5.7 | / 10 |
Users | 4.4 | |
Reviewer | 1.5 | |
Overall | 3.7 |
It was great to be alive, once, but the world was perishing. Factories were shutting down, transportation was grinding to a halt, granaries were empty--and key people who had once kept it running were disappearing all over the country. As the lights winked out and the cities went cold, nothing was left to anyone but misery. No one knew how to stop it, no one understood why it was happening - except one woman, the operating executive of a once mighty transcontinental railroad, who suspects the answer may rest with a remarkable invention and the man who created it - a man who once said he would stop the motor of the world. Everything now depends on finding him and discovering the answer to the question on the lips of everyone as they whisper it in fear: Who *is* John Galt?
Starring: Taylor Schilling, Grant Bowler, Edi Gathegi, Michael O'Keefe, Navid NegahbanSci-Fi | 100% |
Mystery | 26% |
Drama | 20% |
Video codec: MPEG-4 AVC
Video resolution: 1080p
Aspect ratio: 2.35:1
Original aspect ratio: 2.39:1
English: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1
English SDH, Spanish
50GB Blu-ray Disc
Single disc (1 BD)
Region A (locked)
Movie | 1.5 | |
Video | 3.5 | |
Audio | 3.5 | |
Extras | 2.0 | |
Overall | 1.5 |
The long-in-the-making Atlas Shrugged: Part I, the film version of the first third of novelist Ayn Rand’s politicizing magnum opus, has arrived
just in time to coincide with the Tea Party’s newfound and sometimes paradoxical obsession with Rand’s objectivist, “rational self-interest” philosophy.
The loudest voices on the political right—who are also unassailably aligned with religious conservatives—have co-opted Rand’s pro-unfettered capitalism
views, all the while conveniently dismissing the fact that Rand was a fiercely anti-church atheist who believed, as she put it in her book For the
New Intellectual, that all religion amounted to “a protection racket…making life on earth unbearable, then charging you for consolation and
relief.”
Conservatives have essentially cherry-picked from Rand’s novel what they want to hear and already believe—namely, that “job-creators” are the
defining beneficial force of society, that government regulation and unions are evils to rally against, and that laissez-faire, totally free-market capitalism
is the only economic system capable of protecting and nurturing an individual’s rights. Right-leaning Washington Times columnist Scott Galupo
even puts it this way: “Conservatives’ embrace of “Atlas Shrugged” today is nothing more than blinkered escapist fantasy—rather like a besieged army
turning to Norse mythology or J.R.R. Tolkien to boost morale.” Yet I strongly doubt anyone’s morale will be boosted by Atlas Shrugged: Part I,
a depressingly low-rent adaptation that’s stilted and poorly scripted and completely devoid of entertainment value. Even the most rabid objectivist
should be objective enough to see that this film has to be shrugged off as worthless.
Dagny Taggart
Atlas Shrugged: Part I was shot digitally with the very capable Red One camera, but there's more to cinematography than just the source format. The film's rather bland, sometimes overly bright lighting gives it the cheap look of a made-for-TV movie. Still, technically, there's not much wrong with the 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer presented here. Video noise is visible in darker scenes but kept to a minimum, there are no halo-ish byproducts of edge enhancement, no DNR smearing, and no blatant compression-related issues. This is a solid encode. You can't complain about clarity, either. While there are certainly a few soft shots, most scenes are more than adequately sharp, with fine high definition detail easily visible in facial texture, hair definition, and other areas where you normally look for it. Color is generally bold, warm, and well-saturated too, but the flat lighting really isn't doing the film any favors. The picture rarely looks appropriately cinematic. Black levels can crush shadow detail at times—especially in dark interiors —but contrast during outdoor and daylight scenes is spot on. This isn't exactly eye candy, but I can't fault the encode for the film's chintzy cinematography and set design.
Similarly, the modestly-budgeted movie features expectedly underwhelming sound design, although it all comes through decently enough via a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track. Most of the time, the soundfield feels decidedly empty and front-heavy, with little environmental ambience and few cross-channels effects beyond the occasional zipping to and fro of the Taggart Transcontinental trains. The rear speakers really only get used for the swelling of the film's orchestral score, which veers between ominous and triumphant and sounds fairly rich, with good bass response and clarity throughout the range. There are a few instances where dialogue takes on a slightly hollow quality, but it's usually clear and full and easy to understand. I didn't notice a low-volume hiss in the surround channels from time to time—only when I really made an effort to listen for it—but there are no dropouts, crackles, or other unacceptable audio traits. Overall, the mix is acceptable but never remotely impressive.
This film version of Atlas Shrugged has gotten some traction on talk radio and within fiscally conservative circles—the target audience—but unless you're completely blinded by ideology it's plain to see that the movie is constructed more poorly than a sweatshop t-shirt. It's all-around bad, a cheapo adaptation that fails to entertain, let alone—judging by the movie's box office numbers—achieve its goal of spreading Ayn Rand's views on economics and individual rights to a larger audience. Unless you're some kind of tri-cornered hat-wearing, picket sign-toting Tea Partier who will love the film no matter what, you should probably avoid Part I at all costs. The producers say the next two installments in the trilogy are still coming, but I'll believe it when I see it.
2012
2014
2016
2022
2008-2013
2015-2022
1997
2018
15th Anniversary Edition
2002
2010
Definitive Edition
1980
2012
2009-2010
2019
2010
The George Lucas Director's Cut
1971
2018
2009
2017
2010