7.3 | / 10 |
Users | 2.8 | |
Reviewer | 3.5 | |
Overall | 3.2 |
Joe Rolfe is an ex-con who's trying to go straight with a job as a deliveryman for a florist. Unfortunately, a gang led by a criminal mastermind have rob an armored car using a van that looks just like Rolfe's. Narrowly avoiding arrest, Rolfe begins a determined search for the real thieves -- with shocking results.
Starring: John Payne (I), Coleen Gray, Preston Foster, Neville Brand, Lee Van CleefFilm-Noir | 100% |
Drama | 5% |
Crime | Insignificant |
Video codec: MPEG-4 AVC
Video resolution: 1080p
Aspect ratio: 1.33:1
Original aspect ratio: 1.37:1
English: Dolby Digital 5.1
English: Dolby Digital 2.0
Spanish
25GB Blu-ray Disc
Two-disc set (1 BD, 1 DVD)
DVD copy
Region A, B (C untested)
Movie | 3.5 | |
Video | 3.0 | |
Audio | 3.5 | |
Extras | 0.5 | |
Overall | 3.5 |
What a difference one letter can make. John Wayne, after paying his dues in less than stellar films and roles, managed to break through to superstardom with Stagecoach, and then enjoyed a relatively unbroken string of big screen successes. Change that surname “W” to a “P” and the story is remarkably different. Despite being cut from much the same leading man cloth as The Duke, John Payne never really managed to break out into anything approaching major stardom, despite having a long career filled with a variety of roles which included everything from song and dance (something Wayne never really attempted) to westerns to film noir. Payne is probably best remembered today for the Christmas perennial Miracle on 34th Street, but Payne showed a rather remarkable versatility throughout his many years in film and television, and he’s front and center in Phil Karlson’s acclaimed noir Kansas City Confidential. Payne plays ex-con Joe Rolfe, a delivery truck driver for a florist who finds himself caught up in a million dollar-plus heist from a bank next door to a shop where he drops off blooms every morning. Kansas City Confidential is a rather odd little film in the noir canon, a sort of combination of Hitchcock’s frequent trope of the wrongly accused everyman combined with a hunt through a labyrinth of lies and duplicity that recalls better remembered noirs like Out of the Past. This is low budget, stripped to the bare essentials filmmaking, but it’s a bracing piece of work that rarely if ever lets up from its breakneck pace and it provides Payne with one of his signature roles.
Film Chest is a new niche label which is beginning to release public domain titles on Blu-ray. Like The Stranger, which I just reviewed, Kansas City Confidential is presented in an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 1.33:1. Also like The Stranger, this release was sourced from a 35mm print. Unlike The Stranger, however, this release sports much better contrast and a sharper, more well defined image that, while certainly nowhere near reference quality, offers a suitably hi-def look at least some of the time. Black levels are consistent and at times very impressive, and the delineation between gray tones and whites is also often quite admirable. While we're still missing a good grain structure as in The Stranger, this release doesn't have the completely over-DNR'd smooth, textureless appearance that the Welles opus did. I haven't seen as many PD DVDs of this title as I have of The Stranger, but this release has a couple of things going for it. It is virtually spot and blemish free, which none of the DVD releases I've seen (including the touted MGM) have, sometime in abundance. This also sports a reasonably sharp and clear image with above average contrast. It's certainly not what it could have been had an internegative been available, but transfers must be judged based on their source elements, and in this case the digital sharpening of a decent 35mm print hasn't been literally smoothed over to the point of blandness.
Once again, as was the case with The Stranger, we have no lossless options and instead are given two standard Dolby mixes, one in 5.1 and one in 2.0. The better news is that, unlike The Stranger, the source soundtrack utilized for this new Blu-ray does not have egregious damage, with noticeably less hiss and virtually none of the pops and cracks that marred the Welles film. Dialogue is presented cleanly and clearly and both the sound effects and underscore sound good, if slightly boxy. These 5.1 mixes on the first two Film Chest releases seem needless, as there simply isn't the ability to separate discrete effects for proper placement around the soundfield. Instead we get a sort of willy- nilly spread out into the surrounds that never approaches anything like a modern surround track, and in fact, this film really doesn't call out for an immersive surround track, anyway. It's a close-up look at a man in peril, without a lot of big action sequences, and so there just isn't ample opportunity to exploit the side and rear channels. Film Chest would do better to look into presenting decent lossless mono tracks for its releases; my hunch is most Blu-ray consumers would prefer that option to a needlessly dispersed faux surround option, especially in Dolby.
Do a brief Theatrical Trailer and Restoration Demonstration count as real life supplements? I personally don't think so.
Kansas City Confidential is one of the most quietly influential noirs ever. It's a film that strangely has never really been paid its due, despite several elements having been quoted in numerous subsequent films. While there will be a host of people probably nitpicking this release due to its public domain genesis, it sports a sharper image than any other PD DVD I've seen with perhaps the exception of the MGM release, but the print is also noticeably cleaner and more damage free than even the MGM print. While it's inarguable that DNR has been applied here, it's not to the smooth, textureless level that a lot of The Stranger was. The soundtrack here also does not have the damage, hiss, cracks and pops that plagued The Stranger BD. While this may not be the most perfect release imaginable on Blu-ray for this film, it's better by far than some might expect from a "mere" PD release. Recommended.
1950
1956
1955
Special Edition
1953
1951
The Boulting Brothers Production of Brighton Rock / Young Scarface
1947
2001
1953
1952
1956
1949
2002
1948
Warner Archive Collection
1978
1946
1954
1955
1946
1944
1955