Rating summary
| Movie |  | 5.0 |
| Video |  | 4.5 |
| Audio | | 5.0 |
| Extras |  | 4.0 |
| Overall | | 4.5 |
The Man Who Laughs Blu-ray Movie Review
An outstanding 4K restoration of the silent-era classic.
Reviewed by Neil Lumbard June 30, 2021
As one of the great silent films of the 1920's, The Man Who Laughs is
a haunting exploration of the turmoil of a disfigured young child named Gwynplaine. A group of savages commonly referred to throughout the land as
comprachicos have gone throughout the countryside wrecking havoc and disfiguring the faces of young children. The film has been produced by the
great Carl Laemmie (Frankenstein, Dracula).
One of these victims was the innocent Gwynplaine. In becoming a disfigured child
his face took on a maniacal appearance which led to him becoming the laughingstock of his town. Gwynplaine starts to become a side-show attraction
to the cruel audience gleefully laughing at his never-ending smile as he appears to them as a mere form of spectacle at the circus.
The one and only soul whom Gwynplaine connects to is the blind beauty Dea (Mary
Philbin). Unlike the soul-crushing cruelty which he endures by circus attendees, Dea forms a romantic connection with him which is pure of heart. As
Dea cannot see his face (carved into a smile), she connects to him on a deeply personal level which is not about physical beauty but about the
radiance of Gwynplaine's heart.
An astonishing performance by Conrad Veidt.
The film has a new score performed by the Berklee School of Music. Featuring
compositions done by a variety of students of this famed school, this was a huge project developed for the restoration initiative. This is one of the
best efforts I have ever heard for a newly recorded score for a silent film. I don't use those words lightly. The musicians involved delivered a
fantastic experience. The score even reminds one somewhat of the haunting work from composer Shirley Walker for Batman: The Animated
Series (I would not be surprised at all if that iconic fan-favorite score was even an inspiration on some of the music cues). If only all classic
film scores received this level of love and attention to detail.
The exquisite black and white cinematography by Gilbert Warrenton (Panic
in Year Zero, Telephone Operator) is a visual stunner and helps draws audiences into the cinematic world created by the film
with ease. The experience feels eerily hypnotic and a large part of this aspect is the visual cues by the cinematographer. Warrenton's efforts leave a
long-lasting impression. The visuals also highlight the superb costumes by designers David Cox (It's a Great Life) and Vera West
(Shadow of a Doubt).
Featuring tight editing by Edward L. Cahn (Surrender,
Resurrection), The Man Who Laughs feels surprisingly punchy and energetic in the rhythm of the edit. This is no doubt
one of the main reasons the film has remained a favorite of classic silent film enthusiasts. It doesn't slog through any of its takes or cuts. Rather,
the editing and pace feels highly focused and compelling.
J. Grubb Alexander (Svengali, The Trail of the
Octopus) delivers an excellent screenplay which is one of the film's greatest strengths. Having to live up to the original source story written
by the legendary author Victor Hugo is no easy feat. The storytelling carries an authenticity in exploring both the pain felt by the chastised
Gwynplaine and the beating heart of the character's emotions as he connects with Dea. An argument could be made that one of the primary
reasons The Man Who Laughs has withstood the test of time so well is because of the nuanced romantic storytelling: it's absorbing
and uplifts the heart.
There is an immense beauty to this silent classic which manages to grab hold of
one's soul. The film was a passion project for it's director. Filmmaker Paul Leni (The Last Warning, The Cat and the Canary) had enormous ambitions for the project and its clear that
there was a drive behind the filmmaking. Several sequences (such as the action-packed finale) are so ambitious in scope that one wonders how the
producers even managed to pull of the scenes utilizing the technology and resources of the time.
As an adaptation of the classic novel
written by the brilliant author Victor Hugo (Les Miserables), Leni had high stakes to live up to with the production. Thankfully, Leni's efforts ultimately paid off with the end result being a
cinematic concoction which feels just as compelling today as it would have felt for audiences experiencing the film for the first time during the
theatrical run in the 1920's.
The Man Who Laughs Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality
Arriving on Blu-ray from Eureka Entertainment, The Man Who Laughs is presented in 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encoded high definition
presentation in the original full frame aspect ratio. The release uses the 4K scan and restoration completed by Universal Pictures. The presentation on
the release is quite similar to what is found on the Region A Flicker Alley edition (reviewed here).
However, the Eureka Entertainment release produced for the United Kingdom is a little bit different – similar overall, but grain is a bit more
pronounced and some parts look slightly more rough. This is certainly a close match to the Flicker Alley edition and those in European countries will be
fine to purchase this edition over the Flicker Alley release. Though I had a slight preference for the Flicker Alley presentation, The Man Who Laughs
looks exceptional here and the 4K restoration is stunning to behold. Black levels are exceptional and the level of clarity (and definition) on display
is top-notch.
The Man Who Laughs Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality
The release comes with two lossless audio options: uncompressed PCM 2.0 stereo with the Berklee Silent Film Orchestra Score (2018) and
uncompressed PCM 2.0 stereo with the 1928 Movietone Score from the film's original release. The high-resolution audio on the Berklee orchestra score
is top-notch throughout the entire presentation. The audio clarity is astonishing and makes the experience all the more enveloping. The original score
recording quality is noticeably inferior to the brand new recording and should be considered as supplemental.
The Man Who Laughs Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras
Kim Newman on Paul Leni (HD, 12:23)
The Face Deceives (HD, 33:18) is a video essay by David Cairns & Fiona Watson.
Paul Leni and The Man Who Laughs (HD, 13:44) is a video essay by John Soister.
Stills Galleries:
Click through galleries presenting a selection of photographs related to the release and production of The Man Who Laughs.
Production Stills
Behind the Scenes
Costume / Make-up Tests
Exhibition / Trade Ads
Programs / Posters / Heralds
Memorabilia
The Man Who Laughs Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation
The Man Who Laughs is a cinematic masterpiece. The silent film has managed to withstand the test of time and is regarded as one of the
best
achievements in silent film history. The great performance by Conrad Veidt (who inspired The Joker of Batman lore) is astonishing and a
cinematic miracle. The maniacal smile is an iconic element of the silent classic.
Even after more than 100 years after production, The Man Who Laughs remains impressive and the new 4K restoration by Universal
Pictures is well worth seeing. The Eureka Entertainment release includes some exclusive supplements not included on the Flicker Alley edition released
in North America. Fans of the film residing in Region B territories will want to pick up the release. Highly recommended.
