8.1 | / 10 |
Users | 4.0 | |
Reviewer | 3.0 | |
Overall | 3.7 |
Former U.S. Marshal Wyatt Earp's plan for peace, quiet, and prosperity misfires when he, his brothers, and the outrageous rogue Doc Holliday encounter that ruthless band of outlaws, the Cowboys.
Starring: Kurt Russell, Val Kilmer, Sam Elliott, Bill Paxton, Powers BootheWestern | 100% |
Period | 63% |
Action | 53% |
Drama | Insignificant |
Video codec: MPEG-4 AVC
Video resolution: 1080p
Aspect ratio: 2.40:1
Original aspect ratio: 2.39:1
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 (48kHz, 24-bit)
French: Dolby Digital 2.0
Spanish: Dolby Digital 2.0
English, English SDH, French, Spanish
50GB Blu-ray Disc
Single disc (1 BD)
Region free
Movie | 4.0 | |
Video | 3.0 | |
Audio | 4.5 | |
Extras | 1.0 | |
Overall | 3.0 |
Some fifteen years after its initial release, fascinating revelations began to emerge that actor Kurt Russell, not the late George P. Cosmatos, had directed Tombstone. These reports have recently gained even more traction as the film, slowly but steadily closing in on its twentieth anniversary, makes its much-anticipated Blu-ray debut. But the arresting story behind Tombstone's parentage, as well as subsequent accounts of its troubled production and release, shouldn't distract anyone from the tightly tuned, action-packed Western that first charged theaters in 1993. Blessed with a masterclass cast and several outstanding performances, a smartly penned script by Glory's Kevin Jarre, and a slew of pulse-pounding gunfights, Russell's film is, without a doubt, an electrifying introduction to one of the most iconic figures in American history. Though it doesn't dig as deeply as new classics like The Assassination of Jesse James or withstand close critical scrutiny as well as Oscar-winners like Unforgiven, it excels on its own terms. It also isn't beyond reproach. It's simply an entertaining, character-driven actioner both serious cinephiles and casual filmfans can enjoy.
Together again...
As a longtime fan of the film, this inconsistent, increasingly problematic 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer left me confused and disappointed. Overcast with a strange breed of shadow, the image is darker and more brooding than it's ever been before, often to the detriment of background and foreground details, nighttime sequences, and low-lit interiors (of which there are many). At first, I thought Cosmatos' stark, sun-bathed locales and the actors' wide-brimmed hats were working in tandem to play a trick on my eyes, but it didn't take long to realize that wasn't the case at all. Though contrast remains quite strong throughout, it continually overwhelms and hampers William A. Fraker's sunburnt Arizona palette. Skintones are frequently either debuffed or oversaturated, black levels are hampered by debilitating crush, and textures are often muddied by the murky results (not to mention the intermittent smearing that appears from time to time). Worse, while the Blu-ray edition handily bests its DVD counterparts in terms of color vibrancy and general clarity, the DVD features more revealing delineation. It's a shame too. For every poorly defined saloon and waxy face, an exceedingly crisp closeup or refined burst of grain hints at how amazing the presentation could have been had the film received a complete restoration. Unfortunately, these showcase scenes tend to contribute to the erratic tenor of the presentation. Other complaints? Edge enhancement produces slight (on some occasions, severe) ringing and aliasing, wavering and flickering make a few negligible appearances, and source noise surges in a handful of shots.
That's not to say Disney's transfer isn't without merit -- primaries are bold and stable, fine detail is quite impressive at times, some shots are downright gorgeous, artifacting and other anomalies are kept to a bare minimum, and the presentation still offers DVD owners a notable upgrade overall -- but it doesn't quite do the whole of the film justice. Hopefully, the studio will revisit Tombstone in the near future and give it the high-dollar overhaul it deserves. For now, fans will have to settle for a decent presentation and focus on enjoying one of their favorite films in high definition.
From the moment a dusty gunslinger fires his pistol at the screen and Bruce Broughton's score announces the sudden arrival of Curly Bill's dastardly Cowboys, Disney's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track makes its presence known. The thunder of charging horses, the roar of a shotgun, and the hearty kik-cak of a six-shooter follow close behind, carefully preparing the way for the gunfight behind the O.K. Corral, Wyatt Earp's rage-fueled vendetta, and Doc Holliday's climactic duel. Through it all, LFE output is brazen and aggressive -- lending every shootout and hoof-fall weight and heft -- and rear speaker activity is fierce and involving. Moreover, dialogue remains clear and intelligible, prioritization is nearly impeccable (more on that in a bit), and directionality is thoroughly convincing. Listen to the heart-wrenched gravel in Russell's voice when he cries "hell's comin' with me!" The wet crack of a cowboy's broken nose and the syrupy splash of his blood. The triumphant horns and mounting drums that seem to propel Earp and his immortals into history. Dynamics, channel pans, separation... it's all exactly as it should be, and injects some much-needed value into the release. If anything, several lines are lost beneath the chaotic storm, and still others suffer from somewhat shrill ADR work. Even so, each instance is attributable to the original audio elements and rarely detracts from the quality of the track. All in all, those who've been eagerly anticipating Tombstone's Blu-ray debut will be most pleased.
In 2002, Disney granted Tombstone a 2-disc Vista Series release that included a solid selection of special features. The Blu-ray edition retains some of this previous release's content... minus a George P. Cosmatos commentary, an interactive timeline, and a historical account of the shootout at the O.K. Corral. Why some content is missing, particularly Cosmatos' commentary, is a mystery, but its absence certainly takes a toll. All that remains is a decent 3-part "Making of Tombstone" documentary (SD, 27 minutes), a glimpse at the director's "Original Storyboards" (SD, 4 minutes), two trailers (SD, 4 minutes), and seven TV spots (SD, 3 minutes).
Tombstone may not be a perfect film -- several stilted mishaps hinder its stride -- but its intense action, character-driven story, stunning second and third acts, and unforgettable performances solidify this fan-favorite Western's standing as an early '90s classic. Sadly, Disney's Blu-ray edition stumbles out of the gate with an underwhelming video transfer and a lackluster supplemental package (one that's missing a number of special features). While a fantastic DTS-HD Master Audio track salvages the release, it fails to take the sting out of the disc's lesser qualities. Ah well. I doubt this will be the last we see of Tombstone. Hopefully, the studio will grant the film the full restoration it deserves the next time around.
Per un Pugno di Dollari
1964
1985
1951
2003
1965
2016
1992
1973
2015
1995
2016
2007
2005
2K Restoration
1972
2019
2018
1967
2010
1985
1962