The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Blu-ray Movie

Rating summary

Movie		5.0
Video		4.5
Audio		5.0
Extras		5.0
Overall		5.0

The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Blu-ray Movie Review

"A red sun rises, blood has been spilled this night..."

Reviewed by Kenneth Brown June 17, 2011

There's some good in this world, Mr. Frodo. And it's worth fighting for.

After rejecting Morton Grady Zimmerman's screenplay for producer Al Brodax's proposed 1957 adaptation of "The Lord of the Rings," J.R.R. Tolkien eviscerated their first and only script, particularly as it pertained to "The Two Towers." Tolkien took issue with Brodax and Zimmerman's decision to intercut the splintered fellowship's storylines (rather than tell them one at a time, as the author did in his books), criticized their "preference for fights" and rallied against their use of "blue lights" and "irrelevant magic." He felt the battle of Helm's Deep would be better served on the cutting room floor, balked at stylistic changes made to the dialogue he had so carefully penned, and disagreed with their disregard for the true hearts of his characters. Suffice it to say, Tolkien was irritated and dismayed by Brodax and Zimmerman's treatment. Of course, the full "Lord of the Rings" saga wouldn't make its way onto the silver screen for another forty-four years -- three decades after Tolkien's passing -- when a crafty, daring Kiwi by the name of Peter Jackson was handed the keys to the kingdom.

Frodo, Sam and Gollum gaze down at the Black Gate of Mordor...

So how would Tolkien have responded to Jackson's decidedly sinewy adaptation of The Two Towers? After all, Jackson, like Zimmerman before him, made the deliberate choice to move freely between Aragorn and Frodo's separate journeys. Then there's his battle scenes, chief among them Helm's Deep, which certainly show a penchant (albeit not a preference) for fights. And Weta's visual effects wizardry, which would have most likely given Tolkien some measure of pause. I would humbly suggest, though, that the question of Tolkien's posthumous satisfaction or dissatisfaction be replaced with more relevant questions: How true does Jackson remain to the spirit of Tolkien's characters and tale? Is he eager to alter Tolkien's text or is he merely making tough decisions for the betterment of a film? Does his adaptation retain the heart, muscle and blood of the next leg of Frodo's journey? Does his Two Towers wash over you? Raise the hair on your arms? Draw you in? Move you to tears? In my case, the answer to each question is simple. Jackson, even in departing from Tolkien's text, proves himself a devoted, dutiful steward, and his affection for the original tale is purer and his grip on its nuances is surer than ever.

The extended version of The Two Towers expands and enriches Jackson's theatrical cut with poetic ease; so much so that it's difficult to imagine Jackson, Walsh and Boyens struggling with the decisions they eventually made as much as they did. Sam uses his Elvish rope (in a sequence that ties in nicely with an extended scene in The Fellowship of the Ring), Théodred's funeral is held in Rohan, Merry, Pippin and Treebeard earn more screentime, Old Man Willow (or an incarnation of the character) makes an appearance in Fangorn Forest, Gandalf and Aragorn share a quiet conversation about Frodo, Faramir discovers the boat that carried Boromir's body, flashbacks reveal more of Faramir's backstory and his relationships with Boromir and Denethor, and an extended speech in Osgiliath fleshes out another important milestone in Sam's arc as a character. Other scenes appear throughout -- some significant, some fleeting -- but each one is in keeping with Jackson's vision his extended versions as enhancements, rather than replacements, of his theatrical cuts. And, in many ways, the extended version of The Two Towers is arguably the most rewarding of the trilogy. Its additions and extensions are more essential and revealing than those that grace The Fellowship of the Ring, and more balanced and refined than those that appear in The Return of the King. (Although little can top King's inclusion of Saruman's fate and the Mouth of Sauron's arrival.)

No matter which version you prefer, though -- extended and theatrical -- Jackson and co-writers Fran Walsh and Philippa Boyens deliver an exceedingly judicious, altogether faithful adaptation of "The Two Towers" that's both a seamless continuation of The Fellowship of the Ring and a substantial evolution in the trilogy. In spite of relentlessly dissecting every passage of the book, viciously exorcising entire subplots and characters, rearranging key sequences and events, and making several broad changes to Tolkien's mythos, the sharp-penned threesome evoke much of what the author so poetically spilled on the page, even when making departures from his text. As writers, Jackson, Walsh, and Boyens are so in tune with the substance of Tolkien's "Two Towers" that they're able to adapt it as readily and effortlessly as they adapted "The Fellowship of the Ring" (which was, by all accounts, an easier story to bring to the screen). Paramount to their success was an instinctive understanding of the limitations of a sprawling literary text and the needs of a cohesive and absorbing film. They identified what would work and what wouldn't translate to the screen -- no matter how much it pained them to do so -- and fashioned it into a digestible epic; one that sings a sweet song to those familiar with the original book and one that weaves an engrossing tale for newcomers. Their dialogue is as beautiful and lyrical as Tolkien's, yet never sounds stuffy; their pacing is patient and weighty, yet builds legitimate tension and momentum; and their climactic battles are viscerally conceived and thrillingly envisioned, yet never lessen the impact of anything that comes before or after.

The Two Towers, be it the extended version or theatrical cut, is as perfect a fantasy epic as this feeble mind can imagine, and as perfect a cinematic adaptation of Tolkien's work ("cinematic," not "staunchly faithful," mind you) as The Fellowship of the Ring. Jackson's films will always have their critics; even The Two Towers, arguably the most beloved and critically acclaimed of the three. But I remain amazed. Not just by the film itself, but by its ability to continue speaking to me after so many viewings, to continue drawing viewers to its fold after so many years, to still stand so high above every fantasy film and franchise that's arrived in its wake.

The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality 

All our hopes now lie with two little hobbits, somewhere in the wilderness.

I was already fairly pleased with the VC-1 encoded transfer afforded to The Two Towers' theatrical cut in 2010. And while the Extended Edition's 1080p/AVC-encoded presentation isn't all that different, it does feature several subtle but welcome improvements. A faint hint of edge halos remain, but some of the more distracting bouts of ringing have been tamed or banished altogether. Compression artifacts, though far from a pervasive nuisance in the 2010 theatrical cut release, have all but been eliminated. (Spreading the film across two BD-50 discs helped in that regard, no doubt.) And what little smearing does appear most likely traces back to Jackson and director of photography Andrew Lesnie's tinkering years ago, not an extra helping of studio-applied DNR. (Reports are a bit conflicting, but signs point to the extended edition of The Two Towers being born from a new HD master.) Again though, the differences between the theatrical and extended presentations are small and delicate, and most viewers won't even notice they've been made.

As before, skintones are relatively lifelike, contrast is strong and reliable, and black levels are deep and earthy. Lesnie's bleak colors aren't as far removed from The Fellowship of the Ring's palette as they once were -- Jackson and Lesnie have re-graded the extended edition of Fellowship, making it much darker -- but each scene is faithful to its source. Moreover, unsullied fine textures, crisply detailed rocks and grasslands, wonderfully refined cloaks and well-resolved hairs, pores and shards of bark don't disappoint. Note Gandalf's beard and pocky nose during his battle with the Balrog, Gollum's craggly cheeks, the sun-scorched knolls and stony cliffs of Rohan, the rustling leaves in the Ents' shadowy realm and the grizzled walls of Helm's Deep. Granted, the transfer is no stranger to softness and a number of special effects sequences show their age (Théoden's awakening doesn't hold up and Merry and Pippin's travels with Treebeard remain eyesores), but almost every instance is attributable to the original source, not the studio's subsequent encode. (It's important to keep in mind that Towers was shot more than ten years ago. I can't believe it either.)

I don't have many complaints, actually. Minor crush takes a slight toll and delineation isn't always ideal, but it all seems inherent to the original photography. Noise spikes at times, but it rarely proves to be unruly (at least for very long). And there isn't any significant artifacting, aliasing, banding or other nonsense of their kind to report. I suspect if criticism does arise, it will be of the original print, whether the person issuing the criticism realizes it or not. I can't imagine The Two Towers looking much better than it does here. I'm sure there's room for some further improvement -- a frame here, a frame there -- but I was thoroughly pleased with the results. As to my score, I bobbled between a 4.0 and 4.5, landed squarely on a 4.25 and rounded up to the nearest half-point.

The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality 

Look to my coming on the first light of the fifth day, at dawn look to the east.

No need to break down each individual release here. Like the 2010 theatrical cut releases, the Extended Editions of The Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers, and The Return of the King charge the fields of Blu-ray with a trio of powerful DTS-HD Master Audio surround tracks, all of which allow Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy to storm every home theater, no matter how grand in scale. Dialogue, whether whispered or shouted, is crisp, clean, and intelligible; voices, whether human, beast or ethereal warrior, ring true across the soundfield; and creature cries, whether spittled roars or high-pitched screeches, are sharp and stable. LFE output deserves a score of its own, aggressively supporting every amassing horde, topping tower, rickety weapon of war and exploding wall the various members of the Fellowship encounter. Close your eyes as Wargs ambush a passing caravan. Listen intently as the trees of Fangorn Forest begin to groan and murmur. Try to lift your jaw off the floor when the Uruk-hai forces charge the soon-to-be-toppled defenses of a fortified keep. Environmental ambience never relents (Treebeard's enveloping realm!), directionality is impeccable (the climactic battle at Helm's Deep!), and pans are smoother than Wormtongue's silver tongue (the volley of arrows that sail over those same walls and rain down on advancing foes). Best of all, the experience is as immersive as they come. Howard Shore's masterful score is perfectly prioritized beneath the film's soundscape, gut punch revelations are as pitch-perfect as they are emotional, restless armies will make viewers turn their heads, and the terrifying clamor of orcs, underwater spirits, Uruk-hai, fell beasts and more will unsettle the most steely listener. And dynamics? Prepare yourself. The Two Towers, and really The Lord of the Rings trilogy as a whole, is a sonic powerhouse.

The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras 

Open war is upon you whether you would risk it or not.

Like The Fellowship of the Ring, the Blu-ray edition of the The Two Towers boasts all of the special features that appear on the 2003 Extended Edition DVD, and then some. A feature-length documentary from filmmaker Costa Botes (previously found on the Limited Edition DVD) is included as well, and those who haven't seen it will be thrilled with every fly-on-the-wall inlet to the production it offers. Again, the only complaint that could really be registered against the extras is that they're all presented in standard definition. But considering the sheer volume of content on hand, and the fact that they were all produced in SD, I doubt many fans will get worked up about it.

• Audio Commentaries (Discs 1 & 2): The Two Towers features four full length audio commentaries: the first with director/co- writer Peter Jackson and co-writers Fran Walsh and Philippa Boyens; a second with production designer Grant Major, Weta Workshop creative supervisor Richard Taylor, conceptual designers Alan Lee and John Howe, supervising art director Dan Hennah, art department manager Chris Hennah and Weta Workshop manager Tania Rodger; a third with producer Barrie M. Osborne, executive producer Mark Ordesky, director of photography Andrew Lesnie, editor Mike Horton, additional editor Jabez Olssen, co-producer Rick Porras, composer Howard Shore, visual effects supervisors Jim Rygiel and Joe Letteri, supervising sound editors Ethan van der Ryn and Mike Hopkins, Weta animation designer & supervisor Randy Cook, Weta VFX art director Christian Rivers, Weta VFX cinematographer Brian Van't Hul and Visual Effects DP Alex Funke; and a fourth with actors Elijah Wood, Sean Astin, John Rhys-Davies, Billy Boyd, Dominic Monaghan, Orlando Bloom, Christopher Lee, Sean Bean, Bernard Hill, Miranda Otto, David Wenham, Brad Dourif, Karl Urban, John Noble, Craig Parker and Andy Serkis.
  
  Each commentary has its own strengths -- Jackson and his co-writers are incredibly engaging and informative, the actors are full of insight and good humor, the production team examines the fabric of the film and its release, and the design team details the nuts and bolts of each element that appears on screen -- and very few weaknesses. Silence is a rarity and the mass-member commentaries have been mercifully, meticulously and intelligently edited together using a variety of recording sessions consisting of smaller groups and individuals. Needless to say, audio commentaries don't get much better, or much more engrossing, than those that appear across The Lord of the Rings extended edition releases.
• Easter Egg (Disc 1, SD, 3 minutes): Less of an easter egg and more of a what happens if I click on this icon in the special features sub menu?, this MTV Movie Awards short finds Gollum battling Andy Serkis for the duo's Best Virtual Performance award. It isn't very good... until Gollum starts spouting censored F-bombs that is.
• The Lord of the Rings: War in the North - The Untold Story (Disc 1, HD, 2 minutes): A trailer for the upcoming Snowblind videogame.
• The Appendices Parts 3 & 4 Introduction (Disc 3, SD, 2 minute): Peter Jackson introduces the next two parts of the Extended Edition Appendices; the massive six-part mega-documentary spread across the set's 15 discs.
• J.R.R. Tolkien: Origins of Middle-earth (Disc 3, SD, 29 minutes): Tolkien's friendship with fellow author C.S. Lewis, his wartime experiences on the battlefield, his passion for writing, and the themes, storytelling, characters, language, imagery, structure and enduring relevance and power of Tolkien's tale are at the heart of the set's second Tolkien documentary.
• From Book to Script: Finding the Story (Disc 3, SD, 21 minutes): Tolkien's "The Two Towers" posed a variety of problems that the rest of his trilogy did not. Subsequently, it proved to be the toughest adaptation that Jackson and his co-writers tackled. Thankfully, Jackson isn't interested in making excuses or mounting impenetrable defenses. The filmmakers, cast and crew simply explain the various changes made to the text, detail their devotion to retaining the spirit of Tolkien's tale, and discuss making the best film they possibly could (as opposed to making the most literal adaptation they could). This is yet another fantastic documentary among a slew of fantastic documentaries, and should not be missed.
• Designing and Building Middle-earth (Disc 3, SD, 89 minutes): This section offers two documentaries -- "Designing Middle-earth," an exceedingly extensive 46-minute overview of the work invested in creating the imagery and locations that were eventually brought to life on the screen, and "Weta Workshop," a 44-minute all-encompassing overview of Weta's physical realization of the design team's ideas. Over the course of both documentaries, the creatures, armor, architecture, weapons and cultures are given the Appendices' undivided attention. Two large design galleries, "The Peoples of Middle-earth" and "The Realms of Middle-earth," are available as well.
• Gollum (Disc 3, SD, 44:40 minutes): "Gollum" is divided into four sections. "The Taming of Smeagol" provides an account of the long and intense design period devoted to Gollum -- from drawings to sculptures to maquettes to Weta Digital CG to Andy Serkis' performance -- and all of the changes made along the way. "Andy Serkis Animation Reference" is a before-and-after comparison sequence. "Gollum's Stand In" gives everyone an opportunity to laugh while recalling co-producer Rick Porras' work as Gollum for a day. And yet another design gallery has been added for good measure.
• New Zealand as Middle-earth (Disc 3, SD, 14 minutes): A collection of short featurettes that follow Jackson and his crew as they scout locations in New Zealand. Their discoveries include Emyn Muil, the Dead Marshes, Rohan, Edoras, Ithilien, Fangorn Forest and Helm's Deep.
• Middle-earth Atlas (Disc 3, SD): An interactive map viewers can use to trace the separate journeys of Frodo and Sam, Gandalf, Merry and Pippin, and Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli. A flood of film clips are crammed into the experience as well.
• Elijah Wood Introduction (Disc 4, SD, 1 minute): Actor Elijah Wood introduces The Two Towers' fourth disc.
• Filming The Two Towers (Disc 4, SD, 89 minutes): Principal photography coverage of The Two Towers is split between two documentaries. "Warriors of the Third Age" touches on the film's stunt team, sword fighting, actors training, shooting the battle at Helm's Deep, Viggo Mortensen's comradery with the film's stuntmen and much more. "Cameras in Middle-earth," meanwhile, is a 68-minute monster that expounds upon the trilogy's 15-month shoot, the similarities between the actors' separation and that of their characters, Jackson's use of multiple shooting teams, challenges the director faced with The Two Towers, and a scene-by-scene, battle-by-battle overview of the film's production, from location scouting to filming. A "Production Photos" gallery rounds out the section.
• Visual Effects (Disc 4, SD, 54 minutes): The Two Towers documentaries forge ahead without losing steam. "Visual Effects" examines three aspects of the production -- "Miniatures" pushes in on the film's big-atures, "Weta Digital" tracks Weta's insertion of CG into the film's principle photography, and "Abandoned Concepts" reveals two sequences that never came to fruition, "Slime Balrog" and "Endless Stair," by way of artwork and brief audio commentaries. More design galleries are sprinkled throughout the "Visual Effects" section.
• Editorial: Refining the Story (Disc 4, SD, 22 minutes): Like The Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers features an editorial documentary. Jackson talks about his collaborative edit of Towers and the many, many cuts he and his editor made to scenes before settling on the sequences that appear in the final film.
• Music and Sound (Disc 4, SD, 48 minutes): "Music for Middle-earth" stalks Howard Shore's Two Towers score, "The Soundscapes of Middle-earth" sinks its teeth into the film's sound design, and "Sound Demonstration" is a semi-interactive sound mixing suite of sorts that allows users to hear seven isolated tracks before listening to the scene's final mix.
• The Battle for Helm's Deep is Over... (Disc 4, SD, 9 minutes): The Two Towers Appendices limp through the film's painful post- production period and look ahead to The Return of the King.
• Costa Botes' Two Towers Documentary (Disc 5, SD, 106 minutes): The journey continues in filmmaker Costa Botes' second behind-the-scenes documentary, shot during the filming of The Two Towers. As he did with The Fellowship of the Ring, Botes explores the daily grind of the production from a passive position, blending into the surroundings like a chameleon. Alas, it too is presented in non-anamorphic widescreen, meaning its presentation is far from satisfying, even for an SD documentary.

The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation 

Where is the horse and the rider? Where is the horn that was blowing? They have passed like rain on the mountain, like wind in the meadow. The days have gone down in the West behind the hills into shadow. How did it come to this?

The Extended Edition release of The Two Towers brushes nearer to perfection. The film itself is arguably the best of the trilogy (a trilogy that already towers over most every fantasy film since), its supplemental package is vast and rewarding, and its DTS-HD Master Audio track is outstanding. Yes, a few kinks remain in the otherwise striking video presentation, but they're all easy to overlook, particularly when the rest of Warner's transfer, spread comfortably across two BD-50 discs, is so impressive. It even offers a small upgrade when compared to the theatrical cut's Blu-ray presentation. I couldn't ask for much more from the transfer or the entirety of the 5-disc set.