Rating summary

Movie		4.5
Video		4.0
Audio		4.5
Extras		4.0
Overall		4.5

Toy Story 3D Blu-ray Movie Review

The first, for some the best, arrives in 3D...

Reviewed by Kenneth Brown October 19, 2011

It's difficult to convey how drastically and substantially Pixar Studios and filmmaker John Lasseter have altered the landscape of animation. As the '80s slowly sank into the sands of time and the '90s began promising new strides in technology, CG animation was little more than an intriguing gimmick; a gangly gambit that didn't seem destined for any sort of greatness, much less the sort of cinematic coup that was brewing in Lasseter's brain. But that was before 1995; before Toy Story invaded thousands of theaters, took international audiences by storm, and inspired an artistic revolution that continues to rage some fifteen years after its first battle was forged. Animation enthusiasts can bicker for days on end as to whether a hand-drawn wonder or a CG marvel offers the best animated experience, but no amount of debate can rob Pixar or its best films of their incalculable value. And Toy Story? More than just the first of its kind, it remains one of the studio's finest, and the first of a thriving breed of new Disney classics -- among them beloved Pixar favorites Up, Wall-E, Finding Nemo, Toy Story 2, Monsters, Inc. and, most recently, Toy Story 3 -- that have steadily established a hold over filmfans of all ages.

You. Are. A. Toy!

Woody (voiced by Tom Hanks) is living the life. Pull-string cowboy dolls don't usually have it so good, but as his owner Andy's favorite toy, Woody rules the playroom. His friends love and respect him -- matter-of-fact piggie bank Hamm (John Ratzenberger), the cantankerous Mr. Potato Head (Don Rickles), ever-loyal right hand man Slinky Dog (Jim Varney), anxiety-stricken plastic dinosaur Rex (Wallace Shawn), the lovely Bo Peep (Annie Potts), and the dutiful sergeant of Andy's Green Army Men (R. Lee Ermey) -- and his owner has scribbled his name on the bottom of Woody's boot, an enviable honor in the toy world. The rules are simple: never let Andy know that toys merely play possum when children come near, and keep the boy as happy as possible. But that all changes at Andy's birthday party when his mother buys him the hottest new action figure on the market, Buzz Lightyear (Tim Allen). Earning instant affection, Buzz makes Woody jealous, especially when the lanky cowboy realizes the space ranger has no idea he's actually just a child's plaything. As Andy prepares to choose one toy to bring on a long trip, Woody tries to knock Buzz out of the running, only to accidentally knock him out of the window. Now, with his friends convinced that he tried to kill the new guy, Woody begrudgingly sets out to retrieve Buzz and restore peace and order to Andy's room.

Toy Story's boundless, dare I say timeless charm traces back to its voice actors' passionate, pitch-perfect performances, Pixar's remarkably smart and funny script (penned by Lasseter, Up director Pete Docter, Andrew Stanton, and affable "heart and soul" of the studio, Joe Ranft), and the entire animation team's utter devotion to storytelling and character development. Though essentially a riff on the buddy cop films of the '80s and '90s, Lasseter's comedy is a far more nuanced endeavor; one that has plenty to offer both children and adults. Wide-eyed tykes will soak up the building-block sights and Pizza-Planet whimsy, clapping and laughing as Buzz and Woody battle for their owner's affection. But thirty and forty-something parents will be drawn into Andy's world as well, engrossed by a cowboy doll's insecurity and desperation, an action figure's delusions of grandeur and eventual triumph, a dinosaur's perpetual fear and sudden panic attacks and, of course, just how easily Pixar transforms these mounds of plastic and stitched cloth into characters that are so decidedly human. It helps that Hanks, Allen, Ratzenberger, and nearly every voice actor that graces the proceedings has connected to the material so intensely, and has rooted themselves so deeply in the world Lasseter and company are creating. Their performances lend the film legitimate momentum, imbue each toy with spirit and purpose, and make every joke funnier and every theme more powerful. It's something genre filmmakers still fail to achieve some two decades after Pixar mastered the process. Just sample any number of recent animated misfires -- Astroboy, Planet 51, Igor, and many others -- and you'll hear what Toy Story could have been filled with: wooden acting, uninspired voice work, and disconnected deliveries that undermine everything their films' animators have toiled to accomplish.

Pixar's commitment to every aspect of their productions is obvious, and the very thing that allows Toy Story, aging animation and all, to rocket into the stratosphere of the imagination in 2010 as readily as it did in 1995. Toys have never seemed so alive, vending machines have never been home to such hilarious alien cultures, cobbled monstrosities have never been so captivating, sinister toy-nabbing miscreants have never been so terrifying, adventure has never hurtled down a road on the back of an RC car with such abandon, and your childhood playthings have never taken on such a life of their own. (At least until Toy Story 2, but that's another review.) Has it stood the test of time? Dozens of viewings and my five-year old son's couch-bouncing reaction to Buzz and Woody's shenanigans certainly seem to suggest so. Have its jokes grown stale? Not if my family's laughter is any indication. Has the tale lost its hold? Without any misguided pop culture references or cheap humor lurking in the shadows, Pixar's storytelling is as breezy and effortless as it was when the film first hit theaters. Is its animation too outdated to lure in newcomers? Hardly. It may show its age, but antiquated animation hasn't stopped Snow White, Cinderella, Pinocchio, Dumbo, Beauty and the Beast, Aladdin, and countless others from winning over the masses, young and old alike. Just like those indelible greats, Toy Story's memorable personalities, expressive faces, absorbing story, and amazing adventure will keep its heart beating for years to come.

Toy Story 3D Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality 

Questioning the decision to release a sixteen-year-old, first generation computer animated classic in 3D? Don't be too quick to judge. Toy Story may not be getting any younger, but Disney's 1080p/MVC-encoded 3D presentation slaps in some new batteries, dusts off an old cowboy hat and soars to infinity and beyond... with only a few minor mishaps. Ghosting isn't uncommon, but it is fairly negligible, only appearing in a handful of passing shots and rarely invading the foreground. If you must, keep your eyes peeled in the Pizza Planet and in wide shots of Andy's room and you'll see it, haunting tinker toys and arcade cabinet letters. It isn't very distracting, though, and you almost have to go hunting for it to even find it. Aliasing creeps in from time to time as well (a bit more than it does in the film's 2D transfer), but it doesn't pose much of a problem either. It's fleeting, infrequent and, in most case, inherent to the source. So, with all that out of the way, how good does Toy Story look in 3D? Better than I thought it would, that's for sure. I don't know why I expected Toy Story to be any less impressive than its sequels, at least technically speaking, but the relative simplicity of the animation actually makes certain elements pop a bit more. Depth isn't always as convincing or consistent, but the livelier locales of Toy Story 2 and far more lifelike environments of Toy Story 3 lend themselves to such things; the original film's more basic backgrounds don't create as absorbing a world. Even so, the encode and overall 3D effect hold their own.

Take note of the roundness of Buzz's helmet, the way Woody's arms retreat from and rush toward the screen as he walks, the expanse that is Andy's room, the way a grateful alien lifts into the air, the fullness and dimensionality of a toy's head as the virtual Pixar camera presses in, the way Buzz and Woody break the 2D plane after lighting the rocket strapped to the Space Ranger's back... any complaints? I don't have any. Look for standout scenes and marvel. The opening scene, Woody's introduction to Buzz, the new toy's first manned flight across Andy's room, the now iconic "You are a toy!" beat, the little green men in the claw game, Woody's encounter with Sid's mutant toys and, of course, that last dazzling dash down the street. Toy Story shows its age, arguably more so in 3D than in 2D, but that doesn't mean the 3D experience lessens or hinders the film in any way. If anything, it makes it more playful and engaging than before. (If that's even possible.) And beyond the 3D? Toy Story 3D benefits from all the qualities that make its 2D counterpart as striking as it is. Vibrant colors beam from the screen, delivering a veritable rainbow of Crayola reds, Tyrannosaurus greens, and brilliant blues. Detail is impeccable too. Textures, limited as they may be, are crisp and perfectly defined, edges are sharp enough to slice open an action figure blister pack, and every inch of the backgrounds and foregrounds come alive exactly as Lasseter and the Pixar team intended. The difference between the picture and its previously terribly outdated standard DVD counterparts is incalculable. More importantly, significant artifacting, banding, aberrant noise, ringing and other oddities are held at bay. 3D enthusiasts will be overjoyed to see how much love and care has been granted to the granddaddy of computer animated feature films.

Toy Story 3D Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality 

Disney's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track is terrific too. From an opening playroom tussle to the chaotic, birthday-born arrival of Buzz Lightyear; from the space-faring figure's fall out of a window to Woody's reluctant Pizza Planet pseudo-rescue; from Sid's tortured toys to our faithful heroes' escape from his clutches, Toy Story takes advantage of every channel, submerging the listener in a consistently satisfying soundfield brimming with barking army men, clattering slinkies, clanging arcades, clamoring aliens, and the loyal roar of a desperate RC's engine. LFE output is strong (despite being a tad reserved at times), lending toppling toys tremendous weight, lumbering monstrosities some frightening presence, and a rickety truck bed unruly heft. Rear speaker activity is engaging as well, enhancing each scene with ample ambient effects and convincing interior acoustics. Likewise, dialogue is clean, intelligible, and perfectly prioritized regardless of whether Woody and Buzz are surrounded by droning claaaaw servants, arguing beneath a delivery boy's truck, or hurtling down a road in pursuit of their owner. Combined with snapshot directionality and stealthy pans, all of the elements lock into place, creating a sturdy (albeit reasonably dated) sonic experience that complements the film nicely.

Toy Story 3D Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras 

Toy Story 3D packs a bit more supplemental punch than Toy Story 2 3D, but only because its original DVD release had a greater bounty of bonus materials to pilfer (all of which have been ported over from said DVD). Otherwise, Disney has granted Lasseter's first feature-length baby a comparable collection of newly produced high definition content. The only thing that could have made it better? A Picture-in-Picture track or a suite of snazzy BD-Java features.

• Audio Commentary: Director John Lasseter, co-writer Andrew Stanton, art director Ralph Eggleston, supervising animator Pete Docter (who would go on to direct Up), supervising technical director Bill Reeves, and producers Ralph Guggenheim and Bonnie Arnold thoroughly dissect Toy Story and its production. While the room is a bit crowded at times, the group dive into the story, script, characters, voice performances, animation, strides in technology, technical challenges, and filmmaking prowess that made the film the classic that it is today.
• Toy Story 3 Sneak Peek: The Story (HD, 2 minutes): The first of two TS3 featurettes (the other can be found on the Blu-ray edition of Toy Story 2), "The Story" clues fans in on what to expect from Toy Story 3.
• Buzz Lightyear Mission Logs: Blast Off (HD, 3 minutes): Buzz, Hamm, and Rex introduce NASA, the space shuttle, and space exploration to their younger viewers in this cute animated/live-action short.
• Paths to Pixar: Artists (HD, 5 minutes): Several Pixar artists candidly reflect on their introduction to Disney's worlds and characters, their early infatuation with animation, the time they spent at art school, and their experiences at Lasseter's acclaimed studio.
• Studio Stories (HD, 5 minutes): A trio of endearing animated shorts give the Pixar team a chance to reminisce about "John's Car," a Halloween contest that inspired a studio mainstay to become "Baby AJ," and the "Scooter Races" held in the original studio offices.
• Buzz Takes Manhattan (HD, 2 minutes): Lasseter chats about Buzz Lightyear's massive Macy's Day Parade balloon.
• Black Friday: The Toy Story You Never Saw (HD, 8 minutes): Exactly what its title suggests, this featurette presents a version of Toy Story that was thankfully scrapped in favor of the film we're all familiar with.
• Filmmakers Reflect (SD, 17 minutes): Lifted from the standard DVD (along with a variety of other features), this roundtable discussion between Lasseter and his Pixar brethren delves into the film and its production.
• Making Toy Story (SD, 20 minutes): This somewhat glowing EPK gives Lasseter and his Toy Story team ample opportunity to examine the development, design, and animation of Buzz and Woody's first adventure.
• The Legacy of Toy Story (SD, 12 minutes): Lasseter, his voice actors, notable critics, and a number of filmmakers (including Peter Jackson and George Lucas) share their thoughts on Toy Story, as well as the many ways it shook up and revitalized the animation genre.
• Designing Toy Story (SD, 6 minutes): Although it starts to tread on ground covered elsewhere, this solid featurette delves into the technical realm of CG animation and Toy Story's design.
• Deleted Scenes (SD, 19 minutes): Ten unfinished deleted scenes, many of which feature alternate versions of beloved sequences.
• Design (SD, 28 minutes): Character and environment galleries, 3-D visualizations, and color tests abound in this generous section.
• Story (SD, 14 minutes): View a "Green Army Men" pitch, an "Andy's New Toy" storyreel, and a "Chase" storyreel-to-film comparison.
• Production (SD, 14 minutes): Take a pair of "Production" and "Animation" tours, learn about several "Layout Tricks" used in the film, and queue up a "Multi-Language Reel."
• Music & Sound (SD, 26 minutes): Along with a "You've Got a Friend in Me" music video and a "Designing Sound" featurette, supplemental junkies can listen to six Randy Newman audio tracks.
• Publicity (SD, 24 minutes): A slew of advertising materials -- a "Character Interview" short, two "Theatrical Trailers," four "TV Spots," twenty-five domestic and international "Posters," merchandise photos, and fifteen "Toy Story Treats" -- complete the package.
• Maximize Your Home Theater: Use this basic video/audio calibration tool to get the most out of the presentation.
• BD-Live Functionality

Toy Story 3D Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation 

Toy Story 3D isn't as engrossing as Toy Story 3 3D, be it the film, its 3D presentation or its lossless audio, but I can't imagine Lasseter's 1995 original getting a better treatment than it does here. Toy Story remains a classic some sixteen years after its debut, its 3D video presentation is great fun, its 2D transfer doesn't falter, its DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track excels and its supplemental package delivers. I couldn't ask for much more.