Rating summary

Movie		4.0
Video		5.0
Audio		5.0
Extras		4.5
Overall		4.5

Finding Nemo 3D Blu-ray Movie Review

Another Pixar classic, another pair of terrific 3D and 2D Disney AV presentations...

Reviewed by Kenneth Brown November 22, 2012

Cars is typically labeled Pixar's most divisive film, but it's actually Finding Nemo that draws the widest and most passionate range of responses. Some, like my colleague Brian Orndorf, struggle with, as he puts it, the film's "overstuffed narrative, flashes of bodily function humor and screenwriting formula. I didn’t hate the picture," he continues, "but I’ve come to understand that any raised eyebrow directed at a Pixar production is an offense punishable by death in some corners of the internet." Others like myself, though, recognize every one of Nemo's flaws but are so swept out to sea by its grand underwater adventure and indelible characters that little else matters. Still, the years have indeed been kinder to the film's surprisingly viable animation than its beached-whale script and, beloved or no, Finding Nemo isn't the ultimate Pixar experience it once was, even with a dazzling new 3D experience in tow. It's merely one of the famed animation studio's early delights, and a funny, exciting and memorable one at that.

"It's because I like you that I don't want to be with you. It's a complicated emotion."

When a young clownfish named Nemo (voiced by Alexander Gould) is captured by a Great Barrier Reef diver and imprisoned in a fish tank in far-away Sydney, Australia, his hyper-protective father Marlin (Albert Brooks) sets out to get him back, whatever the cost. Along the way, Marlin reluctantly enlists the help of Dory, a blue surgeonfish with chronic short-term memory loss, and a number of new friends, among them a group of current-surfing sea turtles, an enormous whale and even a trio of semi-reformed sharks. ("I am a nice shark, not a mindless eating machine. If I am to change this image, I must first change myself. Fish are friends, not food.") Nemo, meanwhile, is placed in a dentist-office fish tank where he makes a few new friends of his own: moorish idol Gill (Willem Dafoe), blowfish Bloat (Brad Garrett), yellow tang Bubbles (Stephen Root), starfish Peach (Allison Janney), Pacific cleaner shrimp Jacques (Joe Ranft), royal gramma fish Gurgle (Austin Pendleton), and blacktail damselfish Deb (Vicki Lewis). With everything on the line, Marlin has to track down his son and Nemo has to find his way to the sea, where his father will hopefully be waiting.

Pixar's wizards of anthropomorphism are powerful sorcerers, and the magic they conjure here is as wondrous and heartfelt as ever. Every fish, shark and turtle is a memorable character in its own right, Marlin and Dory are still two of the studio's most lovable leads, Mr. Ray and the Reef locals are a colorful cast of eccentrics and working Joes, Bruce and his fellow sharks nearly steal the entire movie, and only the film's humans are shortchanged in any way. Even when Nemo's journey inland threatens to distract and detract from Marlin and Dory's far more engrossing quest, Gil and the Tank Gang keep things light, lively and clever enough to stay the course. More ingenious perhaps are the creatures director Andrew Stanton and his talented team don't grant human characteristics. No speaking role for one of the film's unsung heroes, the whale, who's more of a silent, benevolent deity of Biblical proportions than anything remotely human. No personality for the anglerfish or jellyfish masses either. Deprived of faces, voices and relatable motivations, the deadly beasts are suddenly that much more dangerous and frightening. And never before has the word "mine" accomplished so much with so little and brought as many laughs to a room as it does when squawked by Pixar's hilarious flock of seagulls.

But even the best underwater friends and foes would be nothing without a compelling world to inhabit, and Finding Nemo's endless ocean remains a thriving, fully realized realm that's as much a character as Marlin or Dory. Even some ten years after its creation -- ten years of animation advances, ten years of technical strides, ten years of computer- generated mastery -- the film's water effects are wholly immersive. Fish don't float on screen, they float within a body of oh- so-convincing water teeming with the tiniest particles, creatures, reflections of light, shifts in the current, rising bubbles and settling sand. I'm sure it would pale in comparison to what Pixar could achieve in 2012, mind you, but that shouldn't take away from everything the artists and animators were able to pull off in 2003. (Again, it's the human world that shows its age more than anything else.) Add to that the beauty of the coral reefs, the guts of a sunken ship, the rush of riding a current, the subtlest movements of Marlin and his companions... of Pixar's first six films, Finding Nemo's animation has best withstood the test of time. And while that doesn't make up for the pitfalls that line the at-times uneven two-pronged story, it definitely soothes most of the sting. There's still a lot to love in Nemo and very little to complain about. It says quite a lot when the studio's most recent productions -- Cars 2 and Brave -- have such trouble topping a fan- favorite film ten years past its prime.

Finding Nemo 3D Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality 

If you're ever on a hunt for banding on Blu-ray, there are two surefire places to start: animated movies and underwater adventures. So how does Pixar's animated underwater adventure fare? Incredibly well actually, with only the slightest hint of banding creeping into its 1080p/AVC-encoded video presentation, and even then only on rare occasion. Otherwise, Finding Nemo is as flawless as anyone could hope for. Deep sea colors are delicate and lovely, topside hues are even more vibrant and stunning, contrast is dialed in beautifully from start to finish, and black levels are resolved wonderfully. And detail? Straight from the digital tap perfect. Some softness and a few instances of extremely negligible aliasing appear, but the former is an intentional artistic choice made by the filmmakers and the latter is inherited from the film's original animation, now more than nine years old. Edge definition is as exacting as it should be, the smallest textures are intact and showcased without exception, and clarity is magnificent. It only helps that significant macroblocking, noise and other issues are nowhere to be found, meaning Nemo is as gorgeous as Pixar purists have been hoping.

The 1080p/MVC-encoded 3D experience is just as striking, and the film's vast ocean wonderland is a playground of convincing depth and dimensionality. Fish slowly swim right out of the screen, reefs stretch far into the watery distance, aquarium rocks and decorations provide a sense of boxed-in space and suitably cramped scope, sharks and sea turtles float in and out of the foreground, jellyfish clump believably to form a net of deadly obstacles, and the movie looks as if it were designed from the ground-up with a 3D presentation in mind. There also isn't any further aliasing or 3D-related anomalies to report, there aren't very many on-screen visuals or elements that fall victim to crosstalk (and those that do will only do so on 3D displays that are already prone to ghosting), and I didn't encounter much of anything that will give anyone pause. Ultimately, Finding Nemo's 3D presentation is as spectacular as its 2D counterpart and will surely delight longtime fans and newcomers of all ages. My scores? A 4.75 for both, each of which rounds up to a nice, well-deserved 5.0.

Finding Nemo 3D Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality 

Good luck leveling even the slightest criticism at Disney's masterclass Dolby TrueHD 7.1 surrounded track. Dialogue is crystal clear and perfectly prioritized, without a single muffled line, drowned cry for help or waterlogged whisper. No small feat considering just the exceedingly enveloping and engaging nature of Nemo's meticulously mixed undersea soundfield. The rear speakers never rest and never relent. Schools of fish dart by, sharks circle, predators give chase, jellyfish press in, bubbles scurry toward the surface, fins flap, tails flick, sand swishes, anemone rustle, plankton flee a pursuing whale, seagulls mount a hungry assault and distant sounds echo through the ocean. Moreover, water flows, currents surge and waves lap throughout the proceedings, and there isn't a moment underwater when the sea isn't incorporated or represented to unmistakably immersive ends. LFE output is terrific too, with powerful low-end pulses, truly intense chase sequences and deep, resonant thooms, booms and shooms. And if a shark or whale is about to take the soundstage, prepare yourself for a thrilling, all-encompassing surround experience. Simply put, everything from the faintest blub blub blub to the most harrowing scene to the ebb and flow of Thomas Newman's pitch-perfect music sounds utterly fantastic.

Finding Nemo 3D Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras 

• Cine-Explore (Disc 2, HD, 101 minutes): Director Andrew Stanton, co-director Lee Unkrich and co-writer Bob Peterson sit down to dissect the film in this deceptively simple, wonderfully thoughtful and exceedingly extensive Picture-in- Picture commentary experience, complete with on-screen concept art, storyboards, pre-viz animation and other production materials.
• Finding Nemo: A Filmmakers' Roundtable (Disc 2, HD, 18 minutes): This newly produced exclusive roundtable reunites Stanton, Unkrich, Peterson, producer Graham Walters, production designer Ralph Eggleston and technical lead Oren Jacob for an engaging 10th anniversary retrospective.
• Reinventing the Submarine Voyage (Disc 2, HD, 15 minutes): Step aboard the Submarine Voyage, both old and new, one of the most beloved attractions in Disneyland's ever-evolving Tomorrowland.
• A Lesson in Flashbacks (Disc 2, HD, 8 minutes): Stanton discusses one of the biggest and hardest lessons he learned while developing and refining Nemo's story and flow.
• Deleted Scene (Disc 2, HD, 3 minutes): An alternate opening presented via animated concept art.
• Knick Knack (Disc 2, HD, 4 minutes): Six years before Toy Story, this short hinted at what was to come.
• Trailers and Sneak Peeks (Disc 2, HD, 6 minutes): Monsters University, Monsters, Inc. 3D, Peter Pan: Diamond Edition and Planes.
• Art Review (Disc 3, HD, 9 minutes): Production designer Ralph Eggleston, character art director Ricky Nierva and shading art director Robin Cooper offer a running commentary of pre-production artwork.
• Making Nemo (Disc 3, SD, 26 minutes): The first of many features culled from the 2003 Collector's Edition DVD, this excellent behind-the-scenes documentary covers everything from the Pixar team's undersea research to the finishing touches added to the finalized animation.
• Exploring the Reef (Disc 3, SD, 7 minutes): An all too brief look at the beauty of the world's endangered coral reefs with host Jean-Michel Cousteau.
• Studio Tour (Disc 3, SD, 5 minutes): Young Alexander Gould explores Pixar Studios and its departments.
• Old School (Disc 3, SD 9 minutes): Up next is a series of quick-hit extras: "El Capitan Pitch Selects," "School Progression," "MA Reference," "Whale Mouth," "International Mine," "Pelican Animation," "Glenn McQueen Tribute" and "Aquascum 2003."
• Deleted Scenes (Disc 3, SD, 6 minutes): "Crush the Hippie," "Shark Volleyball," "Frantic Dad," "Scent of Lavender," "Sewage," "Prologue Bedtime Story" and "Soap Opera/Gil Lies," all presented via animated storyboards.
• Outtakes (Disc 3, SD, 2 minutes): "Chickenfish," "Dory Muttering," "Rove McManus" and "Brooks Punch Lines."
• Publicity Pieces (Disc 3, SD, 13 minutes): Four trailers, plus "Fishy Facts," "ABC Stunts" and "DVD Stunts."
• Mr. Ray's Encyclopedia (Disc 3, SD): An interactive encyclopedia with videos of real undersea creatures.
• Aquariums (Discs 1-3, HD): A collection of short-loop ocean floor screensavers. Discs 1 and 2 feature one each, Disc 3 features a selection of six: "Anemone," "Jellyfish," "Plate Coral," "Reef," "Sandy Reef" and "School of Fish."

Finding Nemo 3D Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation 

Finding Nemo is many a Pixar fan's favorite studio film, and rightfully so. I can't in good conscience declare it perfect or claim it as my ultimate Pixar powerhouse of choice, but I certainly see what draws so many people, young and old, deeper and deeper into its underwater adventure. I've returned to it time and time again over the years and it's never failed to deliver, which says quite a bit. Thankfully, Disney's Blu-ray release is a lot tougher to criticize thanks to a stunning video presentation, an excellent 3D experience, a top-tier Dolby TrueHD 7.1 surround track, and a treasure trove of special features, many of which are new to this release. With the holiday season fast approaching, be sure to add Finding Nemo to your collection, cart or wish list. It'll be one of the few purchases you can almost guarantee you and your family won't regret.