Rating summary
Movie | | 2.0 |
Video | | 4.0 |
Audio | | 4.0 |
Extras | | 1.5 |
Overall | | 2.5 |
Don't Grow Up Blu-ray Movie Review
Stuck in the Middle with You
Reviewed by Michael Reuben July 18, 2018
Don't Grow Up ("DGU") is a great premise that needs a better script and a more thorough build-out than it gets in French
director Thierry Poiraud's horror film, an English-language project first
seen in European markets in 2015 and now being released in the U.S. through Shudder, the
horror streaming service owned by the AMC network and RLJ Entertainment. Shudder is slowly
venturing into Blu-ray, and its new disc presents DGU to best advantage, but it can't overcome
the film's inherent flaws.
Fans of the original
Star Trek
will remember the episode entitled "Miri", in which an Earth-like
planet is infected with a virus that causes all the adults to go homicidally insane before they die,
and the children who survive live in terror of growing up.
DGU transfers that scenario to a
fictional resort island off the northern English coast (though it omits "Miri's" time-bending
wrinkle in which the virus also slows growth to a crawl, so that the planet's youngsters are
hundreds of years old when the Enterprise finds them).
DGU attempts to build a zombie variation
on "Miri's" notion by having six teenagers on the edge of adulthood awaken to a world in which
the adult population is trying to kill them—and they never know when anyone may cross the
wavering threshold to adulthood that will cause one or more of them to "turn". Bleeding from the
ears is the first visible sign, but it is preceded by subtle changes in attitude. Some of the pre-teen
survivors have banded together for protection, and the most proactive among them have adopted
a simple policy of preemptively shooting anyone old enough to pose a potential threat.
DGU's fundamental flaw is its setting, a fictional resort island where the buildings are far too big
for the sparse population and the six protagonists/victims have to treat as normal a world that the
viewer finds bizarre from the outset. In a film like
28 Days
Later, by contrast, Cillian Murphy's
survivor knows there's something wrong the instant he awakens in a London hospital with
deserted corridors and exits into city streets that are empty instead of bustling.
DGU's teens
accept as routine that they're the sole inhabitants of a sprawling youth home that appears to have
been built to house a hundred or more of the abandoned, troubled and orphaned, and apparently
there's only one adult attendant, whose car is glimpsed speeding away at the film's opening. It's
only when the youngsters venture into town that they realize what's happening, and even then
they don't question the empty shops and streets until they encounter a few crazed grownups. It's hard to build suspense with creepy surroundings
that the characters utterly ignore. If
they're not unsettled, why should we be?
DGU was shot in Spain's Canary Islands, and director Poraud has sought out every eerily
beautiful and deserted landscape he can find, but those vistas aren't especially frightening if
emptiness is their normal state (which appears to be the case). Marie Garel-Weiss's screenplay
only scratches the surface of the characters and their relationships, and Poraud doesn't do enough
with the script's various encounters between the central six and a variety of older and younger
inhabitants to fill out an entire movie. Even at 81 minutes,
DGU feels like a short film padded to
feature length with extended credits (both opening
and closing) and shots and scenes that last too
long to sustain the kind of tension that a horror film needs. The young British cast is game and
shows talent, but they're betrayed by failures of exposition and the director's tin ear (eye?) for
atmosphere.
Don't Grow Up Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality
Don't Grow Up was photographed by Matias Boucard, making his feature debut as a
cinematographer after shooting numerous shorts and other credits that include executive
producing Pixels. It's a clean, sharp and detailed image, typical
of digital capture (with the Arri
Alexa XT, according to IMDb). The palette tends toward the understated and undersaturated,
whether in the expansive landscape shots or in institutional indoors and, as a result, the
occasional flash of bright red blood is more arresting. Video inserts of the characters being interviewed (by whom is never clear) are appropriately
distressed. Shudder has mastered the film on Blu-ray with an average bitrate of 25 Mbps, with a capable encode
Don't Grow Up Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality
DGU's lossless DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack is serviceable but unremarkable, with surround
activity primarily devoted to ambiance and an expansion of the thriller/horror score by Jesús Díaz
and Fletcher Ventura. The dialogue is sometimes buried in the mix and blurred, which is
especially a problem in a tale where spoken words contain essential exposition.
Don't Grow Up Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras
The extras are brief and promotional. Note that, for this release, Shudder appears to have
borrowed Magnolia Home Entertainment's menu and authoring style, right down to the pointless
inclusion of a BD-Live feature without any content. In addition, two of the titles with
introductory trailers are Magnolia's.
- Making of Don't Grow Up (1080p; 2.38:1; 2:32).
- On the Set: Languages and the Director (1080p; 2.38:1; 3:30).
- Inside the Group: Cast and Characters (1080p; 2.38:1; 2:50).
- Don't Grow Up Trailer (1080p; 2.38:1; 1:11).
- Introductory Trailers: At startup, the disc plays trailers for Dead Shack, Found Footage
3D, Marrowbone and Higher Power, plus the promotional spots for the Charity
Network
and AXS TV that are customarily found on discs from Magnolia Home Entertainment.
However, unlike Magnolia titles, Don't Grow Up does not contain an option to play these
trailers from the "Special Features" menu.
- BD-Live: "Check back later for updates."
Don't Grow Up Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation
DGU has an interesting, if derivative, premise, and its young cast is appealing, but its script
needed more work, and its director's visual choices sabotage his intentions. Rent (or stream) if
interested.