red
glow of a burning fire, the mahogany walls and doors of Scrooge's home, or the bright blue/green glow of the ghost of Scrooge's deceased partner --
with incredible precision. Blacks are impeccably true and perfectly balanced in every scene. Depth is quite strong, too, though obviously limited by the
2D elements and not nearly as mesmerizing as what's to be seen on the 3D transfer, but nevertheless exquisite for a traditional image. Of course,
the image is immaculately clean and sharp, no doubt a perfect copy straight off the hard drive. Banding is kept to a bare minimum, and there are no
other anomalies to report. A Christmas Carol is sheer digital bliss and quite possibly the year's finest transfer.
A Christmas Carol 3D boasts a DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtrack that's up to the challenge of supporting the incredible 3D visuals. The track excels at both ends of the sonic extreme, whether offering pinpoint and hushed elements or the loudest of effects and music. The film offers up a nice mixture of both, but it's those quieter moments and dialogue-driven scenes that seem a bit more dominant. Dialogue is handled effortlessly by the center channel, and the sides and surrounds chip in with plenty of ambience, particularly in those moments where Scrooge's old house creaks and cracks and audibly shows its age. Directional effects are expertly handled, too; as Scrooge walks towards a group of carolers in one early scene, their song seems to slowly inch from left to center as he approaches. It's a subtle but very nicely done effect that adds a great deal of realism and sonic dimension to the track, both of which make for fine accompaniments to the astounding 3D visuals. The entire soundstage supports plenty of aggressive music and more pronounced sound effects, such as a cacophony of ringing bells and blaring clocks, backed up by creaking doors, creepy footsteps, and clanky chains dragging across an old wooden floor. The back channels offer several strong echoing effects throughout, notably as the Ghost of Christmas Present's voice bounces around the listening area. Heavier sound effects are supported by a fair bit of tight and balanced bass. A Christmas Carol's lossless soundtrack is exceptional; it's strong in every area but it's not likely to go down as one of the year's most memorable. Nevertheless, fans should be thrilled with Disney's efforts; the studio hasn't forgotten about the sound on this release that's sure to be dominated by its 3D visuals.
Disney's A Christmas Carol features a nice array of extra material, the package headlined by Behind the Carol: The Full Motion Capture
Experience (1080p, 1:35:48). This is a picture-in-picture supplement that offers viewers the opportunity to watch A Christmas Carol
both in its finished version
and the on-stage motion capture processes and performances. This amazing supplement allows for a comparison between the physical human
performances
and the final digital rendering; it's a novel experience to be sure and a fascinating study in how modern technology is capable of so finely capturing the
performances, both the large, sweeping gestures and movements and the most subtle of nuances -- eye raises, wrinkles in foreheads, and other
slight movements that tell a story, build a character, and sell a scene as much so, if not more than, the more generalized efforts -- alike that make up
the
whole of the performances behind A Christmas Carol. Viewers have the option of watching either the finished picture with the motion
capture efforts in a small secondary window, or expand the motion capture footage to fill the screen and remove the finished product. Also included is
a strong and invariably engaging commentary track with Director Robert Zemeckis who passionately tells the story of the motion capture process
behind the movie and touts it as the next great technology. He also fills in plenty of gaps and shares the other benefits of the working in both the
physical and digital realms. The Full Motion Capture Experience is best enjoyed with the commentary track turned on as Zemeckis offers
scene-specific insights that pertain to both the film and the motion capture process, and both together are
almost worth the price of this set alone.
Capturing Dickens: A Novel Retelling (1080p, 14:43) is a well-produced and slightly humorous piece that offers an interesting look at why this
cinematic telling of the story best captures the spirit of Charles Dickens' tale while paying special attention to the process of recording the actors'
work via motion capture technology. Countdown to Christmas Interactive Calendar (1080p) allows users to count down the days until
Christmas by selecting numbers from one through twenty-five, but jumping ahead in the process will result in a verbal wrist-slapping by Ebenezer
Scrooge. Next is On Set with Sammi (1080p, 1:52), a brief piece that follows young Actress Sammi Hanratty's experiences on the set of
A Christmas Carol. Also included are two extras that aren't film-specific. Discover Blu-ray 3D with Timon & Pumbaa (1080p, 4:23) is
an extended advertisement for Blu-ray 3D technology, hosted by the two characters from The Lion King. Learn How to Take Your Movies
on the Go (1080p, 1:04) touts the benefits of digital copy. The standalone 3D disc contains two extras: Mr. Scrooge's Wild Ride (1080p,
2:33, full HD 3D), a brief featurette on the making of the film; and
Disney Blu-ray 3D Sneak
Peek (1080p, 1:25, full HD 3D), an ad for upcoming Disney 3D Blu-ray titles, including Bolt, A Christmas Carol, Alice in Wonderland, Tron Legacy, and A Nightmare Before
Christmas. Disney's four-disc set also features DVD and digital copies of the film.
Robert Zemeckis' motion capture/CGI take on A Christmas Carol doesn't shed any new light on the story; nevertheless, audiences won't think of Ebenezer Scrooge, his family and colleagues, old London, or the three Christmas ghosts in quite the same way again. A Christmas Carol perfectly captures the traditional look, feel, and appeal of Charles Dickens' timeless classic while still managing to spruce it up for the 21st century with a dazzling computer-aided visual scheme that has to be seen to be believed. Visually, A Christmas Carol seems far more seamless than even Zemeckis' own The Polar Express and Beowulf. That, combined with the honest and heartwarming adherence to the story's themes and principles, makes this a burgeoning new holiday classic suitable for the entire family. Disney's 3D Blu-ray release of A Christmas Carol features the best overall Blu-ray 3D experience yet. Combining a fantastic full HD 3D transfer, an equally strong lossless soundtrack, and several extras -- including the amazing commentary/picture-in-picture combo supplement -- this is a must-own set for all Blu-ray 3D owners and the perfect Christmas gift for the Blu-ray and 3D fan. Highly recommended.
2009
2009
Premium Collectors Edition
2009
2009
2010
2010
2004
Tinker Bell
2012
2009
2008
2011
Anniversary Edition | The Signature Collection
1953
2009
2001
Tinker Bell
2014
2006
Peter Pan 2
2002
2012
2014
2012
2017
2013
60th Anniversary Edition
1951
Rental Copy
1940