7.7 | / 10 |
| Users | 0.0 | |
| Reviewer | 4.0 | |
| Overall | 4.0 |
Welcome to the picture-perfect New England town of Stars Hollow, Connecticut. Founded in 1779. Population 9,973. Home of 32 year old Lorelai (Lauren Graham) and her 16-year-old daughter Rory (Alexia Bledel) - the Gilmore Girls. Quick-witted Lorelai, manager of historic Independence Inn, is mother to Rory. She is her daughter's best friend, confidante and mentor who's determined to help her avoid the mistakes that sidetracked Lorelai when she was a teen.
Starring: Lauren Graham, Alexis Bledel, Scott Patterson, Keiko Agena, Yanic Truesdale| Comedy | Uncertain |
| Family | Uncertain |
| Drama | Uncertain |
Video codec: MPEG-4 AVC
Video resolution: 1080p
Aspect ratio: 1.78:1
Original aspect ratio: 1.78:1, 1.33:1
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 (48kHz, 24-bit)
English: DTS 2.0
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 (48kHz, 24-bit)
English: DTS 5.1
English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 only on last season 6 & 7 & also A Year in the Life
English SDH
Blu-ray Disc
Thirty-disc set (30 BDs)
Region A (B, C untested)
| Movie | 4.0 | |
| Video | 4.0 | |
| Audio | 4.0 | |
| Extras | 3.0 | |
| Overall | 4.0 |
Amy Sherman-Palladino's Gilmore Girls was popular enough to last for seven seasons on two networks but, since ending in 2007, its pop culture footprint has grown thanks to DVD and streaming, where its prominent position as a Netflix staple -- for a few more days, at least -- only strengthened the show's devoted fanbase. The four-part "sequel" A Year In the Life materialized in 2016, reuniting many of its characters during four movie-length installments which were collected on Blu-ray the next year thanks to Warner Archive. Speaking of 2017, that would have been a perfect time to release the series proper on Blu-ray, but Warner Bros. unwisely sat on the opportunity for almost a full decade despite growing interest. While "better late than never" doesn't always apply to all situations, it certainly does in this case: even with inevitably lower sales and the studio's recent switch to awful Epic keepcase packaging, I'm thrilled to finally have Gilmore Girls on Blu-ray. (And just for the record, my wife is even more thrilled.)

Do you like fast-paced chatter, non-stop pop culture references, and quirky small-town charm? Gilmore Girls might be right for you, but it's also a pretty touching drama about mothers and daughters, personal growth, love, ambition, and the challenges of balancing independence with family obligations. True to its name, the series revolves around 32 year-old single mother Lorelai Gilmore (Lauren Graham) and her 16 year-old daughter Rory (Alexis Bledel). Lorelai became pregnant as a teenager and chose to raise Rory on her own rather than follow the rigid expectations of her wealthy and socially prominent parents, Emily and Richard Gilmore (Kelly Bishop and the late, great Edward Herrmann, who passed away between Season 7 and A Year in the Life). After leaving home with infant Rory, Lorelai built a life for herself in the (unfortunately for fans) fictional town of Stars Hollow, Connecticut, where in earlier seasons she works as a manager of the Independence Inn alongside her best friend and chef Sookie St. James (Melissa McCarthy, before her film career) as well as the obnoxious desk clerk Michel Gerard (Yanic Truesdale), who somehow keeps his job indefinitely.
Rory's first-episode acceptance to the private high school Chilton drives much of Season 1's initial drama, which also includes the financial catch of grandparents Emily and Richard re-entering the Gilmores' lives, and Rory's own suitors include the likes of local Dean Forester (Jared Padalecki), Chilton student Tristin Dugray (Chad Michael Murray), Luke's bad-boy nephew Jess Mariano (Milo Ventimiglia), and later, ultra-wealthy Logan Huntzberger (Matt Czuchry). Besides for mom, of course, Rory's main support group includes her best friend Lane Kim (Keiko Agena) as well as whip-smart Paris Geller (Lisa Weil), at least eventually; during the course of the series, she faces the typical teenage challenges of independence, school prospects, learning boundaries, breaking them, and finding out what happens when you steal a yacht. Some of these challenges lead us full-circle back to her relationship with Lorelai, who shares many of Rory's ups and downs as the show progresses while trying to find the right balance of regular love and tough love.

The close-knit, eccentric community of Stars Hollow becomes a cozy backdrop for much of the show's humor and warmth, but Gilmore
Girls is overwhelmingly driven by the lives and relationships of its two main characters. Lorelai and Rory share an unusually close bond, often
coming off like best friends as much as mother and daughter; they have a shared interest in movies, books, music -- all of which they reference
constantly -- and are fueled by a steady stream of junk food, takeout, and regular outings to the local diner owned by Luke Danes (Scott Patterson).
Luke serves as the main "will they or won't they" love interest for Lorelai during several of the show's seasons, but he's only one of many potential
matches alongside Rory's teacher Max Medina (Scott Cohen), Jason Scooper "Digger" Stiles (Chris Eigeman), and of course Rory's father
Christopher Hayden (David Sutcliffe), who's still very much a part of their lives. Lorelai's career undergoes a potential shift partway through the
series, as her dreams of finally running her very own inn with the help of Sookie and Michel (for some reason) could actually become reality once its
former owner passes away. But since the stress of work, parenting, and dating aren't enough, Lorelai often also has to deal with overbearing parents
-- especially her mother -- whose hefty school loan for Rory is sometimes used as a bargaining chip.
I understand that this is all an awful lot to keep track of already... but we've barely touched upon the dozens upon dozens of quirky, colorful Stars Hollow citizens that give Gilmore Girls its unique flavor while increasing the fun factor during yet another annual rewatch. Conservative grocery store owner Taylor Doose (Michael Winters) doubles as Town Selectman and duly leads regular town meetings in a dance studio owned by Patricia "Miss Patty" LaCosta (Liz Torres). Lorelai's eccentric but good-hearted neighbor Babette Dell (Sally Struthers) has a real ear for gossip, a mellow husband in Mory (Ted Rooney), and at least two cats. The borderline creepy jack-of-all-trades Kirk Gleason (Sean Gunn) seems to have a new job every episode. Mrs. Kim (Emily Kuroda) is Lane's ultra-religious mother and the intimidating owner of an antique shop with a strict policy of "you break it, you bought it". Jackson Belleville (Jackson Douglas) is a produce supplier who's just as passionate about food quality as Sookie, which draws them together as one of the show's most dependable (and level-headed) relationships. Countless other normal folks and weirdos dot the landscape of Stars Hollow and beyond, numerous enough that you'll likely need a spreadsheet to keep track of them all.

Those who love "spot the celebrity" will enjoy doing that the first time through and on future rewatches, as Gilmore Girls featured no
shortage of current and future notable figures in supporting and one-off roles during its run. These include Twin Peaks actors Mädchen
Amick and Sherilyn Fenn, Family Guy's Alex Borstein as well as Seth MacFarlane himself, Jon Hamm, Parks and Recreation's Nick
Offerman (without a mustache!), Melora Hardin AKA The Office's Jan Levison Gould, former Superman Brandon Routh, Rami
Malek, singer Paul Anka, Skid Row's Sebastian Bach, Grant-Lee Phillips, Sonic Youth's Thurston Moore and Kim Gordon, The Shins, Yo La Tengo,
Carole King, Christiane Amanpour, Madeleine Albright, and of course Norman Mailer, who even gets a Season 5 episode named after him.
Throughout its seven seasons, Gilmore Girls skillfully balanced humor and drama while exploring themes of ambition, identity, friendship,
romance, and loads of generational conflict. As mentioned before, it also continued in 2016 with the Netflix mini-revival Gilmore Girls: A Year In
the Life, whose four movie-length installments each represented a season in Stars Hollow. Set nearly a decade after the original series (which
ran for another year after Amy Sherman-Palladino and her husband Daniel left in 2006 due to creative differences, which were resolved for the
revival), this limited series catches up with Lorelai, Rory, Emily, and many of the show's original characters as they navigate new challenges and life
events. The revival explores grief, personal reinvention, and the passage of time -- heavily underlined by Edward Hermann's passing -- but, in my
opinion, only reinforces the old adage that "you can't go home again". Shot digitally and mostly lacking the spark of the original series (though not
without its highlights, including the Palladinos' original ending), it falls well below expectations and, for some fans, is better left out of the marathon
cycle entirely. Martin Liebman reviewed A Year In the Life's stand-alone Blu-ray edition back in 2017 (linked above, for those seeking more
information) and that two-disc set is included as part of Warner Bros.' massive 30-disc collection.

Each of Gilmore Girls' seven seasons (all with 21-22 episodes apiece) are presented on four 50GB discs -- that's 28 total -- with two more for the four-part A Year In the Life. This is cutting it awfully close for ideal disc compression, but for the most part WB has done a very good job with this material despite a few prevailing signs of mild macro blocking which also competes with noise during some of of its darker scenes. For the record, these HD masters appear to be the very same ones created for streaming on Netflix over a decade ago; largely clean and film-like with no obvious native shortcomings, outside of the fact that the first three seasons are presented in 1.78:1 widescreen rather than 1.33:1 for broadcast and DVD. For the most part, this isn't nearly as problematic as WB/HBO's bone-headed decision to present Curb Your Enthusiasm's earlier seasons in cropped widescreen, which led to some pretty egregious compositions for the native 4x3 material. But it's still at least noticeable here and there, with Gilmore Girls' pilot filmed in native 1.37:1 and most of the rest composed for 1.66:1 but clearly shot with 1.33:1 and 1.78:1 in mind. That said, a growing majority of fans have joined during the post-Netflix era, so many should be used to this wider -- and only occasionally cramped -- presentation during the first three seasons. In short, it's pretty much what you'd expect.
More than usual, these direct-from-disc screenshots -- which, as always, represent a fairly even cross-section of episodes by year -- should provide a decently accurate picture of the 1080p transfers' fine detail and aesthetic, which unsurprisingly is a mostly solid image with warm and inviting colors, occasional depth, and varying levels of film grain that seem faithful to the source. (A Year In the Life was shot digitally, so it's the exception here and, in any case, was already covered in our stand-alone Blu-ray review back in 2017.) It's a fine presentation, all things considered; not perfect (and perhaps even a shade too dark, in my opinion), but at the very least it offers noticeable improvements over the heavily compressed streaming versions that fans have watched ad nauseum since 2014.

The audio is much more straightforward, as all of the content included here is presented in its native lossless format: DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio Stereo for Seasons 1-5, and DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio Surround for Seasons 6-7 and A Year in the Life. Not surprisingly, Gilmore Girls is not exactly a sonically demanding series as almost all of its nearly non-stop dialogue is anchored squarely up front with minimal directionality, while separation and (later) surround effects are reserved for background activity as well as the series' memorable music and soundtrack cues.
Speaking of which, one music change (likely due to rights issues) was noted in our official forum thread a few weeks ago: during the Season 1 episode "Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers", John Lennon's "Oh My Love" has been replaced by "Love Is Real" by Steve Robinson. My casual familiarity with Gilmore Girls before Blu-ray would've made this change go completely over my head, but no more substitutions have been revealed.
Optional English (SDH) subtitles are included during all episodes and applicable bonus features listed below.

This whopping 30-disc set is unfortunately another recent victim of WB's recent switch to "Epic" keepcases for series sets, a space-saving but notoriously difficult type of packaging with overlapping hubs. At least this time there are two separate cases bundled inside a slipcase, and the artwork is attractive with disc-by-disc breakdowns printed inside, but individual hinged keepcases for each season would've been truly ideal and worth a higher retail price.
The bonus features are spread across several seasons and all are ported over from the old DVD sets, but there are a few minor omissions including about three minutes of deleted scenes for Season 1 (perhaps the source materials were subpar or missing?), as well as a player-based trivia game from Season 4. Basic descriptions of everything are below, but most are either self-explanatory or long-time fans should already be familiar with all of this stuff.
SEASON ONE, DISC FOUR
SEASON TWO - DISCS ONE AND THREE
SEASON TWO, DISC FOUR
SEASON THREE, DISC THREE
SEASON THREE, DISC FOUR
SEASON FOUR, DISCS ONE AND THREE
SEASON FOUR, DISC FOUR

SEASON FIVE, DISC TWO
SEASON FIVE, DISC FOUR
SEASON SEVEN, DISC ONE
SEASON SEVEN, DISC FOUR
NOTE: Season Six and A Year In the Life do not have -- or have ever had -- any bonus features.

Amy Sherman-Palladino's mega-popular Gilmore Girls gradually blossomed from a modest, cozy small-town TV show to a full-blown pop culture phenomenon, inviting fans of all ages to revisit the seven-season series as well as its four-part Netfilx continuation A Year In the Life each and every fall... or whenever you feel like yet another marathon. Aside from WB's old DVD sets, streaming has the been the main access point for fans... but since it's leaving Netflix after 12 years, Warner Bros.' long-overdue Blu-ray collection (which serves up everything Gilmore expect for two extras stuck on DVD) has now become more essential. This set will continue to be a big seller and, despite reservations about the packaging and cropped early seasons (which were the same way on streaming), it comes firmly Recommended.

2016

1987-1995

1993-2000

1987

2007

2008

2003

2003

2013-2014

2003

1968

We Love Lucy / S1 / I Love Lucy: Season 7
1957-1958

30th Anniversary Edition
1990

1993

2004

2006

1998

2003

2011

10th Anniversary Edition
2003