Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 3D Blu-ray Movie

Rating summary

Movie		4.0
Video		4.5
Audio		5.0
Extras		4.5
Overall		4.5

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 3D Blu-ray Movie Review

It delivers a better 3D experience than Part 1. Just don't set your expectations too high...

Reviewed by Kenneth Brown November 13, 2011

It had to end, and it had to end spectacularly. After fourteen years, seven unexpectedly gripping award-winning books, eight wildly successful record-breaking films, eight billion dollars at the box office, and the franchise GNP of a small, self-sustaining nation, author J. K. Rowling's burgeoning wizards and warriors deserved a big screen finale of sky-splitting proportions, and returning director David Yates and series overmind, screenwriter Steve Kloves, were more than happy to oblige. Death, betrayal and magic. Heartbreak, desperation and darkness. Selflessness, sacrifice and redemption. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 has it all. The risky, oft-criticized proposition of splitting Rowling's seventh book into two films? Vindicated. The efforts of the many filmmakers, actors, artists and technicians who've walked through the doors of Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry? Honored. The series' devoted fans? Thrilled. Rowling's readers? Satisfied. Critics? Uncharacteristically united. It had to end, and it ended in style. Spectacularly, though? Almost. Almost.

Once more unto the breach, dear friends. Once more...

When last we left our faithful heroes -- Harry Potter (Daniel Radcliffe), Hermione Granger (Emma Watson) and Ron Weasley (Rupert Grint) -- the haunted and hunted young wizards were completely isolated from their teachers and friends for the first time in their lives; on the run and battling for their very existences after burying a dear friend following a too-close-for-comfort encounter with Death Eater Bellatrix Lestrange (Helena Bonham Carter). To its credit, The Deathly Hallows: Part 2 doesn't waste any time. It barely pauses for an opening title sequence; the theme that has so dutifully accompanied Harry Potter for eight films now offers little cheer or refuge, and even less relief or respite. Lord Voldemort (Ralph Fiennes), having seized the Elder Wand from Dumbledore's grave, turns his attention to his favorite pastime: plotting the gory demise of nemesis and beloved Hogwarts messiah, Harry Potter; Hogwarts continues to cede power to Severus Snape (Alan Rickman, stealing yet another Potter film) and Voldemort's demented Death Eaters; Snape, in turn, reflects on the events that placed Hogwarts in his hands; and Harry, Hermione and Ron set out to find and destroy the remaining Horcruxes and put an end to Voldemort's reign. Permanently. What follows is an arresting clash of the titans in which the Potter-led trio break into Gringotts bank, make their way back to Hogwarts, reunite with their secret brothers in arms, and take the fight to Voldemort's legions. Wands crackle, magic sizzles, dragons screech, giants topple, heroes weep, villains shriek, and gods fall.

There's a disconnect between all of the VFX wizardry and narrative power, though, slight as it is. Chalk it up to the fact that, separated from Part 1, The Deathly Hallows: Part 2 is essentially a string of climaxes comprising one of the longest third acts Hollywood has ever given us. Or chalk it up to the sheer amount of plot points, characters and set pieces it has to nurture (or, on occasion, neglects to nurture). If Part 1 was a slow-brew masterpiece of isolation, loneliness and adolescent uncertainty (which it absolutely was, no matter how short-sightedly some have dismissed it as a lesser film), Part 2 is a wands-to-the-wall actioner through and through. Oh, it doles out as many arresting character beats, tragic developments and heart-wrenching realizations as previous Potter entries, but it does so while drawing upon everything from Die Hard to Braveheart to The Matrix Revolutions (of all things). Part 1 may have felt as if it had been cut short, deprived of a proper ending, but Part 2 feels as if it's been trimmed down and robbed of a proper beginning. Thankfully, the magic of home video rectifies the disconnect somewhat, even if there are still too many tiny twists and turns that aren't given enough explanation. Wait, how did the Sword of Gryffindor... but then how does Harry... so what do the Malfoys actually... but can't Voldemort just... so Hogwarts is... is any of this answered in the books? Don't search too long and hard; some answers simply aren't provided in the course of the film and can only be found in Rowling's text. Potterphiles who've pored over every last page won't bat an eye at the exclusions, but those weened on the screen adaptations alone will be left wishing Yates and Kloves had added another ten or fifteen minutes of material, expositional or redundant as some of it may have been.

Otherwise, The Deathly Hallows: Part 2 is as fitting and fantastic a franchise finale as anyone could hope for. Harry, Hermione and Ron take several bold, long-awaited steps into adulthood, each in their own way, and Radcliffe, Watson and Grint come full circle, their once-rosy cheeks faded but their talent and performances in full bloom. Nearly every Hogwarts student, teacher, denizen and outcast is given his or her own moment to shine as well. Old favorites return, recent additions step out of the shadows, friends and foes are stuck down and lifted up, spirits lend support, and rivalries are brought to fruition. No stone is left unturned (least of all the Resurrection Stone), no devious deed is left unpunished (so long as you're willing to forgive a trio of villains who walk off into the sunset), no sacrifice goes unrewarded, no downfall or revelation disappoints. (The action itself is a bit pew! pew! pew!, pew! pew! pew!, but there's only so much that can be done when two armies are pointing sticks at one another.) Elsewhere, the mysteries surrounding Snape's loyalties and motivations are finally put to rest in one of the most stunning, emotionally charged and gratifying sequences of any Harry Potter film to date. Thematically, it makes Snape the most intriguing character in the Potterverse. Visually, it rivals Part 1's beautifully animated fairy tale. Ultimately, it might just be the finest sequence of the series; the one that will change the way you watch the films the next time you stage an eight-entry marathon.

With the double and triple crossing and horcruxing that littered previous Potter films all but exhausted, the story is at long last able to hone in on Harry and Voldemort's contest of wills and wiles. But instead of elevating Harry into a nigh-unstoppable force, it's Voldemort who undergoes crucial changes. Slowly stripped down to his slithery core, the Dark Lord finds himself on a crash course with mortality, a descent Fiennes plays with a sense of sweaty unease and weary restlessness; qualities we just haven't seen in Voldemort before now, qualities that make him that much more fascinating. Harry's is a journey of actualization, one that isn't dependent on his own strength but rather on that of his friends and fellow wizards. He's come an undeniably long way, but he reaches his destination thanks to the same never-say-die spirit that's driven him through the entire series. He doesn't rely on a super spell, a doomsday wand, or a surge of supernatural power. Harry is what Harry's always been: a well-intentioned boy learning how to be a man, a leader, an inspiration and, reluctantly perhaps, a savior. It's in perfect contrast to Voldemort, really: the unremittent monster dead set on doing everything in his power to abandon his humanity. Voldemort wants to be feared; Harry just doesn't want to be afraid anymore. For all the darkness that presses in, for all the evil that promises to overcome the boy wizard, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 arguably dares to hope more than any other film in the franchise, even more so than The Sorcerer's Stone and The Chamber of Secrets. The relief that comes at the end of Voldemort's mad ascension is tainted by sadness and loss, but Hogwarts finally earns a moment of real rest, Harry finally finds some measure of real peace, and Potter filmfans are finally able to truly justify all the love and tears they've invested in the series from the beginning.

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 3D Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality 

The 3D release of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 fares better than its Part 1 counterpart, even though it also hinges on a less-than-spectacular 3D post-conversion. The 3-disc set's 1080p/MVC-encoded 3D transfer, like its separate (and magnificent) 2D encode, is a technical powerhouse, not to mention faithful to Yates and cinematographer Eduardo Serra's bleak, haunting vision and intentions. There are also far more scenes that take advantage of -- or try to take advantage of -- the 3D presentation: a winding roller-coaster ride through the caverns of Gringotts, a daring escape on the back of a dragon, the vast halls of Hogwarts, a near-death encounter with a trio of fire beasts, the clash of Voldemort's forces and Dumbledore's Army, and, of course, the final showdown between the Boy Wizard and the Dark Lord, a battle that exhibits more patented 3D pop than any other sequence in the film. Still, Part 2 is an even darker film than Part 1 and depth and overall dimensionality take a bit of a beating. Whenever shadows descend, an inherent flatness descends too; whenever darkness presses in, the 3D effect all but relents; whenever the image is at its blackest, the tint of the 3D glasses blot out already obscured on-screen objects and make it that much more difficult to peer into the corners of Hogwarts' chambers. Depending on your display and glasses, you may also notice a bit of crosstalk, particularly as Potter rallies the troops before the sun rises and Voldemort falls. Again, though none of it is a product of the technical encode or the Blu-ray transfer; both are as precise and on point as they should be. It's simply the fault of the film which, to cut to the heart of the matter, probably shouldn't have been converted to or released in 3D. The Deathly Hallows isn't blessed with the traits that would lead to a more absorbing and immersive 3D experience.

Thankfully, the film itself, whether viewed in 2D or 3D, remains a gorgeous entry in the Potter franchise. Colors have been mercilessly drained of life, but bursts of magic, chambers of gold, walls of flame and visions of the past nevertheless boast a spread of vivid primaries and rich, storybook hues. Fleshtones are pale but natural, complementing the film's tone perfectly; shadows threaten to overwhelm every inch of the screen, but delineation doesn't falter; black levels are as deep, inky and ominous as anyone could hope for; and crush isn't an issue. Any loss of detail traces back to the original source (or the tint of the 3D glasses), not the studio's high definition encode. Not that there's anything in the way of actual detail loss. Closeups, midrange shots and, well, everything in between and beyond reveal wonderfully resolved fine textures. Better still, edge definition is crisp and satisfying (with only a hint of ringing to contend with), a faint veneer of unobtrusive grain lends the image a beautiful filmic quality (that isn't distracting in 3D), every set and costume looks as lived-in and worn as it should, and clarity is, in every instance, as forgiving or foreboding as Yates and Serra intended. Better still, artifacting, banding, aliasing, aberrant noise and other unsightly distractions are nowhere to be found. Some exceedingly minor and altogether infrequent smearing is present, negligible as any affected shot is, but it's strictly a product of post-production noise reduction as it was visible in the film's theatrical presentation. Don't blame either encode, though; if you notice any instance of it at all. Suffice it to say, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 impresses and then some... so long as you view it in 2D. The 3D presentation isn't a complete loss and even boasts a few standout moments, but it isn't armed with the might and magic that could have made it a 3D legend.

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 3D Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality 

As if an outstanding video transfer weren't enough, The Deathly Hallows: Part 2 conjures up a jaw-dropping, window-rattling, sternum-thumping DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track that takes every advantage of the eighth Harry Potter installment's absorbing sound design. LFE output isn't just powerful, it's all powerful. Toppling towers thunder to the ground, rubble roars as it scatters, explosions erupt with ferocity, dragons screech with authority, rickety vault carts clank and clunk heavily and heartily, giants lumber, halberds crash to the ground, and magic bolts tear through the soundscape. Rear speaker activity mounts an equally aggressive assault on Hogwarts as armies clash in the oh-so-convincing distance, chaos erupts around the listener, and directional effects are precise and, in spite of all the dark deeds afoot, relatively playful. But it isn't all shock and awe. Quiet, thoughtful moments precede every Death Eater storm, and the nuances and subtleties of the film's atmospheric soundfield are magnificent. Whether dealing with the vast expanse of an underground cavern or the wind-swept depths of a slumbering forest, dynamics are impeccable, pans are disarmingly smooth, and dialogue, be it whispered, spoken or shouted, is clean, clear and intelligible, no matter how explosive the wand-vs-wand battles become. And Alexandre Desplat's somber score? As delicate, graceful and climactic as it should be. Make no mistake, The Deathly Hallows: Part 2 sounds even better than it looks, and that's saying a lot. Fans will be ecstatic, casual listeners will be blown away, and audiophiles won't have a single complaint.

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 3D Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras 

• Maximum Movie Mode (Disc 2, HD, 167 minutes): Matthew Lewis (Neville Longbottom), producer David Heyman and other notable members of the cast and crew host Warner's latest Harry Potter Maximum Movie Mode experience. It's a terrific Picture-in-Picture track too, one that offers countless interviews, glimpses behind the scenes, VFX breakdowns, production design details, concept art, mythology overviews, integrated deleted scenes, and more. The various participants pause and address key scenes at will, making this particular Maximum Movie Mode as extensive and engrossing as Warner's best. Not to be missed.
• Focus Points (Disc 2, HD, 26 minutes): Fans can also access an excellent selection of production featurettes. Segments include "Aberforth Dumbledore," "Deathly Hallows Costume Changes," "Harry Returns to Hogwarts," "The Hogwarts Shield," "The Room of Requirement Set," "The Fiery Escape," "Neville's Stand" and "Molly and Bellatrix."
• Final Farewells (Disc 2, HD, 3 minutes): The cast and crew bid a bittersweet goodbye to Hogwarts, their characters, franchise fans and, most importantly, each other.
• Deleted Scenes (Disc 3, HD, 7 minutes): While you won't find anything extraordinary or extraordinarily revealing in Part 2's eight deleted scenes, fans will enjoy seeing the little moments Yates left on the cutting room floor, even those that are unfinished. Scenes include "Shell Cottage," "Grave on the Beach," "Hog's Head," "Marble Staircase: Harry & Ginny," "Wooden Bridge," "Hogwart's Battlements," "Slytherin Dungeons" and "Marble Staircase: Ron & Hermione."
• A Conversation with J.K. Rowling and Daniel Radcliffe (Disc 3, HD, 53 minutes): Rowling and Radcliffe have a wonderful rapport and lovely senses of humor, and this insightful, all-too-engaging hour-long chat is easily one of the best features on the disc, if not one of the best special features to appear on any Potter release to date. Over the course of their winningly candid, rapidfire conversation, they delve into Radcliffe's casting, the character of Harry, Rowling's role in the films' production, the story and its themes, the details about future books Rowling shared with different members of the cast and crew, favorite characters and moments, and much, much more.
• The Women of Harry Potter (Disc 3, HD, 23 minutes): A look at the strong, atypical heroines and women that populate Rowling's books and the world of the films.
• The Goblins of Gringotts (Disc 3, HD, 11 minutes): The series' creepy, pit-eyed goblins in all their... glory.
• Warner Bros. Studio Tour London (Disc 3, HD, 2 minutes): Go behind-the-scenes of the UK attraction.
• Pottermore (Disc 3, HD, 1 minute): Rowling introduces her new website, Pottermore.
• BD-Live Functionality

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 3D Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation 

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows is best viewed as one long epic event, but Part 2 stands on its own quite well, bringing confident closure to a beloved saga. It isn't a perfect adaptation, nor is it a perfect film. But it's a commanding, compelling finale that will top many a fan's Best of Harry Potter list. Warner's 3D Blu-ray release wields powerful magic of its own thanks, despite a 3D experience that doesn't always pop as well as it might if the film were shot in 3D or featured a bit more light. Still, it serves up two technically proficient video transfers, a top tier DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, and a marvelous supplemental package sure to keep diehards and casual fans busy for the better part of an afternoon. Don't hesitate, don't wait, don't waste any time. Add The Deathly Hallows: Part 2 to your cart post haste, be it the 2D version or the 3D combo pack.