Rating summary
Movie | | 4.5 |
Video | | 4.0 |
Audio | | 4.5 |
Extras | | 2.5 |
Overall | | 4.0 |
Another Year Blu-ray Movie Review
If a picture says a thousand words, the last few frames of 'Another Year' summarize a lifetime's worth emotions.
Reviewed by Martin Liebman July 19, 2011
Life's not always kind, is it?
Another Year is a movie about the "haves" and the "have nots," but not as they pertain to the financial implications with which most associate
those terms. No, this is a story about those who live life and those who don't, or better said, those who lead a happy and fruitful life and those who
merely get by as far as their limited social graces allow. Another Year is a daunting, challenging, sobering, and sometimes even difficult film to
watch because it paints people in a state of despair that's obvious and runs very deep. Add that there seems to be no help in sight for them and the
audience's frustrations with the characters will only grow as they slowly degrade through the course of a two-hour year. Still, this is a film that doesn't
exactly
paint its message and purpose in broad strokes. Instead, one must look past the superficialities to find what it is Writer/Director Mike Leigh is trying to
accomplish with his film. The only question that remains is whether viewers can tolerate the characters and suffer along with them in what might be
an ultimately futile effort to discover what the movie has to say about life and the way people live it.
Festering despair.
Longtime husband/wife tandem Tom and Gerri Hepple (Jim Broadben and Ruth Sheen) have the ideal marriage. They get along swimmingly, have
done and still are doing well for themselves, and have surrounded themselves with good people while rightly raising their now thirty-year-old son Joe
(Oliver Maltman). Unfortunately, the pains of the real world are about to catch up with the blissfully wedded couple. No, their marriage isn't in
jeopardy, but all the negativity they've managed to keep out of their relationship -- heartache, despair, depression, even death -- will within the
course of one year in some way shape
their lives. The upheaval centers around Gerri's longtime co-worker Mary (Lesley Manville), a single woman with big dreams but neither the means
nor the attitude to get what she wants. She longs for a relationship with the right man -- a good man like Tom -- and with most of the good men
taken or not to her liking, she dares flirt with the one man she probably shouldn't approach. Meanwhile, depressed old friends and grief-stricken
relatives will take their toll on the strong Hepple couple, but no matter the challenge they can count on their rock-solid marriage to get them
through, even with
the albatross that is Mary hanging over their necks to challenge their happiness and many strengths of character.
Never mind that
Another Year is marketed as the story of Tom and Gerri, longtime lovebirds who witness the slow deterioration of the lives
of
those around them. That's certainly true, but with the way the movie is structured -- and considering its final shot in particular -- It's difficult to see
this
as anything other than Mary's movie. It's her emotional state that truly sets the story in motion; she interacts with every character that appears
throughout
the film, whether the mainstays Tom, Gerri, and Joe, or the "seasonal" friends, relatives, and acquaintances such as Tanya, Ken, and Ronnie. She's
the driving force in the film, but she's also, potentially, its biggest hindrance. She's certainly loquacious, which comes with a price. She's in a near
constant state of emotional excitement, bounding with energy and a motor mouth that gets her on the wrong side of all who cross her path,
whether her figurative -- and sometimes literal, it seems -- victims admit it to her or themselves or not. Often
drunk and flirtatious, she annoys the characters who are too polite to shut her up and bothers the audience like fingernails scraping on a chalkboard.
Her
routine wears thin rather quickly and grows obnoxious to the point that the movie sometimes borders on the unwatchable.
But it's all deliberate and part of
Director Mike Leigh's masterful manipulation of the audience. Once Mary turns from exuberant but annoying companion to emotional train wreck
who can't shut up and get out of the scene fast enough,
that audience hostility turns into something of an aching sympathy. One can't help but realize she means well but has painted herself
into a corner and isolated herself to the point that she disappears even in a small gathering, becoming an inconsequential body filling a chair at the
dinner table and not a human being engaged in the discussions, revelry, and fun happening around her. Hers is a truly self-destructuve character;
she knows what she wants but she always sabotages her own life by unrealistically raising her expectations and clinging to false hopes and fantasies
that are far less likely to materialize than they are to suddenly come true as if she only needed to tap her heels together three times.
Viewers will grow to dislike her -- maybe even hate her -- but find themselves being beat upon by their better judgement for having developed such
a strong negative reaction towards what is certainly one of the most polarizing and complicated but ultimately sympathetic and sad figures in recent
cinema memory.
The rest of the film isn't exactly as it seems, either. Writer/Director Mike Leigh crafts the picture as if a master manipulator.
Another Year
is subtly melancholic
and grows into something downright depressing, and he manages to emotionally wear down his viewers simply by having them witness the slow but
steady decline of the characters who appear on-screen. Even as Tom and Gerri are the rocks throughout the movie, their world seems as if a
bubble, a force field that somehow protects them from the negativity that surrounds them but that deflects all the incoming bad vibes back at the
characters who can't take any more. Unfortunately, the audience has no such protective
shield, and the negativity seems to spill out of the screen like a waterfall.
Another Year is all about its emotional content; the picture is
dialogue intensive but few of the spoken words really matter. They convey parts of the plot to be
sure, but this
film is all about the looks on people's faces, the happiness, regret, anger, or sadness in their eyes. Mike Leigh makes sure to direct with an invisible
hand; his camera serves merely as a device that allows his audience to witness the story develop, which lends a greater sense of realism to
the film. The end result feels more like a stage play than a movie, allowing viewers to fully concentrate on the characters rather than be distracted
by unnecessary movement or other tricks of the trade meant to spice up the screen rather than allow a story to unfold. It's all very well done, with
the
performances wonderfully engaging and positively seamless. Lesley Manville is fantastic as Mary; for all the raw emotion her character lets out --
and all the
raw emotion she struggle to keep in -- her performance is a thing of beauty, even if she manipulates the audiences into a wave of varied feelings
towards her that absolutely define the movie and what viewers will take away from it.
Another Year Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality
Another Year features a steady and stable but not-quite-perfect 1080p transfer. Despite some evident softness, the image enjoys
above-average detailing both in the usual places -- faces and clothes -- and in more general areas, such as chips and dents in wooden door frames, the
rough
texture of pavement, and the layout of the short-cut greens at a golf course. Outside of those few soft shots, the image displays a readily-evident
crispness and superior clarity that allow
details to be
well-defined all over the screen, and not just centered on whatever happens to be in the middle of the frame. Colors are well balanced, vibrant
when need be but sometimes washed out and occasionally downright gray, but only as the film's mood calls for such drastic shifts. Blacks, however, are
a little murky and not too kind to foreground detailing. On the plus side, the source is spotlessly clean and is free of any distracting edge enhancement,
debilitating blocking, or unsightly banding. This is another strong effort from Sony, but not quite a showcase title.
Another Year Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality
Another Year is one of those Character Dramas that doesn't really require much of its soundtrack. The picture is content to get by primarily on
light music and dialogue, and Sony's Blu-ray handles both admirably. Music plays with exceptional clarity, as light as it may be; it sounds perfectly
natural and pleasant, the kind that melts away the speakers in favor of a natural, lifelike authenticity. No doubt the music is very gentle and reserved,
but that in no way lessens the raw sonic quality. Dialogue is expectedly strong, grounded in the middle and of course free of secondary obstruction, a
given considering the meagerness of the surrounding elements. A
few ambient effects are perfectly integrated, too, notably a gently falling sheet of rain early in the film and two random passes of a wailing ambulance in
the film. If there's a fault, there seems to be a completely random but ever-so-slight rumbly undercurrent running through parts of the
track. It doesn't seem to fit, but it's there. Still, this is a very high quality audio presentation and a showcase for how good even the most subtle of
soundtracks can be.
Another Year Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras
Another Year arrives on Blu-ray with a handful of extras, the majority of which in one way or another revolve around Writer/Director Mike
Leigh.
- Audio Commentary: Director Mike Leigh and Actress Lesley Mannville discuss the film. Leigh dives straight into the commentary
after
a
short delay, speaking on the film's structure, its look, the characters, the quality of the cast, his shooting style, the details of the plot and the
nuances that truly define it, and many of the additional expected insights. Mannville joins in after awhile, speaking primarily on her performance and
the
surrounding themes in the film as her character defines them. Leigh does a fine job breaking the film down, almost speaking at times as one might
expect of a college film professor. Those who enjoyed the film definitely need to give this one their full attention.
- The Making of Another Year (480p, 12:29): For those who don't have an additional two hours to spend with the commentary,
this supplement features Mike Leigh hitting some of the highlights as he speaks on what the film is all about. Additionally, members of the cast and
crew
share their thoughts on the film and discuss their contributions to making the final product.
- The Mike Leigh Method (480p, 11:48): A short feature that looks at the director in action, featuring Leigh himself and others discussing
his filmmaking techniques.
- Another Year Original Theatrical Trailer (1080p, 1:45).
- Previews (1080p): additional Sony titles.
- DVD Copy.
Another Year Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation
Another Year is an exhausting film that leads its audience through a minefield of emotions, not only those of the characters on-screen but those
that fester and threaten to explode in the gut of all who watch the film. It's the ultimate manipulative film that sees its audience through a wide range
of sensations, from annoyance to enmity, from regret to sorrow. Director Mike Leigh's film certainly isn't for everybody. It's slow and deliberate but it's
just about the ultimate true Character Drama out there. Made with completely unobtrusive direction, wonderful acting, and a story that's meaning
comes more from the eyes and body language and seen and unseen emotions of the characters than in its pages and pages of sometimes monotonous
and empty
dialogue, Another Year may be seen as nothing short of a uniquely engaging picture that drives the emotions like few others. Sony's Blu-ray
release of Another Year features a good video transfer, a reserved but high quality lossless soundtrack, and a few extras. Recommended.