Rating summary
Movie | | 3.5 |
Video | | 3.0 |
Audio | | 2.5 |
Extras | | 3.5 |
Overall | | 3.0 |
JFK: A New World Order Blu-ray Movie Review
A solid primer for basic JFK history.
Reviewed by Martin Liebman August 5, 2013
A man of many contradictions.
If JFK: A New World Order were a book instead of a Documentary, it might be one of the kid-oriented paperbacks Scholastic sells at book fairs,
not a hefty academic text.
That is, it covers the basic information in an agreeable, straightforward manner, lacking much insight and certainly absent significant depth but offering
its viewers a satisfying glimpse into the life and times of America's 35th President and one of the nation's most beloved historical figures. And there's
nothing wrong with that. In fact, A New World Order is a well put-together, though certainly very straightforward and low budget,
Documentary that deals mostly with Kennedy's Presidency and the massive amount of history that played out during his all-too-brief time in office.
From his 1960 run and win and on through to his determination to expand the space program, maneuvering through the Cuban Missile crisis, and
fighting for civil rights, the film chronicles Kennedy's presidency -- and all that was packed into it -- with broad strokes but nevertheless enough detail
to teach today's generation the basics or refresh the memories of those who still remember the rise and fall of Camelot.
Mr. President.
Though the absence of depth is a bit disappointing, the filmmakers have done a good job of conveying the basics and never losing a fast pace. The
film's individual
segments move by quickly and don't overflow with information but are defined by a quality combination of historian interviews, narration, still
photographs, film clips, and extended archival highlights from speeches, debates, and so forth. The documentary chronicles Kennedy's early life and
rise in
political stature, from his days at Harvard and his participation in World War II and on through his time in elected office before ascending to the
Presidency and taking that office on January 20, 1961. It captures the highlights of his two years and ten months in office, from his historical
inauguration speech to his tragic assassination in Dallas, Texas on November 22, 1963. Finally, it studies the Kennedy legacy then, today, and
tomorrow.
Episode summaries are as follows:
- Early Years: Part one takes a look at Kennedy's early life of wealth and privilege. It also briefly studies his grandparents, his maternal
grandfather, once Mayor of Boston, and his paternal grandfather, a liquor importer. The piece examines his interest in politics at Harvard and his
departure from his father's political points of view. It focuses on his
enlistment in the military and command of the famous PT-109, with emphasis on the ordeal's shaping of his image. It then transitions to the
difficulty he found in adapting to political life, discovering his style and voice along the campaign trail, the flourishing of his family, his role in the
senate and his televised rise to fame during a congressional investigation of a racketeering scandal, and his place at the 1956 Democratic national
convention. It also touches his authorship of Profiles in Courage.
- For All to See: A closer look at the 1960 campaign, including the expanded role of television coverage of the election. It focuses on
Kennedy's appearance on television, Kennedy's deeper understanding of how to best utilize
the medium over his opponent, and the contrast between Kennedy's and Nixon's looks. It also covers the split in the party and some of the
electorate's uncertainty with his candidacy, not only concerning his
policies but his frail health, religion, and inexperience. It also looks at his tackling of domestic and foreign issues and his tight 1960 Presidential
election victory and the television coverage of it.
- New Frontiers: Part three begins with JFK's inaugural address ("ask not what your country can do for you but what you can do for
your
country") on a chilly Washington day. After a year, his Presidency accomplished little, though he did create the Peace Corps, which the film details. It
examines in great detail -- with lengthy speech highlights -- his goal of landing a man on the moon and expanding the U.S. Space Program as part of
the race and challenge against Communism and as a part of the larger Cold War.
- Doomsday Averted: As the title suggests, this segment studies Kennedy's role in averting nuclear disaster. It examines his role in the
"Bay of Pigs" incident as part of an intelligence effort to remove Communist influence on the island nation and dealing with the aftermath of failure.
Part four continues with a detailed history of Kennedy's involvement in the Cuban Missile Crisis. Finally, the segment focuses on Kennedy's push for
détente.
- A Wall of Worlds: A closer look at the American and Russian influences on Europe after World War II, with a focus on the construction
of the Berlin wall, separating the Communist East and the free West. It shows highlights from Kennedy's address to the nation after the wall's
construction as well as his famous speech in Berlin ("Ich bin ein Berliner").
- War Within & Without Part One: This segment opens with an examination of Kennedy's role in the civil rights movement. It highlights
the complications that arose from communist infiltration of the civil rights movement and the domestic and foreign policy challenges that were a
result of the civil
rights movement. It looks at the turning point for his further involvement in the movement: Alabama Governor George Wallace's ordered blockage
of the
entrance to the University of Alabama to keep two black students, Vivian Malone and James Hood, from attending classes. It also looks at Lyndon
Johnson's future pushes for civil rights.
- War Within & Without Part Two: An examination of foreign policy in the nuclear and Cold War era. The piece focuses on Kennedy's
concern with Southeast Asia: the origins of what would become the Vietnam Conflict. Kennedy searches for options to deal with the risks of both
expanded involvement in or a departure from the theater, with emphasis on the inevitable "Domino Effect" of further Communist expansion in the
region. Expanding the role of American military influence in the region, the propaganda war that was a result, and the Kennedy policy of "working
for peace but preparing for war" are also studied.
- Camelot & Beyond: A closer look at the Kennedy family, including Jacqueline Kennedy's role in JFK's Presidency and her greater
influence on the 1960s style scene. Kennedy's frail health, his affairs, the assassination, and his legacy are also featured.
JFK: A New World Order Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality
JFK: A New World Order is another Documentary crafted from a variety of sources. There are color and black-and-white still photographs, which
in totality look quite nice, sharp and true and, where applicable, nicely colored and era-authentic. There's also a myriad of film and video sources, with
the film holding its own at the increased Blu-ray resolution but obviously showing signs of age, some more so than others. The video and television
broadcast footage ranges from acceptable to downright poor, wavy and distorted in places. As always, this older footage doesn't factor into the score.
The only real new footage comes from a few still shots and interview snippets. There's little life to these elements; the interviews appear rather flat and
revealing of only basic definition and details. Skin textures are not flat but they lack the complexity that top-end HD video is capable of displaying.
Colors, too, follow suit; they're not bland but there's no brilliance, either. For a smaller-scoped Documentary and a budget Blu-ray release, this transfer
is more than capable.
JFK: A New World Order Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality
JFK: A New World Order arrives on Blu-ray with a Dolby Digital 2.0 soundtrack. There's zero range beyond a bit of stretch out to the sides for
musical pieces. Militaristic beats enjoy a little more heft. Clarity is never lacking, but listeners certainly won't mistake the track for a live band. Dialogue
ranges in quality from source to source. Newly recorded narration and historian interviews never sound too terribly detached, but there's no sense of
realistic clarity, either. Placement is, at least, consistent. Older footage, unsurprisingly, lacks crispness and definition but is, for the most part, fully
intelligible save for a few excessively scratchy moments. All in all, this is a track that gets the basics done well enough, and that's all this material
requires.
JFK: A New World Order Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras
JFK: A New World Order includes a DVD copy of the documentary as well as a bonus DVD with the following features:
- Kennedy vs Nixon Presidential Debate (SD, 58:44): The second debate in its entirety.
- Assassination of President John F. Kennedy (SD, 20:48): A vintage black-and-white film chronicling the event after the fact.
- Funeral Service of President John F. Kennedy (SD, 43:05): A vintage color film chronicling the event.
- Vietnam! Vietnam! by John Ford (SD, 58:02): A film chronicling the war, narrated by Charlton Heston.
JFK: A New World Order Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation
JFK: A New World Order probably isn't even deep enough for college classrooms, but for middle or high school teachers looking for a solid
overview of a Presidency or the major highlights therein, this Documentary is hard to beat. With eight separate features that run around 26 minutes
each, it's a highly efficient JFK primer that gets the information out there in an agreeable, easily understood fashion. Look elsewhere for depth, but don't
look anywhere else for the basics. Four terrific bonus features and adequate video and audio support a quality release. Recommended; the supplements
will particularly appeal to students of history.