Rating summary

Movie		3.0
Video		4.5
Audio		4.5
Extras		2.0
Overall		3.5

Planes 3D Blu-ray Movie Review

Reaching for the skies with a terrific AV presentation...

Reviewed by Kenneth Brown November 21, 2013

High above the world of Cars comes a low-altitude spin-off that never quite takes off. That's right, three aviation puns in one sentence. And if that has you rolling your eyes, brace yourself for director Klay Hall's Planes, a well-intentioned family-friendly racer sure to entertain younger kids, and just the kids. There's nothing particularly terrible about the film, and it's certainly not as bad as you've probably heard. Still, the animation lacks the fresh coat of paint typical of most theatrically released CG-animated spectacles, Jeffrey M. Howard's screenplay relies heavily on familiar cliché after familiar cliché and, sorry to say, the voice cast isn't all that special. Not so surprising considering the psuedo-sequel began its life as a DisneyToon Studios direct-to-video project and was only later promoted to feature film once the powers that be started to see box office potential. And yet Planes remains a decidedly direct-to-video adventure, with Hall and company distilling elements of Cars and Cars 2 into a cute, harmless, ultimately unremarkable underdog story most parents have sat through a hundred times before.

"I'm just trying to prove that maybe, just maybe, I can do more than what I was built for."

When a crop duster with big dreams named Dusty (Cook) defies all odds and narrowly qualifies for the globe-spanning Wings Across the World race, he finds himself jetting from New York to Iceland, Germany, India, Nepal, Shanghai, Mexico and back across the United States. To win, he'll have to outmanuever and outrace an array of international fliers, including mean-spirited reigning champ, Ripslinger (Roger Craig Smith), and his toadies, Ned and Zed (Gabriel Iglesias); French-Canadian racer, Rochelle (Julia Louis-Dreyfus); stuffy Brit, Bulldog (John Cleese); passionate Mexican Gee Bee, El Chupacabra (Carols Alazraqui); and Indian love interest Ishani (Priyanka Chopra). And it'll take everything Dusty's got, along with a little help from his friends: best friend Chug (Brad Garrett), mechanic Dottie (Teri Hatcher), reluctant mentor Skipper Riley (Stacey Keach), forklift Sparky (Danny Mann), Super Hornet duo Bravo and Echo (Top Gun alumni Val Kilmer and Anthony Edwards), and others who rally behind the crop-dusting upstart.

Despite Hall and Howard's best efforts -- and the two do make a concerted effort -- there's not a lot to Planes that isn't derived from the series' core films. From the quaint but sharply penned Cars comes the clash of vehicular cultures and destinies, the racing scene, a fish out of water adventure, a romantic subplot, a crusty old racing mentor haunted by his past, a cocky rival desperate to win at all costs (he's even green and black, just like ol' Chick Hicks), several sidekicks in the making, and, of course, a glimpse into the eerie but amusing world of sentient cars with no human masters. (Why is Dusty dusting crops exactly? Other than the fact that he's a crop duster?) From the maligned Cars 2 comes the international hotspots, a colorful cast of multinational racers (each one showcasing a bigger stereotype than the last), the thrills and chills of a worldwide race mixed with... you get the idea. Planes is at its finest when imagining how a society of planes would function in the larger Cars world, and when humanizing its aeros and autos. But sparks of imagination don't seem to come as freely or frequently as before, and Dusty's rise to fame is far more derivative than it is original.

Ironically, had Planes never dared to dream more than a direct-to-video dream, it would have been more successful. The film struggles to inflate itself to theatrical proportions, reaching for the stars and barely lifting off the ground. There are laughs to be had, an exciting but predictable race to follow, and enough lovable personalities -- yes, even Cook's Dusty -- to keep the movie in the air. It rarely soars, though, and even at its best, tends to skim the surface of its potential. Adults would do well to watch the disc's behind-the-scenes featurette, "Klay's Flight Plan", and only then giving Planes a go. Realizing how much of the film was a personal passion project for Hall makes for a richer experience. The story still only skims the surface, but the heart it proudly wears on its wings suddenly begins to shine that much brighter. Kids, on the other hand, needn't invest any prep time. Planes will strike anyone under ten as a fun, wondrous race across the skies of one of their favorite animated universes; one with a few life lessons worth reinforcing. (Minus the old you can be anything you want to be when you grow up myth, which most of us spread to children all too eagerly even though we know full well it's little more than a lovely sentiment.) As family entertainment geared for the grade school set goes, it excels. As a Pixar spin-off, though, it lacks a certain level of magic, wit and refinement.

Planes 3D Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality 

Disney's Planes excels on Blu-ray in both 3D and 2D, with only a hint of banding creeping into the otherwise pristine 1080p/MVC-encoded 3D experience and AVC-encoded 2D presentation. In 3D, depth and dimensionality are notably dazzling, with plane noses that jut out from the screen and vast international vistas that stretch into the distance. Foreground objects exhibit welcome pop at every turn, races are that much more exciting, and the fun kids will have is that much more infectious. All the while, colors are bright, vibrant and playful, bathed in convincing light and shadow that isn't undone by the added dimness of the 3D glasses. Primaries remain strong and black levels inky, with consistent contrast and unhindered clarity to boot. Detail is quite striking too, with crisp edges and exacting textures. Crosstalk is almost non-existent (for those whose displays are prone to ghosting) and aliasing is never a concern. Nor is macroblocking, ringing or any other unsightly anomaly for that matter. And while, yes, there's a bit of filmic, wind-born softness present whenever Dusty and his competitors lift high above the Earth, it never amounts to an issue, and really only enhances the illusion of flight. Planes may not be the prettiest Pixar sequel or spin-off, or the most engaging 3D animated adventure, but it holds its own beautifully.

Planes 3D Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality 

Perhaps more thrilling is Planes' DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 surround track, even if the film's original sound design isn't really all that engrossing. Dialogue is crystal clear and perfectly prioritized, without anything in the way of muffled or buried lines. Voices tend to float in the mix, but no more so than in most animated films. LFE output, meanwhile, embraces every engine chug and roar, propeller drone, and dive-bomb attack, making the most of the adventure's every racing sequence. The rear speakers are quite active as well, with an endless assortment of directional and ambient effects. Racers zoom seamlessly from one channel to the next, the soundfield is suitably enveloping, and hardfought losses and narrow victories take full advantage of every asset at their disposal. Quieter moments are slightly flatter and less immersive, but no matter. Planes sounds as good as it looks, and as far as I can surmise, couldn't sound much better.

Planes 3D Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras 

• Exclusive Musical Scene: Franz's Song (HD, 3 minutes): Director Klay Hall and producer Traci Balthazor-Flynn introduce a finished deleted sequence featuring the diminutive Franz that takes place shortly after Dusty arrives in Germany.
• Klay's Flight Plan (HD, 16 minutes): This production featurette tracks the development of the project, the animation team's hands-on research, Hall's lifelong love of airplanes and aeronautics, and his very personal connection to the film, which he shares with his two sons while taking a look at the real planes that inspired the movie's characters.
• Deleted Scenes (HD, 8 minutes): Hall and Balthazor-Flynn share two unfinished deleted scenes: a training montage presented via animated storyboards and a Taj Mahal sequence via pre-viz animation.
• Meet the Racers (HD, 7 minutes): Meet El Chu, Ripslinger, Dusty and Ishani.
• Top 10 Fliers (HD, 6 minutes): An educational tie-in that counts down the top ten real-life fliers of all time.

3D Blu-ray/BD/DVD/Digital Copy Combo Pack Contents (Subject to Change): The initial combo pack release of Planes features a slipcover (with the original pressing), two separate BD-50 discs (one 3D, one 2D), a standard DVD copy of the film, and a downloadable digital copy that "works with iTunes."

Planes 3D Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation 

Planes would have been better off abandoning the racing scene of the first two Cars movies and focusing instead on something new to the series' universe. Private and commercial aviation, the Air Force, the daring rescue work glimpsed in the trailer for next years Planes: Fire & Rescue... just a few of the tantalizing possibilities that would have set Hall's spin-off free. Not that kids will care. Younger children will have a blast, if only because they won't notice just how much Planes begs, borrows and lifts from a hundred other underdog stories. Disney's Blu-ray release is more satisfying, fortunately, with an excellent video presentation, a relatively impressive 3D experience, and involving DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 surround track. Its supplemental package is much too direct-to-video for a film that earned a theatrical release, but complaints end there. Bottom line? You could do a whole lot worse this holiday season. Planes is perfect for the kiddies, even if it will prove somewhat disappointing for parents.