9 Blu-ray Movie

Rating summary

Movie		3.5
Video		4.5
Audio		4.5
Extras		4.0
Overall		4.0

9 Blu-ray Movie Review

An uneven animated adventure receives an excellent Blu-ray release...

Reviewed by Kenneth Brown December 19, 2009

An animated future dystopia? Bizarre burlap dolls battling bestial machines in the shadows of post-apocalyptic ruins? The support of dark fairytale wunderkind Tim Burton and Russian madman Timur Bekmambetov? I cannot begin to convey how excited I was to see 9 after marveling at its first theatrical trailer. But I should have known months of mounting expectations would once again lead to disappointment. Its story wasn't the sprawling epic I had hoped for; its wasteland wasn't the mind-blowing, ashen wonderland its trailer promised; its characters weren't the complex survivors I had sketched out in my mind. I walked away disillusioned and disheartened. Thankfully, my second visit to 9's war-torn cityscape proved to be more rewarding. Its flaws were still apparent, as was its squandered potential, but the whole of the film was more satisfying.

Loss and loneliness permeates the dolls' encounters with their unrelenting mechanical foe...

Based on writer/director Shane Acker's Oscar-nominated animated short of the same name, the film tells the tale of a family of diminutive dolls -- skeptic and self-proclaimed leader 1 (voiced by Christopher Plummer), sweet-natured scout 2 (Martin Landau), mute catalogers 3 and 4, kind-hearted inventor 5 (John C. Reilly), obsessed artist 6 (Crispin Glover), graceful rogue warrior 7 (Jennifer Connelly), and burly swordsman 8 (Fred Tatasciore) -- who are forced to contend with a vicious machine inadvertently reactivated by their newest member, 9 (Elijah Wood). Their very existence is a mystery, as is their purpose, and their understanding of the world in which they live is limited to their elders' firsthand accounts of the destruction of man. Some feel they should flee the vicinity and live out their lives in seclusion. Others feel it's their god-given duty to stay and fight, a responsibility their creator seems to have tasked them with. Now, inspired by 6's crazed scribblings and 9's determination, the dolls have to choose between remaining hidden or trying to stop the very machine that eradicated humanity in the first place.

9 is the sort of film that's grown on me with multiple viewings; the sort of film that will probably continue to do so. While I envisioned a grander story, I've come to realize Acker's smaller scope isn't necessarily a detriment. And while I expected more engaging characters, several third-act revelations about the dolls' creation make their rather one-note personalities far less distracting. If anything, the fact that the central conflict is one of the dolls' own doing remains the film's greatest weakness. It's more difficult to care about their plight when humanity is already extinct and their enemy has left no one for them to save. Self-preservation is never as powerful a theme as sacrificing oneself for the greater good. It doesn't help that the ending turns out to be such an expendable, tacked-on denouement. Having listened to the disc's elaborate commentary, I finally understand what the filmmakers were aiming to do, but the film's closing scenes are still some of its most jarring and nonsensical. Had Acker given his barren world more context from the outset, it might not require two viewings and an audio commentary to appreciate 9's finer qualities. However, because most animation fans won't give Acker more than one opportunity to win them over -- I doubt I would have watched it more than once if it weren't for this review -- many will simply declare 9 an underwhelming letdown and move on. As someone who initially despised the film but has since come to enjoy its haunting simplicity, I can tell you that would be a shame.

9's jaw-dropping animation is more immune to criticism. Everything from the expressive tin eyes of the film's fateful heroes to the cold, calculating sheen of its mechanical beasties exudes soul; every crumbling building, pile of rubble, and human corpse lends an intriguing bit of backstory Acker is all too willing to overlook. Inks splashes onto parchment, electricity crackles whenever the Scientist's machine bellows, scissored incisors rattle as a diving creature attacks, dust bristles as a warrior decapitates a lunging monster, thin stitches pull and tear as an arm is left tattered... it's all a wondrously dark and menacing sight to behold. Humans, though only seen in flashbacks, lack the polish and spirit of Acker's burlap warriors and devious bots, but little else falls short. Still, despite its beauty, 9 will continue to be a divisive oddity. Neither a groundbreaking gut-punch nor an utter waste, it will speak to a select few far more than others. A handful of boundary pushing images further limit its appeal, particularly since a few minor cuts would have earned it a more family-friendly PG-rating without affecting Acker's tone or atmosphere in the slightest. As it stands, 9 is worth watching -- in some cases worth watching more than once -- and should continue to welcome eager newcomers into its fold.

9 Blu-ray Movie, Video Quality 

9 is an absolute joy to watch in high definition. Blessed with a magnificent 1080p/VC-1 transfer, its every frame exudes the kind of color and clarity videophiles long for. Otherworldly greens, blazing-hearth oranges, earthy burlap browns, ferocious reds, and inkblot blacks bring the dolls and their world to vibrant life, rendering every hue, stitch, hair, flame, and shadow with the utmost care. Minted directly from its digital source, the presentation is nearly flawless. Only a hint of faint banding (occasionally visible in the night skies) and some minor, I stress minor aliasing (watch the metal surrounding the machine god's eye) hold the image back from perfection. Otherwise, detail is impeccable, edges are sharp and clean, textures are immaculate, and Acker's vision is intact. From a technical standpoint, the results are just as impressive. Artifacting, noise, crush, edge enhancement, and other pesky unmentionables are nowhere to be found. The picture is stable and strong throughout and never succumbs to any debilitating anomalies that might undermine Acker's visual achievements. I can't imagine anyone will be disappointed with Universal's efforts. If anything, most viewers will be more forgiving of its mild banding and aliasing (if they notice either issue at all) and award the transfer the top marks it arguably deserves.

9 Blu-ray Movie, Audio Quality 

Universal's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track is equally powerful save one small problem: dialogue prioritization. Voices are a bit low at times, particularly whenever the dolls are attacked by their screeching oppressors, and a few inconsequential lines are lost in the chaos of battle. That being said, I suspect each instance is a product of intention; Acker's desire to make 9 and his comrades seem even smaller and more frail in the face of insurmountable odds. Luckily, everything else is flawless. Rear speaker activity is aggressive and enveloping, LFE output is forceful and resonant, and the soundfield is eerily realistic and undeniably immersive. There wasn't a moment I felt yanked out of 9's world; not a moment I felt disconnected from the billowing factories or empty expanses that dot his journey. Sound leaps from channel to channel as gracefully as 7 fells a towering beast, pans are swift and smooth, and directionality is precise and convincing. Steely nerved children will clasp their hands to their ears and audiophiles will nod in enthusiastic approval. Suffice to say, 9 sounds fantastic.

9 Blu-ray Movie, Special Features and Extras 

The Blu-ray edition of 9 arrives with a thoroughly absorbing supplemental package; one that will even appeal to people like myself who weren't thrilled with the film itself. It includes an exclusive Picture-in-Picture track, an engaging audio commentary, and a variety of additional features (many of which are presented in high definition) that help the disc stand out from most other animated releases.

• U-Control Experience: I haven't been entirely impressed with Universal's U-Control tracks of late, but the Picture-in-Picture gem that accompanies 9 is definitely an exception. With a steady stream of cast and crew interviews, director commentary, candid footage from the actors' recording sessions, storyboards, concept art, animatics, production stills, and much, much more, it's arguably worth the price of admission alone. I do wish every stretch of silence had been filled with additional artwork, but the PiP content is strong enough to push viewers through the thankfully brief breaks in the track.
• Audio Commentary: Be careful not to overlook this equally exceptional audio commentary (it appears alongside the audio options, not in the special features menu). Writer/director Shane Acker, animation director Joe Ksander, head of story Ryan O'Laughlin, and editor Nick Kenway are a chatty bunch, but they remain focused throughout, dissecting 9's characters, their motivations, and the world in which they live, as well as the film's visuals, atmosphere, sound design, and animation. Surprisingly, they rarely repeat information found in the U-Control track, sticking to aspects of the production that haven't been covered elsewhere on the disc.
• The Original Short (SD, 11 minutes): The animated short that started it all is, as far as I'm concerned, much better than its feature film incarnation. Granted, the characters never speak and the world in which they live is smaller in scope, but I found their simple adventure to be far more captivating. Optional commentary with Acker and co-animator Joe Ksander is available as well.
• The Long and Short of It (HD, 16 minutes): An excellent behind-the-scenes featurette that traces 9's journey from animated short to feature film.
• On Tour with Shane Acker (HD, 6 minutes): A solid, albeit all-too-brief EPK in which Acker takes viewers on a whirlwind tour of the various production departments that had a hand in the final film.
• The Look of 9 (HD, 13 minutes): More satisfying and extensive, this engrossing featurette digs into the design, history, and tonal qualities of 9's post-apocalyptic world.
• Acting Out (HD, 5 minutes): Animation department team members discuss the expressive performances they were tasked with creating on screen.
• Deleted Scenes (SD, 7 minutes): The five deleted scenes in this collection are decent, but sadly comprised of animated storyboards, animatic sequences, and poorly edited voicework.
• BD-Live Functionality and News Ticker
• My Scenes Bookmarking

9 Blu-ray Movie, Overall Score and Recommendation 

9 may not be the be-all, end-all animated future dystopian masterpiece I had hoped for, but it is a decent, potentially stirring tale all the same. Just be prepared to give it a second go if your first viewing doesn't turn out so well. By contrast, Universal's Blu-ray release is far easier to evaluate. With a near-perfect video transfer, a near-perfect DTS-HD Master Audio track, and a near-perfect supplemental package, the disc comes... you guessed it, close to perfection. The Blu-ray edition of 9 falls just shy of must-own or blind-buy status -- be sure to see the film before committing any serious cash to a purchase -- but fans will be more than pleased with the results.