7.2 | / 10 |
Users | 4.6 | |
Reviewer | 4.0 | |
Overall | 4.3 |
Film adaptation of Tim Rice's and Andrew Lloyd Webber's smash stage musical detailing the life and death of Argentina's controversial First Lady.
Starring: Madonna, Antonio Banderas, Jonathan Pryce, Jimmy Nail, Peter PolycarpouMusical | 100% |
Biography | 17% |
Drama | Insignificant |
Video codec: MPEG-4 AVC
Video resolution: 1080p
Aspect ratio: 2.40:1
Original aspect ratio: 2.39:1
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 (48kHz, 24-bit)
English SDH, Spanish
50GB Blu-ray Disc
Single disc (1 BD)
Region free
Movie | 4.5 | |
Video | 4.5 | |
Audio | 4.5 | |
Extras | 2.0 | |
Overall | 4.0 |
Evita's stature has grown with the passage of time, and even if you feel (as many fans do) that Alan Parker's 1996 film adaptation doesn't capture the electricity of the stage musical at its best, the movie remains one of the most effective stage-to-screen adaptations of the last thirty years. Both lyricist Tim Rice and composer Andrew Lloyd Webber have had hugely successful careers, together and apart, and each one is probably better known for works more popular even than Evita (Lloyd Webber for The Phantom of the Opera and—God help us!—Cats, and Rice for The Lion King), but I suspect Evita will remain crucial to their artistic legacies. It seemed a strange premise for a musical when the show debuted in 1978 (after release of a "concept album" in 1976). It must have seemed stranger still when Rice first suggested it to Lloyd Webber. For all the attention she garnered during her short life, many would dispute whether Eva Perón actually accomplished anything. Thousands may have cheered as she stood on the balcony of the Casa Rosada following the election of her husband as president of Argentina, and thousands more followed her coffin to its final resting place when she died a few years later at age 33, but given the troubled history of coups and juntas that followed, it's hard to see her as more than a blip on the radar charting the country's erratic course through the 20th Century. Hers was merely "the death of an actress", says the story's narrator, Ché, dismissively. But Ché doesn't get the final word in Evita, even if he is the story's narrator. One reason for Evita's longevity (aside from the memorable score) is the dramatic energy it generates from the fiery clash of its dramatic leads: Juan Perón the realist, Ché the idealist, and Eva the star, who threatens to overpower them both. In common with all the best dramas, no point of view emerges victorious, but they all have their say. Rice and Lloyd Webber managed to stick closely enough to Eva Perón's biography (though, as with many controversial figures, the facts are in dispute) that, for a long time, Evita seemed to be primarily a historical drama. Over time, however, it has revealed itself as a prescient parable about celebrity in the modern world, especially as celebrity and politics have become almost indistinguishable. The Eva Perón of Evita yearns for power, but she has no interest in actually doing anything with it. That gives her a huge advantage over those, like her husband, still interested in pursuing the "art of the possible", who are quickly upstaged by a woman with a talent for entertainment and, more importantly, a bottomless appetite for the crowd's adulation. Today such people are legion, and they occupy all points on the political spectrum. Evita was their vanguard.
Darius Khondji, the poet of dark spaces who shot David Fincher's Se7en, was the cinematographer on Evita, much of which was shot on location in Buenos Aires and Budapest (where the architecture resembles Buenos Aires of the 1930s). Khondji's palette for Evita is a rich selection of warm earth tones: browns, greens, ochres, rusts. Blues and other cool tones rarely occur except as an accent. The photography effectively evokes both the outer heat of the climate and the emotional heat of the passionate characters. Disney's 1080p, AVC-encoded Blu-ray presents an exceptionally film-like image, which remains finely detailed throughout, though it tends to be softer than eyes accustomed to contemporary digital photography might expect. The extent of detail is most readily observed in the many long shots featuring large groups of people: rallies, military barracks, fancy dining rooms of the upper class. Individual faces are readily distinguishable, as are details of clothing and decor. The image may not "pop", nor should it, since Evita was made before the era when digital intermediates became a standard tool for making film look more like video. Evita looks like film, complete with a light but discernible grain pattern that appears undisturbed by inappropriate filtering or noise reduction. Nor has there been any artificial sharpening applied, though someone might have been tempted to do so, given the softness of the image. Thankfully, any such temptation was resisted. Khondji is known for his blacks, and at least on my monitor, which is properly calibrated, the blacks appeared truly black. Khondji also used different levels of black (and shades of gray) to represent the night in Buenos Aires, when the lights of the city prevent darkness from closing in entirely. Colors are rich and saturated, but rarely are they bright (there's that lack of "pop" again). I have not seen Evita look this good since I first viewed it in the theater. (Note: I have seen claims that the early portion of the film suffers from "DNR". This is just one more example of how the term "DNR" has become internet-speak for "I don't like the picture". I saw absolutely no indication of any noise reduction applied to Evita, or at least none that reduced picture information or "smeared" the image, and I certainly observed no change in image quality midway through the film that was attributable to anything other than the evolution of the story and/or changes in filming technique.)
Evita was released in Dolby Digital 5.1, as was the Criterion laserdisc and the Disney DVD. The Blu-ray's DTS-HD MA 5.1 track presumably shares the same source. Lloyd Webber's music dominates the track, as it should, because it's the sonic "through line" of the film. The orchestra has a rich, full presence that makes good use of the discrete format to provide a sense of depth and to envelop the viewer in the experience. Having heard the PCM 2.0 soundtrack CD many times, I appreciated the additional spaciousness and sense of separation supplied by the 5.1 format. If the soundtrack were being recorded today, it would no doubt benefit from advanced digital recording and mixing techniques, but what's here is quite impressive. (Contrary to the experience reported by some posters, my subwoofer engaged regularly. The orchestra's bass extension doesn't match that of action movie sound effects, but it's appropriately deep for an orchestra.) The vocal recordings from the studio sessions are well-mixed so that they feel part of the action on screen and don't have the vaguely detached quality that one often finds in older movie musicals. Solo voices remain centered, while choruses are spread across the front soundstage. The lyrics are generally intelligible, except for an occasional turn of Banderas' accent or a group intonation that slurs a word, but the subtitles are always available. Sound effects are relegated to a secondary role, and none of them are routed to the rear channels. To do so would be to distract from the music.
Disney's 1998 DVD release of Evita was featureless. A deluxe laserdisc edition from Criterion in 1997 contained all of the features below and considerably more: a trailer (in addition to the "teaser trailer" listed below); 5 TV spots; the illustrated shooting script; a 1947 Time Magazine article about the Peróns illustrated with archival footage; a 1948 New Yorker article illustrated with archival photographs; and a feature-length commentary by director Parker.
Evita reveals something new every time I watch it. On this viewing I was struck by the degree to which Eva's early death transforms her love affair with fame into a Romeo and Juliet story. Over the long haul, fame is a fickle lover, as any of a hundred bio-pics can attest, with their almost ritualized second acts of troubled relationships and substance abuse, when fame turns out to be an emotional sponge, all take and no give. And Eva never had to confront issues of aging and passing the torch; she never had to live that "All About Eve" moment when someone says to her (as she said to Perón's prior mistress): "Hello and goodbye. I've just unemployed you." A short life and a tragic death froze her in fame's embrace, much as we see her in the imaginary waltz with Ché, or even in her last appearance on the Casa Rosada balcony: frail but still beautiful, still offering hope (however illusory) to her descamisados, still functioning as the vessel of impossible dreams. Far from being a tragedy, death completed her achievement and cemented her legacy. Parker's film allows this ironic underside of Evita's story to emerge far better than any stage production I've seen to date, and the Blu-ray capably presents it. Highly recommended.
Director's Extended Edition
2006
Fox Studio Classics
1954
1980
2020
2014
Limited Edition to 3000
1967
Warner Archive Collection
1936
1956
1973
Warner Archive Collection
1964
Warner Archive Collection
1962
1936
2010
Special Edition
2004
1985
Warner Archive Collection
1940
1995
2012
Warner Archive Collection
1952
1979