Rating summary
Movie | | 4.5 |
Video | | 5.0 |
Audio | | 4.5 |
Extras | | 3.5 |
Overall | | 4.5 |
The Congress Blu-ray Movie Review
Who Were You (Do I Really Wanna Know)?
Reviewed by Michael Reuben December 2, 2014
Even as he was releasing his multi-award-winning 2008 animated documentary, Waltz with
Bashir, Israeli director Ari Folman was already planning his next, even more ambitious
undertaking, The Congress, which would take another five years to complete. Inspired by Polish
science fiction writer Stanislaw Lem's 1971 novel, The Futorological Congress, Folman
envisioned a dystopian future in which people surrendered their freedom to an unreal world not
simply through the magic of drugs (as Lem had forecast) but through the digital machinations of
the entertainment industry. As a filmmaker himself, Folman thought he knew all the industry's
tricks, but in making The Congress, he discovered that reality was catching up to his vision faster
than he anticipated. Scenes that he had scripted as fantasy were becoming technologically
feasible, and significant parts of The Congress were rewritten during production to incorporate
the latest breakthroughs.
Like Waltz with Bashir, The Congress begins with what appears to be solid reality, then launches
into a realm where nothing is certain, including time, space and identity. The same team that
created the nightmare worlds for Waltz with Bashir went even further, imagining countless
fantasy landscapes, some friendly, some not. About 60% of the film is animated. Wherever you
think The Congess is going, you're probably wrong. At the end, though, it is possible to look
back and realize that Folman's story has an organic integrity that unifies its many shifting layers
and makes its strange world worth visiting repeatedly.
At the center of
The Congress is Robin Wright, who is played by the real Robin Wright and
shares key elements of her biography. The film's Robin Wright is a character constructed by the
actress and Folman to be entirely separate from the actress who plays her, but Folman's essential
strategy is to blur the line between fiction and reality from the outset. Thus,
The Congress' Robin
Wright is chiefly remembered for her radiant performances in
The Princess Bride and
Forrest
Gump. Since then, however, she has rejected many attractive offers, never starred in a box office
hit, and acquired a bad reputation in the industry. In the film's opening scene, she is mercilessly
reproached by her long-time agent, Al (Harvey Keitel, in one of his best performances), who
wants her to accept an unusual offer from a huge entertainment conglomerate, Miramount.
The offer, as explained by a reptilian senior executive, Jeff Green (Danny Huston), is literally the
last contract she'll ever sign, because Miramount is buying her entire identity. Everything she is
as an actress will be digitized, and the studio will no longer need her participation to make
movies. In exchange, she must agree never to act again. Al supplies an ambitious young attorney
named Steve (Michael Stahl-David) to represent Robin in negotiating the contract for this new
frontier in entertainment law, where there are no opportunities for re-negotiation once the studio
has the actor's digital self.
Though Robin initially refuses, she is ultimately forced to accept the contract because of the cost
of treating her son, Aaron (Kodi Smit-McPhee), for a degenerative disease that is slowly
destroying his sight and hearing, despite the efforts of a sympathetic specialist, Dr. Baker (Paul
Giamatti, who wanted to be part of the film even though he was mystified by the script). Many
elements of this long opening section of
The Congress make it clear that Robin's greatest loyalty
in life is to Aaron and his older sister, Sarah (Sami Gayle). In one of the film's most powerful
scenes, Al uses this fact—and everything else he knows about Robin from their long
relationship—to elicit the intense emotions from her that the digital scanners require for a
successful "capture". (The sequence was shot in a real scanning facility that Folman and his crew
were shown during production). The scene, which took weeks to rehearse, is an acting tour de
force that represents the last gasp of traditional human interaction before both Robin and Al
surrender to the digital future that is sweeping them both aside.
Twenty years later, Robin is invited to speak at the "Futurist Congress" in Abrahama City hosted
by Miramount, which has now become "Miramount-Nagasaki". As Peter Green predicted, the
technology that transformed Robin into a digital character has been rendered obsolete, although
advertisements can still be seen for the sci-fi franchise called
Rebel Robot Robin in which her
avatar continues to star. Current technology allows people to become animated characters in a
landscape that resembles
Who
Framed Roger Rabbit?
's Toon Town, if it had been drawn by Max
Fleischer. Abrahama City is just such a "restricted animated zone", and the "Futurist Congress"
is the occasion for a Steve Jobs-like figure to announce Miramount-Nagasaki's latest advance:
consumable characters. No longer will viewers have to watch Robin Wright in movies made by
the studio. They can drink her in a milkshake and
become her. They can become anyone,
anywhere, at any time, and animated zones will no longer be restricted. Tomorrow when you
leave here, announces the corporate cheerleader, it will be as if you take Abrahama City with
you.
Robin's presence at the Futurist Congress is intended to be much like that of a dutiful star at a PR
event. Her job is to say "great idea!" and no more. Then she can head back home to Aaron, now a
young man. Ironically, it is Aaron's condition that predicted the developments announced at the
Congress. As Dr. Baker described twenty years ago, Aaron was taking in all the sensations he
could so that, when his hearing and sight failed, he would have a rich supply of raw materials for
a vivid interior life. Miramount-Nagasaki is offering something similar to everyone, but instantly
and without effort—and Robin objects to participating in such a commercial venture. So,
apparently do others, because the Congress is attacked by some sort of rebel force. Or maybe
Robin just imagines that, just as she dreams about violating her contract the night before the
Congress.
Indeed, the last third of
The Congress demonstrates the unpredictability of the imagination, as the
film shoots off into unexpected places that, like so many dreams, are strange and yet oddly
familiar. Robin may be rescued from the rebel attack by a cartoon figure named Dylan Truliner
(voiced by Jon Hamm), who seems to know her. She may be executed at the hands of Gestapo-like police led by someone who
resembles Jeff Green.
She may be cryogenically frozen by a man
who looks like the former cinematographer (Christopher B. Duncan) who scanned her for
Miramount twenty years ago. She may fly kites, as Aaron used to, or she may grow wings and fly
herself. But these and many other experiences may be no more than vivid hallucinations
unleashed by the inventive chemicals synthesized by Miramount-Nagasaki.
What seems reasonably certain, however, is that Robin does ultimately awaken into the "real"
world, because
The Congress has one final live-action sequence near the end that appears to draw
a clear distinction between reality and the chemically-induced fantasyland that each individual
creates for him- or herself. What Robin finds in the non-animated world is very different from
what she last saw before entering Abrahama City. And the choices that she must make there are
not easy.
The Congress Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality
Both the live-action and animated portions of The Congress were shot digitally, but unlike the
fictitious studio in the film, the team of animators and the live-action cinematographer, Mikal
Englert, did not eliminate real actors from the equation. Even for the animated sequences, the
lead actors performed in pantomime, and the animators used their gestures and expressions as
references for storyboards, which were then animated digitally. (As in Waltz with Bashir, no rotoscoping was used.)
Drafthouse Films' 1080p, AVC-encoded Blu-ray has presumably been sourced directly from
digital files and, except for possible differences in compression and disc authoring, should be
identical to versions released in other regions. Both the live-action and animated sequences are
superb, with exceptional clarity and detail and an expressive palette of colors that ranges from
the riot of hues greeting Robin when she enters the restricted animated zone to the dark recesses
when she and Dylan are hiding underneath Abrahama City. The intense white LED lights of the
scanning session register their intensity without blooming, and the pools of blackness outside
from which Al speaks to Robin while she is being scanned are appropriately dark and inky. As
strange and unsettling as it often is, The Congress is filled with images to be savored and
revisited, and the Blu-ray's quality facilitates that experience.
Drafthouse has mastered the film with an average bitrate 31.996 Mbps. Once you see the
complexity of some of the animated sequences, you will understand why.
The Congress Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality
A running theme in Folman's commentary whenever he discusses the film's soundtrack is his
desire to find the right balance between sounds. It is clear that he did not want sound effects to
draw attention to themselves, thereby interrupting the dream-like spell of the film. The Congress'
lossless DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix is filled with interesting effects that come and go throughout the
surround field, including the complex of sound that accompanies Aaron's kite-flying (which is
different for Aaron than for those around him), the various tones Dr. Baker uses to test his
hearing (heard from Aaron's perspective, as he reads the lips of the doctor and his mother talking
about him), the surge of power that Robin experiences in the scanning booth, the riot of voices
and cartoon effects that she encounters as she transitions to animation in Abrahama City—and
many other examples.
But none of these moments overpowers one's hearing with the "Listen to me!" sensation that
makes a Blu-ray disc so-called "demo material". The effects have been dialed down to a point
where they seem to slip naturally into place with the increasingly strange events transpiring
onscreen. The reflective, even doleful orchestral score by Max Richter (a veteran of Waltz with
Bashir) has more of a presence than any of the effects, and that, too, is by design.
The Congress Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras
The extras overlap with, but are not identical to, those contained on the Region B Blu-ray
previously released by ARP Sélection. Of particular note is that Drafthouse's disc replaces the
"Making Of" featurette with an informative interview with Robin Wright.
- Commentary with Director Ari Folman, Production Designer David Polonsky and
Animation Director Yani Goodman: The more substantive portion of the commentary
accompanies the live-action segment, where Folman is speaking solo. There he discusses
the project's long gestation, many of its themes and his collaboration with Wright. Once
the film enters its mostly animated portion, Folman is joined by Polonsky and Goodman,
and the tone changes. The three collaborators cannot resist laughing and joking, and one
must listen carefully for the tidbits of information that slip out between the wisecracks.
Of perhaps greatest interest (and frustration) is the revelation that nearly an hour of
material was cut from the film late in post-production. Maybe someday these deleted
scenes will be made available. (Note: Internal references indicate that this is the same
commentary included on the Region B Blu-ray.)
- Robin Wright at The Congress (1080i; 1.78:1; 9:26): This interview with the film's
star
allows her to present her recollection of the initial meeting with Folman in which they
agreed to undertake the project, to reflect on the film's themes and to describe the
production process.
- :30 Spot (1080i; 1.78:1; 0:33): A brief teaser.
- Trailers
- Booklet: Drafthouse's insert for this release includes stills from the film, a "director's
note", a "director's Q & A", and film and disc credits.
The Congress Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation
The Congress is a challenging and provocative film, the kind that will not yield all or even most
of its secrets on a single viewing. It's no accident that Folman's favorite film of all time is
Stanley Kubrick's 2001: A Space
Odyssey, a film
that has inspired wonder in many (and
boredom in some) but must be seen more than once to be fully enjoyed. In its own way, The
Congress is just as ambitious, and Folman is the first to admit that he cannot be the final arbiter
of his accomplishment. In the director's Q&A reprinted in the booklet insert, he says: "I think
this is the beauty of filmmaking: once you finish your work, it's not up to you anymore; it's up to
the audience. All I need to do now is sit back and listen to them. Maybe then I'll have a chance to
learn what I did." Highly recommended.