The Hunchback of Notre Dame / The Hunchback of Notre Dame II Blu-ray Movie

Rating summary

Movie		3.5
Video		3.5
Audio		4.0
Extras		2.0
Overall		3.5

The Hunchback of Notre Dame / The Hunchback of Notre Dame II Blu-ray Movie Review

"All my life I watch them as I hide up here alone..."

Reviewed by Kenneth Brown March 7, 2013

Disney is keenly aware of the appeal and reach of its catalog, down to the best and worst films under the Mouse House banner. Titles like Cinderella and Peter Pan arrive separately and to great fanfare, while other titles shuffle onto shelves en masse, sans the red-carpet treatment afforded their Platinum and Diamond Edition brethren. Last year, it was The Aristocats, The Rescuers, The Rescuers Down Under, Pocahontas, Pocahontas II: Journey to a New World, The Tigger Movie and Lady and the Tramp II: Scamp's Adventure, all of which released in a single week in August. This year the mois du jour is March, and the releases include Robert Zemeckis's Who Framed Roger Rabbit (the fan-favorite odd man out in the March 12th lineup) and a trio of 2-Movie Collection Blu-rays: The Hunchback of Notre Dame and The Hunchback of Notre Dame II, Mulan and Mulan II, and Brother Bear and Brother Bear 2. (Atlantis: The Lost Empire and Atlantis: Milo's Return were originally set for March 12th as well but were unceremoniously and indefinitely delayed without explanation.) And, once again, the deluge is another hit or miss affair, with a classic live-action/animation hybrid, three solid (or at least decent) animated features and a near-unbearable batch of direct-to-video misfires.

Like Mulan, The Hunchback of Notre Dame isn't a true classic, or at least not an undisputed classic. For all its majesty and weight, Disney's 34th animated feature makes a few misguided steps that prevent it from reaching true greatness. Still, it remains one of Disney Animation's most beautiful traditionally animated films and something of a masterpiece in numerous circles. Unfortunately, The Hunchback of Notre Dame II is little more than its ill-begotten direct-to-video offspring. Unnecessary and even a bit unwelcome, it doesn't justify its existence, much less deliver anything of significance, making its imperfect but breathtaking predecessor seem almost flawless by comparison.

The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 4/5

Loosely based on the 1831 Victor Hugo novel of the same name, The Hunchback of Notre Dame tells the tale of Quasimodo (Tom Hulce), a deformed orphan in 15th century Paris raised by a cruel Minister of Justice named Frollo (Tony Jay) and confined to the bell tower of the Notre Dame Cathedral. Humble and unassuming, the kindly Quasimodo couldn't be more unlike the manipulative, self-righteous judge, and grows up believing he must keep himself hidden away lest the outside world condemn him as a monster. But when Quasimodo ventures outside the hallowed halls of Notre Dame and is befriended by a caring Gypsy named Esmeralda (Demi Moore), he slowly begins to realize Frollo isn't the saint he believed. Now, with Esmeralda in danger, Frollo's captain of the guard (Kevin Kline) defying the Minister's murderous orders, and rebellion brewing in the Parisian streets, Quasimodo must choose between love and loyalty and become the man his only friends -- stone gargoyles Hugo (Jason Alexander), Victor (Charles Kimbrough) and Laverne (Mary Wickes) -- know him to be.

Let's start with the aforementioned missteps, which really comes down to two things: the gargoyles and the climactic battle outside the walls of Notre Dame. First, Hugo and company. Remove the gargoyles, their forced comic relief and the tragically inserted pop culture references and The Hunchback of Notre Dame is suddenly more even and more satisfying. Taken as imaginary creatures created by Quasimodo during his lifelong isolation (think Tom Hanks and Wilson), the trio are easier to tolerate. Taken as they are, though, they're not shades of Quasimodo's mind, they're distractions. Irritations. They kill the established tone and, worse, lend levity where it isn't needed. Scenes like the climactic battle, which departs from the dark, serious drama of the first two acts with ungainly slapstick, cheap gags and even a wince-inducing Wizard of Oz nod. The influx of comedy -- poorly executed comedy at that -- is baffling.

Thankfully, the screentime granted to the gargoyles and everything that comes with them is relatively limited and, for the most part, fairly easy to overlook so long as you focus on everything directors Kirk Wise and Gary Trousdale get right. Notre Dame is one of the rare films that examine the evils of self-serving religious men without once demonizing faith or religion itself. It's a surprisingly mature Disney animated feature; one that doesn't shy away from the darkness and desires burning within Frollo, Quasimodo's struggle to even entertain the idea of being a hero, and everything from bigotry to obsession to fear of those who are different. Children will gravitate to the film's themes of acceptance and friendship while adults will hone in on its far more subtle dissections of sin, hypocrisy and love. Layered on top of Hunchback's engrossing story and characters are Alan Menken and Stephen Schwartz's sweeping songs and Disney's gorgeous animation; some of the best and most cohesive of the Disney Renaissance. The result? A largely invigorating animated musical that stands as one of the finest mid-to-late '90s Disney animated features (Pocahontas, Hercules, Mulan and Fantasia 2000), second only to Tarzan, and the best since Aladdin and The Lion King.

The Hunchback of Notre Dame II - 2/5

Released six years after the first film, The Hunchback of Notre Dame II, like other Disney direct-to-video sequels before and after it, doesn't have a grasp on the elements that make the original so memorable. The animation is beyond lackluster and a dire downgrade from the stunning visuals that came before it. The songs aren't nearly as integral or revealing, nobly searching for purpose but finding little. The script is weak, the stakes too low, the new characters less interesting and the conflicts less meaningful, while Frollo -- one of the vilest villains in Disney history -- is followed by master thief Sarousch (Michael McKean), who doesn't hold a candle to the malevolent Minister of Justice. As to the story itself, the sequel focuses on Sarousch's apprentice Madellaine (Jennifer Love Hewitt), who cozies up to Quazimodo (Tom Hulce) so her master can steal La Fidèle, one of Notre Dame's bells. She finds more to the deformed bell-ringer than she anticipated, and soon develops genuine feelings for her oblivious mark. Demi Moore and Kevin Kline return as Esmeralda and Phoebus, now married with a six-year-old son named Zephyr (Haley Joel Osment)... who pitches in to help thwart Sarousch's plot.

Young children will still enjoy the return to Notre Dame, not to mention catching up with Quasimodo and his chatty gargoyle pals (Jason Alexander and Charles Kimbrough return, with Jane Withers replacing the late Mary Wickes). Like the original, though, the gargoyles may as well be a rash, this time they're just paired with a perky love interest and a precocious tot. Because that makes it all better. If I sound harsh, it's because The Hunchback of Notre Dame II is one of the most maligned direct-to-video Disney sequels and doesn't have much redeeming value. (Again, outside of the short-lived hour -- literally -- of joy it will bring kids itching to check in with Quasi.) Animated sequels are already tricky propositions, and Notre Dame II rarely feels like anything more than a not-so-clever cash-in. Disney has shown it can pull off a decent DTV sequel (The Lion King 1½ wasn't so bad), it just requires an idea worth the investment. Rather than turn to real history for inspiration or find new inventive ways to plumb the works of Victor Hugo with Quasimodo and company, the studio settled on a half-baked heist flick set in 15th century Paris. Not exactly an idea worth investing in... and yet here we are, with The Hunchback of Notre Dame II.

The Hunchback of Notre Dame / The Hunchback of Notre Dame II Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality 

The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 4/5

For all the beauty and stunning animation on display, The Hunchback of Notre Dame's 1080p/AVC-encoded video transfer has a few issues worth noting. Banding and artifacting appear from time to time (although rarely to any debilitating degree, minus the skies behind Frollo during Phoebus' near-execution), aliasing graces a handful of shots and darker scenes are at odds with the presentation's contrast leveling. Still, the good far outweighs the bad, making any mishap in the image an easily overlooked deformity. Colors are warm and vibrant, with bold primaries, rich purples and golds, and deep blacks. Detail is excellent too. The animators' line art is crisp and clean on the whole, the brushstrokes and textures of the hand-painted backgrounds are wonderfully resolved, and the CG elements fare well, even under high definition scrutiny. Moreover, significant macroblocking, crush, noise and other anomalies are either kept to a bare minimum or nowhere to be found, and most scenes come within a hair's breadth of perfection. The studio's technical encode isn't as proficient as other Disney Animation Blu-ray presentations, but it's close enough to earn respectable marks.

Click here for full review and additional screenshots


The Hunchback of Notre Dame II - 3/5

The Hunchback of Notre Dame II and its 1080p/AVC-encoded video presentation aren't waylaid by many technical issues, but the sequel's terribly mediocre animation and direct-to-video source make it difficult to enjoy any of it. Colors are skewed and off-putting (despite the fact that the image is inherently brighter), primaries are loud but lack real punch, black levels waver and contrast is all over the place. Granted, the line art is smooth and satisfying for the most part, and the original animation is represented rather faithfully. But minor artifacting and instances of banding are present, dirt and dust litter the image, and print damage -- specks, lines and scratches -- make the 2002 production look as if it were minted twenty years earlier. When push comes to shove, the encode holds up I suppose. So there's that. Otherwise, the sequel doesn't have much to offer the high definition viewer other than a nominal upgrade to the DVD.

Click here for full review and additional screenshots

The Hunchback of Notre Dame / The Hunchback of Notre Dame II Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality 

The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 4/5

The Hunchback of Notre Dame bellows from its bell tower with a strong, stalwart DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track. LFE output resonates with power and presence, infusing weight and gravitas into both the dramatic and musical narrative that develop. The rear speakers, meanwhile, help bring the Parisian streets, Gypsy hideaways and vast Notre Dame Cathedral sound as busy, bustling or as sacred as each locale should. Directional effects are free to roam and pans are disarmingly smooth, while dynamics bring nuance to the film's already intricate sound design. And dialogue is crystal clear, perfectly grounded and carefully prioritized within the mix... which is unfortunately something I can't quite say about the song lyrics. Though always intelligible and typically balanced within each song, there are occasions where lyrics are overwhelmed by soaring orchestration. It doesn't ever emerge as a worrisome issue, but audiophiles will take notice. That said, The Hunchback of Notre Dame's lossless audio pairs neatly with its video presentation to produce a stirring spectacle. It isn't ideal, but it isn't without grand merit either.

The Hunchback of Notre Dame II - 3.5/5

Direct-to-video sequel analyses usually boil down to one half-hearted point: it's decent. It is, after all, a DTV sequel. And The Hunchback of Notre Dame II is no different. An objective success and a subjective bore, the sequel's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track does everything it should yet underwhelms all the same. Dialogue is clean and clear, song lyrics are well-prioritized (almost too dominant, truth be told), LFE output is solid, rear speaker activity is light and lively, and a few playful directional effects lend welcome movement to the soundscape. The sequel's sound design was clearly created on a budget, but it tackles every routine task with technical aplomb. No complaints here. No high praise either.

The Hunchback of Notre Dame / The Hunchback of Notre Dame II Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras 

The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 2.5/5

• Audio Commentary: Producer Don Hahn and directors Kirk Wise and Gary Trousdale deliver an extensive, low-key overview of the production and discuss the adaptation, development and execution of the story, as well as the film's voice casting, characters, animation, songs and other key elements.
• The Making of The Hunchback of Notre Dame (SD, 28 minutes): Jason Alexander hosts this corny but nevertheless informative DVD-era trip behind the scenes of Disney's 34th animated feature, from its place in the Disney canon to creating the characters, blending talent and technology, the music and more.
• Multi-Language Reel (SD, 3 minutes): "A Guy Like You," around the world.
• Sneak Peeks and Trailers (HD, 9 minutes): The Little Mermaid, Monsters University, Planes, Mulan, Return to Never Land, the next, as yet-untitled Tinker Bell movie, Super Buddies and Epic Mickey 2.

The Hunchback of Notre Dame II - 1/5

• Behind the Scenes (SD, 5 minutes): Jennifer Love Hewitt is highlighted in this Disney Channel promo.
• A Gargoyle's Life (SD, 3 minutes): "It's Not Easy Being a Gargoyle" in this slapped together short.

The Hunchback of Notre Dame / The Hunchback of Notre Dame II Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation 

The Hunchback of Notre Dame is a worthy addition to any Disney Animation collection. It's flawed, yes. But it has too much to offer to allow a few chatty gargoyles and cringe-inducing gags to spoil one of the later Disney Renaissance's best films. The Hunchback of Notre Dame II is not a worthy sequel, though. Direct-to-video or no. Lazy and tiresome, it hobbles along for a ghastly hour before throwing in the towel and rolling credits. Thus the marketing genius of the 2-Movie Collection, which saddles the good with the bad. Fortunately, both trips to Notre Dame are blessed with strong AV presentations, even if special features are few and far between. So add this one to your cart for The Hunchback of Notre Dame alone, treat the sequel as an extra and reap the singular reward.