Rating summary

Movie		2.0
Video		4.5
Audio		5.0
Extras		3.5
Overall		3.5

The Three Musketeers 3D Blu-ray Movie Review

The ThreeD Musketeers.

Reviewed by Martin Liebman March 5, 2012

We were the Musketeers. Now, we're just...us.

It's a technical accomplishment, an unquestionably grand picture of visual splendor and precision, the product of a multimillion dollar budget made by a crew obviously well-versed in the art of crafting a nearly impeccable recreation of 1600s Europe. Paul W.S. Anderson's (Resident Evil) The Three Musketeers delivers to the five-star level in terms of its technical merits, the movie a fine example of polished, big-budget, 21st century filmmaking. But that's pretty much the best of it. As grand as it may look, The Three Musketeers is also the epitome of the modern day style of superficial and skin-deep filmmaking. Once one gets past the scale and scope of the production, there's nothing left except hollow dialogue, flat characters, mindless action scenes, and an A-B-C plot. It's absolutely predictable and absolutely pointless. Aren't there enough movies already in circulation that only really discredit the source rather than bring it to life? Aren't there any hundreds of films that aim only for overly stylized action rather than plot? The Three Musketeers seems but an excuse to modernize a tale that needs no modernization. The movie features a Musketeer, in an early scene, rising from the water as if the inspiration was a ninja Benjamin Willard. Anderson favorite (and real-life wife) Mila Jovovich slides and slithers and swings and swats and sword fights around the frame in slow motion, avoiding booby traps as if she were Ethan Hunt or Virginia Baker during a bullet-time sequence from The Matrix, all while wearing a period dress that would hardly allow her to breathe, let alone perform action movie stunt work. Then there's the high-flying aerial combat between 17th century aircraft that basically look like blimps with warships slapped onto the bottom. The mantra for this film seemed to be "how cool can this movie be" rather than "how smart can this movie be?" The results speak for themselves.

Musketeers for a new generation.

The Three Musketeers -- Athos (Matthew Macfadyen), Aramis (Luke Evans), and Porthos (Ray Stevenson) -- plus one damsel in a dress called Milady (Milla Jovovich) -- have traveled to Venice for a little action and a big reward: plans for an airship drawn up by none other than Leonardo Da Vinci. The excursion proves a success. Yet as quickly as they claim their prize and as soon as they can celebrate their success, they learn that they have a traitor amongst them: Milady double-crosses the men and gives Da Vinci's plans to the English Duke of Buckingham (Orlando Bloom). A year later, the group has been disbanded by order of the conniving Cardinal Richelieu (Christoph Waltz), but don't tell upstart D'Artagnan (Logan Lerman), a Musketeer-in-waiting trained by his father, himself a former member of the famed society of French heroes. It's off to Paris young D'Artagnan goes to become a Musketeer, riding his steed, Buttercup, and heeding his father's advice to find trouble and make mistakes. His first mistake is nearly a killer: a run-in with the one-eyed Rochefort (Mads Mikkelsen), Captain of Cardinal Richelieu's guard, leaves him shot and at the end of a sword. The suave D'Artagnan is saved only by the graces of Milady, who proclaims him to pretty for death or disfigurement. Soon, D'Artagnan tracks down the three remaining Musketeers. They're broke and aimless, but when they fight valiantly together against incredible odds versus the Cardinal's guards, they are granted an audience with none other than King Louis (Freddie Fox) himself. As the Musketeers become more involved in the court's politics, they become central players in a dangerous conspiracy that could lead to a devastating war with England, a war only their skill and bravery can prevent.

Perhaps the best way to describe The Three Musketeers is to say that it's a Costume film with the most movement and loudest noises in cinema history. The picture attempts to intersect two completely different styles, the classic centuries-old story of treachery in a time of great ornateness with modern day kinetic action that's more about wires, digital aids, and camera trickery than real human motion or capabilities, a terribly odd combination to be sure. Nevertheless, this is Anderson's -- and one of 2011's -- most visually-arresting films. In that regard, it's a real treat and a commendable accomplishment worthy of Oscar nomination recognition for its art direction and costume design, though it probably failed to receive any nominations because it's otherwise too ridiculous to take seriously. Anderson's direction is unquestionably slick, too. He has an eye for this style, which works in the video-game inspired modern day world of Resident Evil but not so much in centuries-old France. The movie undoubtedly means well, and it's a relatively harmless little slice of escapism, but considering there are just so many other, better options out there that don't leave audiences scratching their heads and groaning at the out-of-place elements, bizarre plot lines, generic characters, and awful dialogue, The Three Musketeers, it would seem, just doesn't serve much of a purpose.

Indeed, there's absolutely nothing in The Three Musketeers that hasn't been done before, done better, and done with more purpose and adherence to genre/style combination norms. There's nothing wrong with bucking convention, but some combinations just don't work, The Three Musketeers and other, similar pictures like Wild Wild West proof positive that some genres are best left to the way they already are. As if the odd combination wasn't bad enough, The Three Musketeers doesn't really get anything else right, either. The plot is generic and the surprises hardly surprising. It's very linear and predictable, which makes a watch all the more agonizingly pointless. The characters are absolutely flat and their relationships the product of a poorly-conceived script. There's the "brash!" and "cocky!" good looking lead, the "sensuous!" and "treacherous!" femme fatale, the "chunky!" and "goofy!" fifth wheel (literally) Musketeer sidekick (by the way, why in the world have these stories always been called The Three Musketeers when there are four?). Then there are the singleminded villains, the pretty but otherwise worthless love interest for D'Artagnan, and the Musketeers themselves, who at the beginning parade around like Batman or The Hulk or some such nonsense but pretty much revert back to mere sword fighting masters for the rest of the movie. Every moment is but another tick towards the inevitable ending where a big battle yields victory for the good guys and a setup for the potential sequel. The Three Musketeers is the perfect example of a movie with no teeth, no originality, assembled from stock elements that no amount of visual or aural flash could improve upon.

The Three Musketeers 3D Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality 

The Three Musketeers' 1080p 2D-only Blu-ray release is nothing short of stunning, one of the finest transfers on the market. The good news is that Summit's Blu-ray 3D transfer holds up nearly as well. Pretty much all of the 2D transfer's attributes carry on over here. Though this image is a hair darker and not quite as absolutely bright and brilliant as the 2D version, it's nevertheless a dazzler, featuring wonderful colors, very strong clarity, and impeccable detailing as seen on all of the period costumes and structures. Blacks are a little too dark here, however, but not to the destruction of any shots or scenes. Noise, banding, and the like remain absent. The 3D-sepcific attributes are strong, too. The appearance of crosstalk is extremely light and a rarity. The 3D transfer presents viewers with a natural sense of space in depth, whether in general medium or close shots or when the camera gazes down long corridors, such as that leading to Da Vinci's vault. There are some fine gadget effects, too, swords that appear to poke out of the screen and debris flying at the audience during the key battle scene near the end. Yet for as technically polished as it may be, the 3D elements rarely dazzle, rarely make the extra effort of watching in 3D worthwhile. It's all very effective, spacious, and shapely, but the film doesn't often take advantage of the opportunities innate to the 3D medium. considering the slight drop off in vibrancy and the lack of a real awe-inspiring dazzler of a 3D image, best to enjoy The Three Musketeers in 2D.

The Three Musketeers 3D Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality 

The Three Musketeers sounds great. Summit Entertainment's DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtrack dazzles with its crisp definition and sonic precision. The track plays in a wide, almost cavernous, soundstage. Music is endlessly rich, naturally spaced, and plays with a heavy but balanced surround element. The track plays just as big even in quieter moments. Dialogue and slight sound effects -- the creaking of a large door, for instance -- as heard in spacious royal halls echo about with startling natural authenticity. General dialogue remains balanced and focused up the middle, even as it, too, plays with a rather big, cinematic flair. Minor but mood-critical ambient effects play in harmony, setting the stage for various scenes by building the listening area up with necessary elements to bring each scene to vivid life. Big sound effects are superb; strong winds and thunder dominate, and the big high-flying aerial action sequence comes alive with heavy cannon fire and even heavier explosions, the soundtrack practically sending splinters of wood and other damaged goods flying throughout the soundstage. For as chaotic as it often may be, everything is in its proper place, whether static center-focused sounds or in-transit and location-specific effects. This is a real treat, the perfect compliment to a fine 3D transfer. Both together almost mask the movie's shortcomings, and The Three Musketeers is worth a watch on Blu-ray just for the technical presentation.

The Three Musketeers 3D Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras 

The Three Musketeers contains all of the features found on the 2D-only release, all located on the included 2D-only disc. There are no 3D or exclusive supplements to be found in this two-disc set.

• Audio Commentary: Director/Producer Paul W.S. Anderson and Producers Jeremy Bolt and Robert Kulzer, a.k.a. the "Three Budgeteers," discuss reinventing the story of The Three Musketeers in a post-Matrix world, the many digital effects, set design, practical shooting locales, similarities and differences from the original story, casting the major roles, mixing real and digital locations in the same shots, shooting digitally, and plenty more. It's a balanced and quality commentary; fans and listeners interested in the process of making a big-budget spectacle will find value in it.
• Access: Three Musketeers: This picture-in-picture supplement provides audiences with "access to cast and crew stories, insider information about the making of the film, and more." Viewers are treated to a multitude of behind-the-scenes features that reference many aspects of the filmmaking process, some of which play alongside the film, others of which interrupt it for a nearly full-screen experience. Also included is text-based trivia, interview snippets, and more. Summit's PiP supplements are the best in the game. A static and unobtrusive box remains on the screen with various tools, including a countdown to the next "event," instant access to the next and previous "events," and various additional options. With the interrupted segments included, total runtime is 2:21:02.
• Paul W.S. Anderson's Musketeers (1080p, 2:29): Cast and crew discuss updating the story for a new generation.
• Orlando Bloom Takes on the Duke (1080p, 1:59): A look at Bloom's role in the film.
• 17th Century Air Travel (1080p, 2:20): Anderson discusses his preference for shooting with as many practical elements in the frame as possible, with emphasis on constructing the aerial warships.
• Uncovering France in Germany (1080p, 2:14): The benefits of shooting in Bavaria.
• Deleted & Extended Scenes (1080p, 14:18): Where's the Key?, Catching You, Entering Da Vinci's Vault, Chess Game, Queen Anne Disputes the Cardinal, Buckingham's Arrival, Buckingham and Cardinal in the War Room, Queen Anne and Constance, Planchet and the Horse, Tower of London, The Musketeers of the Airship, and D'Artagnan and Rochefort Fight.

The Three Musketeers 3D Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation 

The Three Musketeers might look great and sound wonderful, but it's otherwise a dreadful movie. Rather than a legitimate take on the old tale, this is a dumbed-down flick that fails to entertain, preferring fantasy and make-believe and eschewing even a semblance of a plot that audiences could take seriously. There's suspension of disbelief, and then there is just ridiculous. Just because something can be made a spectacle doesn't mean it should. Maybe sixth grade boys will like this movie, but there's far better out there for even slightly more discerning audiences looking for a way to spend their mindless entertainment buck. And for those attracted to the two things this movie does well -- set design and costuming -- there are other alternatives that are just as flashy and serve up a better story to boot. Summit Entertainment's Blu-ray 3D release of The Three Musketeers features a clear and precise 3D transfer, a high quality lossless soundtrack, and the same supplements which appear with the 2D-only release. Unfortunately, the movie doesn't improve one bit when viewed in 3D. In fact, the 3D is somewhat boring, though its technical presentation is nearly above reproach. Worth a rental.