8.6 | / 10 |
| Users | 0.0 | |
| Reviewer | 3.0 | |
| Overall | 3.0 |
Curb Your Enthusiasm is the critically acclaimed HBO comedy series which stars Larry David, co-creator and executive producer of "Seinfeld". Larry David has a pretty good life. Pretty, pretty good. He has understanding friends, a tolerant wife, and his plans for the afterlife are all plotted out. See Larry take in a family of Blacks, make a generous donation, pay his respects to the dead, and befriend the handicapped. Is Larry David the most magnanimous man we know.... or the most misunderstood?
Starring: Larry David, Jeff Garlin, Cheryl Hines, Susie Essman, J.B. Smoove| Comedy | Uncertain |
| Dark humor | Uncertain |
Video codec: MPEG-4 AVC
Video resolution: 1080p
Aspect ratio: 1.78:1
Original aspect ratio: 1.78:1, 1.33:1
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1
English SDH
Blu-ray Disc
Twenty four-disc set (24 BDs)
Region A, B (C untested)
| Movie | 5.0 | |
| Video | 3.0 | |
| Audio | 4.0 | |
| Extras | 2.5 | |
| Overall | 3.0 |
It may be salient to "confess" up front that I am evidently one of very few people in the world who generally did not find Seinfeld: The Complete Series to be a so-called "laff riot", which is not to say I didn't appreciate its often snarky humor. Seinfeld's very particular brand of comedy might frankly engender grudging smirks of recognition in me, maybe, and occasional giggles, but very few outright guffaws, if I'm being completely honest. Occasionally the show's weird off kilter detours would actually hit an absolute bullseye for me, as this vignette did for me as your resident Sergio Mendes obsessive and inveterate record collector. For those acquainted with some of the great used record stores that dot (or at least used to dot) the Pacific Northwest, I went into the late, great Bird's Suite on Hawthorne Boulevard in Portland when I was a starving youth and, yes, attempted to sell a Sergio Mendes record. The clerk was even more dismissive than the one on Seinfeld, and in fact mispronounced Sergio's name, but I arguably outdid Kramer and Newman in my umbrage by "informing" the clerk that the album I was trying to sell actually had a (minor) hit single written for Sergio by Stevie Wonder. (My closing comments below share some more information on why that particular Seinfeld vignette was so memorable for me personally.) My only intermittent moments of hilarity watching Seinfeld may indicate some kind of deficit in my funny bone which I'll willingly cop to, but rather interestingly, at least given the many tethers between Seinfeld and Curb Your Enthusiasm, the Larry David HBO outing regularly tickled my personal funny bone more than the adventures of Jerry and his often (always?) dysfunctional cohort.


Curb Your Enthusiasm: The Complete Series is presented on Blu-ray courtesy of Warner Brothers Home Entertainment and HBO with AVC
encoded 1080p transfers in 1.78:1. That constant aspect ratio will probably be the first thing to chafe at videophiles' sensibilities, since the first six
seasons were originally broadcast in 1.33:1, and the reframings can lead to some odd things like the tops of heads largely missing. Aside from the
aspect ratio rejiggering, what will probably really set some teeth on edge
or eyes in need of some kind of masking is the totally bizarre decision to present the first six seasons at circa 24 fps . That gives the native 30i material
a jerky quality that may be more distracting for some viewers
than others, perhaps in an analogous way to how some people have greater or lesser issues with parallax misalignment in 3D presentations. That
combined with a not particularly attractive upscale of the standard definition source is probably going to lead to pretty significant disappointment from
longtime fans wanting some kind of "definitive" release. Video
quality takes a major uptick in more ways than one starting with the digitally captured seventh season on. Suddenly fluidity is markedly improved, the
palette is healthier and clarity takes a major step forward. The whole mishandling of the first six seasons would make a perfect "very special episode"
of Curb Your Enthusiasm, but the upshot is fans of the series may need to take the series' title to heart with regard to the first six seasons.
My score is an average, with the first six seasons getting a 1.5-2.0 and the latter seasons getting a 4.0-4.5.
It's interesting in a way to compare this Blu-ray release to the joint Seinfeld: The Complete
Series and Seinfeld: The Complete Series
4K sets that Sony put out about a year ago, in that the 1080 release like this one reframed things to 1.78:1, though rather interestingly
Sony's 4K release preserved the original 1.33:1 aspect ratio.

Note: I've received several concerned private messages from prospective consumers prior to the writing of this review who report a number of
online sites have Dolby Digital audio listed for this release. I have confirmed the codec is DTS-HD Master Audio, as listed above.
There's a slight but nowhere near as dramatic "shift" between the first six seasons and the subsequent years in the audio department as well, with the
series opening with DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 tracks and then moving on to at least slightly more immersive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks for
seasons seven through twelve. This is such a talk heavy series that the ostensibly increased channelization available in the later seasons tends to be
subtle a lot of the time and frankly intermittent depending on how much "David chaos" is unfolding at any given moment. The series' really fun use of
music does get some more spaciousness, and scenes with a bunch of characters (often talking over each other in Hawksian disarray) provide some
immersion. All spoken material is rendered cleanly and clearly. Optional English subtitles are available.

Note: Unless they're somehow hidden as easter eggs that escaped my diligent searching for them, none of the previously released
commentary tracks are included, despite (again from PMs from members to me about this release) apparent online sources claiming they're included.
All of the
supplements on the first seven seasons look like they're in the wrong aspect ratio, all widened to various degrees.
Season 1, Disc 2

While that above well remembered (attempted) used record selling episode of Seinfeld has entered the lexicon
of "Seinfeld-ian" quotable dialogue vis a vis the legendary Sergio Mendes (I am a part of his "cult", and proudly so), the
inclusion
of Don Ho in addition to Sergio struck me as particularly funny for a pretty unique reason, one which I could easily see David utilizing as the basis for
some kind of episodic rant about idiots on the world wide web. Years ago, in the very early days of the internet, there
was a Usenet group devoted to musical theater that I subscribed to, and who should show up one day but the manager for Steve Lawrence and
Eydie Gorme, who
announced that the pair was releasing the Original Broadway Cast recording of their musical Golden Rainbow on CD themselves, and that
any fans interested could contact the manager personally to purchase a copy. Lo and behold, all of us who did respond then found
ourselves BCC'd (we all assumed unintentionally) on an absolutely vicious email chain between that manager and Don Ho's manager discussing an
impending joint concert that was scheduled for Hawaii. Ho's manager wanted Don to have top billing due to his Hawaiian imprimatur, but Steve and
Eydie's manager was having none of it, and it got very heated, with each of them throwing barbs at each other about the perceived lack of
commercial success recently for the other one's client(s). Now, that's comedy.
This is going to be a cup half full, cup half empty situation for many, with an
understanding that any Larry David fan worth his or her salt will then go off on a tangent about what kind of a cup it is. I'm kind of on the
fence, since the latter half of this set looks and sounds fine, but the botched first half and weirdnesses in existing supplements and lack of other
previously released supplements make this a case of caveat emptor for me.

2013

2005-2012

Limited Edition
1989-1998

2013

UK
2001-2003

2006

1998

2010


Unrated Special Edition
2009

2012

1996

Unrated Extended Edition
2007

2013

2009

Season 1
2004

1987

2015

#XtendedCut
2012

2016