Beautiful Girls Blu-ray Movie

Rating summary

Movie		3.0
Video		2.5
Audio		3.0
Extras		1.5
Overall		2.5

Beautiful Girls Blu-ray Movie Review

Not-so-beautiful picture quality.

Reviewed by Martin Liebman March 26, 2013

There are all sorts of dramatic tales and narratives and arcs out there. The beauty of the cinema medium is its ability to depict every single one of them multiple times over, with different perspectives and unique flavors, often with varying degrees of success. Chances are, if there's a subject that interests someone, there's been a movie made about it. The classic "coming of age" story is one of the constant staples of the medium, a subject that's been covered in countless films and, as always, to varying degrees of success. Director Ted Demme's Beautiful Girls is a story about a handful of young adults searching for their place in the world, living their lives only as they know how while on the path towards something, they hope, beyond the cards they've been dealt. The story as presented herein is told smoothly and cleanly, but there's not much of an original spark to it with precious few reasons -- mostly centered on the cast -- to choose it over all the other, similar films. It's fine at what it does, not too structurally complex or dramatically dull, but there's just not much in Beautiful Girls to set it apart from the pack.

Together again.

Willie Conway (Timothy Hutton) is returning home to small-town Massachusetts for a ten-year high school reunion. Of his group of friends, he's the only one to escape the snowy little town and do something more than plow snow with his life. He's now a big-city lounge piano player and is contemplating taking more steady work as a salesman. He's greeted warmly upon his arrival and soon strikes up a friendship with young Marty (Natalie Portman), a new-to-him next-door-neighbor who, at only thirteen, has the presence of an adult and treats him as such, in more ways than one. Meanwhile, Willie reconnects with his old friends. Tommy Rowland (Matt Dillon) operates the town's snow plow and finds himself caught between two women, his girlfriend Sharon (Mira Sorvino) and the married Darian (Lauren Holly) who dated Tommy years ago and desperately wants him back. Paul (Michael Rapaport) is another plow man who hasn't quite matured beyond puberty. He lives surrounded by posters of pin-up girls and dreams of dating one. The friends often meet at a tavern run by "Stinky" (Pruitt Taylor Vince). He has a sexy cousin (Uma Thurman) who arrives in town and complicates matters for several of the locals. As the friends reunite and deal with life and love, they must make the choices that will guide their respective courses for the rest of their lives.

It's hard to dislike a movie like Beautiful Girls -- it's tender and thoughtful beneath the mountain of genre cliché -- but then again it's easy to brush it off considering the broad unoriginality that runs through it. It lacks the creativity and novelty to be called a "classic" or anything close to that, but it's nevertheless highly proficient at what it does. It's a true, honest "life progression" movie, and if the film does anything spectacularly, it's the authenticity with which it paints its characters, even if they develop rather predictably as the film moves along. The characters are everyday folks with everyday problems, struggles, wants, desires, dreams, and needs. They're largely imperfect, but it's that imperfection that shapes them into better people by the end. The movie is largely about a search for self, a want for something more, a need to choose a path. Sometimes, the movie rightly states, it takes a little bit of time back with the past to forge a trail towards the proper future. It's a story about how the search and the journey never really end, about how things change and stay the same, both inside and out. Beautiful Girls has all of this formula down very well, but it never really does wonders with the material.

The generally recycled, predicable, and clichéd material is helped along by what is mostly a brilliant cast. Even when an actor, or a group, isn't firing on all cylinders in the movie, the sheer star power and surrounding top performances really balance the film and, for the most part, the performances are quite good. The film is at its best in its scenes featuring both Timothy Hutton and Natalie Portman. Their chemistry is eerily natural, and Portman's performance is exceptional. She handles the character with a confidence and natural ability that she really hasn't found in her later years, capturing the same sort of effortless screen magic she displayed in The Professional, a film in which she works with a superior script but here finds a depth and meaning to her character that's not quite so readily evident in the scripted dialogue alone. Nearly every other face in the film is familiar, and most every player falls right into the place and time of the movie's wintry Northeastern setting. It's a cast that provides the movie a very much needed and welcome authenticity. The film benefits greatly from the pure sense of realism that's a product of the believable longtime camaraderie between all of the primaries. It helps better shape the plot arc and the dramatic specifics both, yet that cloud of unoriginality still hinders, but thankfully doesn't destroy, the film.

Beautiful Girls Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality 

Beautiful Girls features a dull, uninspired transfer. The image is stable enough and offers adequate details and colors, but at its best it's not a significant improvement over standard definition. Details are flat, generally, with no life or heavy textures. Faces often appear particularly pasty, while clothes lack that tactile detailing often found on the best Blu-rays. Exteriors both night and day fare nicely enough, however. Colors are quite dreary, for the most part, even against blinding white snowy backdrops. The image is sometimes severely dull, never finding any vibrance even in the most diverse hues. Black levels and flesh tone are neither great nor disappointing. There's very little in the way of grain, but there is some heavy wear-and-tear over the opening titles. Some edge enhancement is visible in spots, but blocky backgrounds and banding are largely absent. This is a serviceable transfer but fans expecting more will be disappointed.

Beautiful Girls Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality 

Beautiful Girls features an uninspired but adequate DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 lossless soundtrack. There's decent presence to the opening music and, indeed, all subsequent songs. Generally, there's a fair front end spacing, clear instrumental playback, and quality vocals that hover in the middle. The track delivers some small but mood- and environment-critical elements well enough. A plow crunching over snowy streets, for instance, comes across well enough that the effect isn't mistaken for something else. There are a few good moments of true, precise ambient effects, such as in Stinky's bar or out on a skating pond. Otherwise, this one is largely all about dialogue. The spoken word is delivered clearly and intelligibly from movie start to finish. This is by no means reference material, but it gets viewers through the movie with no major issues.

Beautiful Girls Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras 

Beautiful Girls contains two supplements.

• Behind the Curtain (SD, 27:00): A mix-and-match piece that offers a somewhat detailed cast and crew dissection of the film, a music video, a Jon Stewart interview with cast and crew, clips from the movie Flirting with Disaster, and more.
• What is True Beauty? (SD, 3:24): The cast shares its thoughts on "true beauty."

Beautiful Girls Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation 

Beautiful Girls isn't much of a cinema novelty -- these sorts of "finding one's place in the world in the company of old friends and in the comfort zone of the old stomping grounds" films are fairly commonplace -- but the picture pieces together a wonderful cast and strong performances that bring more definition to the film than it could ever find in the unimaginative script alone. There's not much of a reason to watch beyond the cast, and this is one of the better ensembles of the 1990s. Echo Bridge' Blu-ray release of Beautiful Girls delivers passably drab video and audio. Two extras are included. Rent it.