6.7 | / 10 |
| Users | 0.0 | |
| Reviewer | 3.0 | |
| Overall | 3.0 |
| Comedy | 100% |
Video codec: MPEG-4 AVC
Video resolution: 1080p
Aspect ratio: 1.78:1
Original aspect ratio: 1.78:1
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1
2.0 (Seasons 1-6), 5.1 (Seasons 7-12)
English SDH
Blu-ray Disc
Twenty five-disc set (25 BDs)
Region A (B, C untested)
| Movie | 3.0 | |
| Video | 3.0 | |
| Audio | 4.0 | |
| Extras | 3.5 | |
| Overall | 3.0 |
Created by uber TV producer Chuck Lorre and Lee Aronsohn, Two and a Half Men was a massively popular American sitcom that aired between 2003 and 2015. Lorre's earlier success with Cybill and Dharma and Greg later led to The Big Bang Theory and its spinoff Young Sheldon during and after Two and a Half Men's unprecedented 12-season run, where it also served as the rare show whose main character changed partway through after a very public war between Lorre and original star Charlie Sheen in 2011; this ended with the actor's dismissal, which led to the arrival of new series lead Ashton Kutcher from Season 8 onward. Most fans adamantly prefer "the Sheen years" for good reason but Two and a Half Men remained decently popular for the remainder of its run, intermittently earning 12 season sets on DVD between 2007-2015 with a brick-sized full-series SD collection materializing six years later. Warner Bros. returns with a budget Blu-ray series set that, in at least one major area, sadly doesn't advance that far beyond earlier releases.

This might normally pave the way for gradual growth on all three sides, but Two and a Half Men generally treats its main characters more cynically: while Charlie sometimes undergoes temporary maturity, he doesn't really grow much. (Like I said, Sheen is basically playing himself.) Neither does Jake, at least mentally. Alan even seems to regresses, gradually soaking up some of Charlie's bad habits like a sponge. Even so, there are softer exceptions along the way and, regardless of its moral barometer, Two and a Half Men's bread and butter is its sporadically sharp humor, quick dialogue, and of course risqué jokes, some of which appear regularly and in rapid-fire succession, but it's also built on the complicated bond between two brothers with a lot of separate and shared emotional baggage.
They aren't alone, of course, because almost every sitcom worth its salt also relies on a motley crew of supporting characters, typically serving as either emotional anchors or wacky distractions. Two and a Half Men has both during these first eight seasons and beyond, with the two most important being Charlie and Alan’s wealthy but emotionally distant mother Evelyn (Holland Taylor) and the family's outspoken housekeeper Berta (Conchata Ferrell), who almost always takes Charlies side during any dispute. Other series regulars include Alan's henpecking ex-wife Judith Harper-Melnick (Marin Hinkle), who often criticizes the faults of both men, as well as their creepy next-door neighbor Rose (Melanie Lynskey), who's initially obsessed with Charlie before they later become friends. While this is admittedly a pretty weak lineup, Two and a Half Men benefits a little more from other recurring characters like Jake's doctors Herb Melnick (Ryan Stiles) and Linda Freeman (Jane Lynch), the eccentric Frankie (Jenna Elfman), Evelyn's suitor Marty (Carl Reiner), and Alan's sporadic love interest Lyndsey (Courtney Thorne-Smith). Also appearing are numerous high-profile guest stars such as Sean Penn, Elvis Costello, Eddie Van Halen, Miley Cyrus, Stephen Tyler, Michael Bolton, Heather Locklear, Hilary Duff, Cloris Leachman, Teri Hatcher, James Earl Jones, John Stamos, Michael Clarke Duncan, Scott Bakula, Megan Fox, ZZ Top, Harry Dean Stanton, and Arnold Schwarzenegger. Who wasn't on this show?

But the elephant in the room is Two and a Half Men's inevitably drastic transformation from Season 9 onwards, which offers one of only a few dynamic permanent narrative shifts during this otherwise mostly episodic series. In real life, of course, Charlie Sheen's ongoing struggles with substance abuse and yet another stint in rehab led to very public insults lobbed towards Lorre, which resulted in (1) an immediate ban from the WB studio lot, (2) his official termination from the series, (3) a $100M wrongful termination lawsuit filed by Sheen that ended with a $25 million settlement, and (4) probably a lot more behind-the-scenes drama that's been since swept under the rug. In any case, his character's fate is just as dramatic: "Charlie" is apparently killed off-screen when he's pushed in front of a train, and future episodes beat this dead horse with an appearance by his ghost (Kathy Bates) who's sent to Hell, the revelation of his illegitimate chip-off-the-old-block daughter Jenny (Amber Tamblyn), and a series finale that must be seen to be believed.
Then there's Walden Schmidt (Kutcher), Charlie's real-life and character replacement who steps into the lead during Seasons 9-12. His character, a socially awkward but extremely wealthy internet billionaire, purchases the Malibu beach house. Walden is emotionally vulnerable despite his fortune and forms an unlikely friendship with Alan, even allowing the unusual living arrangement to continue. This change of characters also introduces a new comedic dynamic: while Charlie’s humor came from his excessive confidence and reckless lifestyle, Walden’s presence provides comedy through his naïveté, romantic idealism, and difficulty with relationships. Essentially, Two and a Half Men now focuses more on Walden's attempts to find love and personal meaning, while Alan continues to rely on others for financial security. Their unlikely friendship is now a central element and replaces the earlier sibling dynamic between Charlie and Alan, allowing everyone to grow up... and that includes Jake too, as he inevitably leaves home to find his own way.
Warner Bros. first released this full-series Blu-ray set back in November with no signs that all 12 seasons will be released individually, and
occasional sales even have pushed it below the $80 mark. That still seems a little high for what you get here, since the prospect of a film-shot
series in 1080p should yield much stronger results than this set ultimately achieves due to corners being cut: as many as 12 episodes are
crammed onto each dual-layer disc, which obviously leads to very noticeable compression issues during its longer seasons. This complaint also
applies to the packaging, which certainly saves shelf space but sacrifices appearance and ease of use in the process.

One of the last sitcoms of its era to be shot on 35mm film, much of Two and a Half Men should look a hell of a lot better than it does here on Warner Bros.' Blu-ray collection. So, where does it fall short? It's mostly due to the early seasons' DVD-era masters as well as the incredibly cheap decision to cram up to 12 episodes on each disc, both of which lead to a relatively flat and video-like appearance that's plagued by macro blocking, black crush, posterization, and a few other anomalies, which isn't surprising since they run at abysmally low bit rates. The show's anything-goes color palette sometimes borders on too vivid with trace amounts of bleeding and values that lean into the exaggerated warmth of the DVD era, while readable but negligible textures are often buried below the thin, gauzy haze of its overall appearance and prevailing noise instead of film grain. It's almost a start-to-finish damnation of the series as a whole, but there are two brighter spots: things get a little better by default as the years go on, and Seasons 8 and 12 have only 16 episodes apiece -- that's just eight on each disc, which should've been the rule instead of the exception. Those watching on small displays won't notice these compression issues as much, but they're clearly there more often than not and contribute to an all-around picture that ranges between "dreadfully disappointing" to "decently passable".

In contrast, the DTS-HD Master Audio mixes (presented in 2.0 during Seasons 1-6 and 5.1 during Seasons 7-12) offer no such obvious shortcomings, displaying the kind of sturdy but supportive strength needed to get the job done. This is obviously a front-loaded presentation, even during the surround years, with noticeable left-right separation and a nicely prioritized soundstage that leaves room for its dreaded laugh track. That said, the 5.1 mix obviously offers a smoother sonic experience with very little discrete use but a more balanced atmosphere that feels closer to actually being on set. As a whole these lossless tracks certainly doesn't reinvent the wheel at either end of the channel count, instead serving as reliably stable and unassuming efforts that don't call attention to themselves.
Optional English (SDH) subtitles are included during each episode as well as most of the extras listed below.

This 25-disc set ships in a pair of "Epic" keepcases (their phrase, not mine), otherwise known as the least desirable type of physical media packaging alongside cardboard sleeves and those old "snapper" cases. For the uninitiated, these DVD-height cases feature multiple overlapping hinges and are notoriously difficult to work with, although at least in this case each disc gets its own hub. It's divided neatly in half with six seasons per case, which might bother anyone with "main character" OCD, but thankfully disc-by-disc episode listings are printed on the inside covers. Character-themed cover artwork is present on both cases, while the outer slipcover features a collage of memorable moments as well as a lineup of the original DVD covers on the back. It's honestly not as terrible as I've made it sound, but obviously a more traditional set of 12 regular keepcases (and more discs per season!) would have been preferred.
As for the extras, they seem to mirror the earlier DVD sets with legacy items present on almost every season.
SEASON ONE, DISC TWO
SEASON ONE, DISC TWO
SEASON THREE, DISC TWO
SEASON FOUR, DISC THREE
SEASON FIVE, DISC TWO

SEASON SIX, DISC TWO
SEASON SEVEN, DISC TWO
SEASON NINE, DISC TWO
SEASON TEN, DISC TWO
SEASON ELEVEN, DISC TWO
SEASON TWELVE, DISC TWO

Chuck Lorre and Lee Aronsohn's Two and a Half Men ran for 12 seasons and even survived some pretty nasty behind-the-scenes turbulence that led to the recasting of its main character, which should tell you all you need to know about the show's unstoppable popularity. Its fanbase grew further thanks to streaming and separate DVD season collections, enough so that Warner Bros. has seen fit to offer a complete Blu-ray collection right out of the gate with no indication it'll be broken up any further. But it almost doesn't matter, as this is a poorly-conceived effort whose older masters and overstuffed discs have resulting in video quality that's well below average and packaging that isn't much better. Fans who desperately want to replace their old DVD sets will still see an improvement here (and the audio quality and extras are at least on point), but I wouldn't blame anyone if they waited for a clearance-level sale on this.

2008-2009

2007-2019

Limited Edition
1989-1998

2013-2014

2003

2013

Bruno
2009

Extended Cut
2014

2012

2014

2018

2017

2018

2017

2016

2016

1989

2015

2015

1986-1993