7.7 | / 10 |
| Users | 0.0 | |
| Reviewer | 4.5 | |
| Overall | 4.5 |
A rebellious U.S. Army Major is assigned a dozen convicted murderers for a suicide mission code-named Operation Amnesty.
Starring: Lee Marvin, Ernest Borgnine, Charles Bronson, Jim Brown, John Cassavetes| War | Uncertain |
| Drama | Uncertain |
| Action | Uncertain |
Video codec: MPEG-4 AVC
Video resolution: 1080p
Aspect ratio: 1.85:1
Original aspect ratio: 1.85:1
English: LPCM Mono
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 6.1
English SDH
Blu-ray Disc
Single disc (1 BD)
Slipcover in original pressing
Region A (B, C untested)
| Movie | 4.5 | |
| Video | 4.0 | |
| Audio | 4.5 | |
| Extras | 5.0 | |
| Overall | 4.5 |
When Universal tried to cash in on the renewed popularity of World War II films after the rousing success of (Fox's) Patton*, they attempted to recruit a so-called "all star cast" for what ended up looking very
much like one of the studio's then au courant "world premiere" made for television outings, the largely lamentable 1976 Midway. It may be slightly ironic, then, that around a decade
earlier Robert Aldrich assembled what ultimately was recognized as one of the most gobsmacking arrays of "all star" talent ever put
together, at least on the masculine side of the ledger and with regard to a war film. Virtually every frame of The Dirty Dozen is rife with
great performances from an astoundingly diverse retinue of performers ranging from Lee Marvin to Ernest Borgnine to John Cassavetes to Donald
Sutherland to Richard Jaeckel to Robert Ryan to Jim Brown to Charles Bronson to Telly Savalas to George Kennedy to Ralph Meeker to (well, maybe
there's an exception or two) Mr. "Lemon Tree" himself, Trini Lopez. The
fascinating thing about this cast is that several of the performers hadn't quite hit their stride yet in terms of international superstardom,
which may make their relatively early performances in this film all the more interesting. Also kind of interesting is the fact that despite this film's
outsized reputation, it's only had one prior 1080 release, a 2007 (!) outing from Warner Brothers (review link below). Arrow is now revisiting the
film in standalone 4K UHD and 1080 editions (both with an additional 1080 disc of bonus features).
*My father was a celebrated battalion commander under Patton and provided technical assistance to the film. We were invited to the Seattle
premiere during a time when my father was Commanding General at Ft. Lawton (no longer extant) and Senior Officer at Ft. Lewis, and when the
film began and George C. Scott started that inimitable monologue, my Dad leaned over and whispered in my ear, "Those may be Patton's words,
but that sure as hell ain't his voice. He had the squeakiest little girl's voice you've ever heard!" There are some online examples of Patton speaking
which tend to back up my Dad's assessment.


Note: Arrow sent a check disc for purposes of this 1080 review, but a full retail final set for purposes of the The Dirty Dozen 4K Blu-ray review. I'm assuming that per Arrow's standard
operating procedure, the packaging, including the insert booklet, is the same for both resolutions.
The Dirty Dozen is presented on Blu-ray courtesy of Arrow Video with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 1.85:1. Arrow's insert
booklet contains the following information about the presentation:
The Dirty Dozen has been restored by Arrow Films and is presented in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio with restored original mono, a restored 70mm 6 track stereophonic mix, as well as a legacy 5.1 audio mix. For the UHD presentation, the film is presented in 4K resolution in HDR10 and Dolby Vision.Marty was less than thrilled with the now ancient 1080 release from Warner Brothers, and reactions to this new presentation may depend on whether the viewer is a "glass half full" or "glass half empty" type. While overall this is a huge upgrade over the old 1080 release, many of the anomalies Marty mentioned in his review are unfortunately still on display here, and may tend to indicate that the negative was simply not in great shape to begin with, something that in and of itself may help to explain the curious lack of repeated disc re-releases of the film after that original 1080 release in 2007. There are undeniably large variances throughout this presentation in both color temperature and densities, and grain structure can also be highly variable, though in my probably not so humble opinion, all of these issues are only exacerbated in Arrow's 4K edition with HDR. As Marty mentioned in his review, the first part of the film seems to be especially badly afflicted with these drops in quality and some of the opening meeting between Marvin and Borgnine feature at least some interstitial snippets that are in very ragged looking condition. Throughout the presentation thereafter, while large swaths of the film can look at least relatively excellent, with a nicely vivid palette and some commendable detail levels, there can be intermittent moments where the image looks degraded and slightly brown. Also as Marty mentioned in his review, things tend to improve markedly toward the end of the presentation. In the best looking moments, the palette is nicely suffused, though flesh tones can look a bit flushed at times, and fine detail is expressive. This is another instance where the "decreased" resolution of this format and SDR may actually make the viewing experience at least a bit more consistent looking when compared to Arrow's 4K release.The 6.0 mix presented in this release is presented in the way it would have been for the original 70mm theatrical screenings. It requires a 7.1 surround sound setup to be listened to correctly.
The original 35mm camera negative was scanned at 4K / 16 bit resolution at Warner Brothers Motion Picture Imaging. Additional film elements were scanned to replace damaged portions of the negative. The film was restored in 4K resolution and colour graded at Duplitech.
The audio mixes were restored by Žorsteinn Gislason.
All materials sourced for this new mater were made available by Warner Brothers.

The Dirty Dozen receives a decided audio upgrade with this release, as the old Warner Brothers 1080 disc featured only lossy Dolby Digital tracks. Here there are LPCM Mono, DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and DTS-HD Master Audio 6.1 options, and they all sound boisterously energetic, with excellent fidelity. Those who (like me) like to toggle between the codecs will find all sorts of interesting differences, though that said, even the mono track offers an excellent mix with a surprisingly forceful midrange and low end. That said, "jumping" up to 5.1 and then 6.1 can show impressive opening up of the soundstage in both effects and maybe a bit surprisingly the rousing score by De Vol. Surround activity is nicely imaged, and effects are often directional. The low end on both of the surround tracks can be very powerful. Dialogue is rendered cleanly and clearly throughout. Optional English subtitles are available.

Disc One
- Commentary by Alain Silver & James Ursini
- Cast, Crew & Experts Commentary
- On Set (HD; 14:00)
- Lee Marvin Interview (HD; 6:11)

The excerpts in the insert booklet by Dwayne Epstein are culled from a book with the subtitle The Most Iconic WWII Movie of All Time, and if some may want to quibble with that assessment, there's no denying that The Dirty Dozen is certainly one of the most iconic WWII movies of all time. This new presentation is undeniably an improvement over the old lackluster 1080 release, but expectations may need to be pretty severely tempered since the source elements can show rather large variances in quality. Those bumpy moments aside, though, this offers stellar audio and some really appealing supplements. This is another case where I personally preferred the 1080 SDR presentation to the 4K UHD HDR presentation, though of course individual mileage may vary. Highly recommended.